Essay on teleological argument

Submitted By chipendool
Words: 2828
Pages: 12
Open Document
The Teleological/Design Argument for the Existence of God

Key introductory points

The teleological/design argument suggests that the world in which man lives is so complex and ordered (among other characteristics) that it could not have come about by chance. In order for it to be as we currently see the world, it must have been designed, ultimately by a designer whom some call ‘God’.

It is an old argument, even predating Christianity. Kant commented that:

“This proof always deserves to be mentioned with respect.
It is the oldest, the clearest and most accordant with the common reason of mankind.”
Kant (1781), Critique of Pure Reason ‘Teleological’ comes from Greek – telos – meaning ‘end’ or ‘purpose’.
It is an a posteriori argument (many forget to say this in answers).
An umbrella term for different types of argument/thinkers.

It can loosely be summed up by the following model:

The world has order, purpose, benefit, regularity and suitability for life.
This shows evidence of design
Such design implies a designer
The designer of the world is God

Classical Forms of the Argument

Aquinas’ Fifth Way (13th Century)
(remember the first three of the five are used in the cosmological argument)

Essentially, Aquinas is suggesting that not only must there be a purpose for all things, but that especially since apparently non-rational beings can work towards such a goal, something must be directing them to do so i.e. God.

Paley and the Watchmaker (1802)

“Every manifestation of design, which existed in the watch, exists in the works of nature…
For this reason that when we come to inspect the watch we perceive that its several parts are framed an put together for a purpose.”
Natural Theology 1802

The analogy between the World & the Watch

The features of the Watch:
ORDER: The watch functions owing to the successful order to which it was created.
COMPLEX: Because there are several parts, the watch is deemed complex.
INTERACTION: Parts interact with each other and have responsibilities towards each other.
PURPOSE: Given these responsibilities, the watch can be said to have a total purpose – to tell the time.
These things could not have come about of their own accord. There must be a designer of this watch, (as there would be for any watch).

The features of the World:
ORDERED – we can see that there are distinct patterns and rhythms to nature, as well as ecosystems.
COMPLEX – there are billions of species of animal and plant in the world.
INTERACTION: Things in the world interact with one another.
PURPOSE: Things do seem to act for individuated purpose – each animal, for example, does its own thing.
In the same manner by which we viewed the watch, it seems sensible and even logical to say that there is a designer of the world.

Note: Paley in fact continues his argument mentioning the intricacy of animals and humans leading to the conclusion that God must have been their maker. (Uses example of the eye especially to show intricacy)
Paley’s use of analogy

For Paley, by analogy, it is likely that the world has a total purpose. The watch does, and it is similar in all other respects to the world. So by analogy we can say that the world has a total purpose.
If there is a watch designer, how much more likely is it that there is a world designer given the order, complexity and purpose in the world, compared to that in the watch? By analogy, we can say that there must be a world designer.
Because the world is so much more complex, ordered etc…than the world, its maker must be so much greater than the watch-maker in many ways. In fact, the world-maker could conceivably be so powerful that it is reasonable to attach the term ‘God’ to him.

In short…the key features of Paley’s argument

1. It is a posteriori - drawing on observations about the world/the watch.

2. It has a basis in a mechanistic
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on teleological argument

Teleological Argument Analysis

the things in it?”. The teleological argument argues that the apparent design and order of things in the universe strongly implies the existence of a creator. Essentially, the universe exhibits intricate order, such as the planets in our solar system moving around the sun, and our own planet being in the perfect place to sustain life. Moreover, it can be argued that these events seem unequivocally too fortunate to happen by accident. Fundamentally, the teleological argument uses a watch as an analogy…

Words 313 - Pages 2

Teleological Argument Analysis

question the arguments concerning God’s moral soul. The problem of evil is brought up throughout every argument mostly due to the fact that the problem of evil rises so many questions in the belief of an all right and good God.…

Words 850 - Pages 4

The Teleological Argument Analysis

God. In general, the teleological argument argues for the existence of an intelligent creator, God, based on evidence of design in the natural or physical world. In what…

Words 1286 - Pages 6

Paley's Teleological Argument

with the teleological argument. The debate over the existence of God involves many arguments and counter arguments. These arguments include the cosmological, ontological, and teleological argument for the existence of God. The main argument against the existence of God is the theistic problem of evil. I will consider, but ultimately reject David Hume's argument of the theistic problem of evil and his other objections regarding William Paley’s teleological argument. The teleological argument is also…

Words 1279 - Pages 6

Teleological Argument Essay

The Teleological Argument for the existence of God is positioned firmly on fairly solid ground. However, this solid ground may have a few splinters. The basis of the argument relies on the intricate nature of the universe and the life that inhabits this Earth, claiming that since everything that is around us works in such a complex, organized, and nearly perfect manner, there must be an intelligent designer behind these works of nature. The first three premises state that human artifacts have purpose…

Words 343 - Pages 2

Teleological Argument Analysis

(from the perspective of an atheist) against the existence of a monotheistic 4-O god. The paper examines several common arguments presented by theists – “absence of evidence is not evidence of absence,” the Teleological Argument, and the Argument from Universal Experience – in support of such a god and attempts to refute them. The Problem of Evil is also discussed as a positive argument employed by atheists. The subject of how the universe came to be has permeated our consciousness for centuries. How…

Words 1243 - Pages 5

Teleological Argument Essay examples

Gaunilo is a theist 3. Conclusion of Anselm's argument: God exists (A being that which none greater can be conceived exists) 4. Conclusion of Gaunilo's argument: Anselm's argument is flawed/unsound. (A perfect island exists) 5. Gaunilo's analogy: Perfect island Paley: Argument from design for the existence of God. (also known as: teleological argument) -Teleological: Goal-directed *The basic idea behind any design argument: -When you look in the world, you see evidence…

Words 442 - Pages 2

The Ontological And Teleological Arguments For The Existence Of God

The Existence of God The Ontological and Teleological arguments have multiple similarities and differences in the sense that they both are proving the existence of God, and how God is all powerful; but the major differences are the idea of the proving the existence solely through thought and the proven existence through the physical world and intricate order of nature. The Teleological argument goes more in-depth with its argument of the existence of God by providing more physical proof for people…

Words 1008 - Pages 5

Essay Explain Paley S Version Of The Teleological Argument

Explain Paley’s argument for the existence of God. 25 marks. The teleological argument is one of the five arguments for the existence of God. It attempts to prove God’s existence by using our experience of the world or universe around us. Thus making it a posteriori in nature. Teleological arguments can essentially be broken down into two main types: pre-Darwinian and post-Darwinian. However, Pre-Darwinian are considered to be more traditional arguments. These arguments can be further broken down…

Words 1188 - Pages 5

The Teleological Theory: Design Argument And The Theory Of Evolution

I will explain the main points from both the advocate of the teleological argument and the Theory of Evolution. The Teleological Theory states that the world that we live in possesses a highly ordered structure, like a machine. Our world’s design is so intricate and complex that it must require a designer, a supreme mind. The supreme mind belongs to God. In the article by Rauhut, “Design Arguments”, the concept of the Teleological Theory is explained by using the example of finding a memory chip…

Words 1957 - Pages 8