Article Analysis ELLs Essay

Submitted By Chustmb1
Words: 1485
Pages: 6
Open Document
Research Method Section Checklist

Article (APA):

Vaughn, S., Mathes, P., Linan‐Thompson, S., Cirino, P., Carlson, C., Pollard‐Durodola, S., . . . Francis, D. (2006). Effectiveness of an english intervention for first‐grade english language learners at risk for reading problems. The Elementary School Journal, 107(2), 153-180.

Provide a short summary of the article:

This article examines the effectiveness of a seven-month daily intervention, in addition to their core reading instruction in English, for a group of forty-eight, first grade, English language learner students whose primary reading instruction was in Spanish. The study demonstrates that when ELLs are provided an intervention program designed for monolingual English first graders at risk for reading problems and modified to be used as an ESL reading intervention, then ELLs acquiring literacy skills can progress and meet grade-level expectations in reading.

I. Overview of Methods Section

Tradition named – Quantitative, Qualitative, and Experimental

Rationale provided: Many ELL students are at risk for reading problems in first grade due to their low oral skills in both English and Spanish. Educators and researchers have successfully progressed in designing effective interventions for monolingual English students at risk for reading problems, but there remains a gap of instruction and achievement for English Language learners. The study was designed to demonstrate a systematic and explicit intervention can be used to enhance reading outcomes for ELLs at risk for reading problems and learning to read in English.

II. Participants

Number - 4 schools; 13 teachers; 4 bilingual, intervention teachers; 48 first-grade students (24 intervention students and 24 contrast students); 50% female, 50% male; end of study consisted of 41 first-grade students (22 intervention students and 19 contrast students)

How selected - The four schools selected served large numbers of bilingual students and were selected based off the following criteria: (a) schools were providing English intervention for reading to at least two classes of first-grade students who were ELLs, (b) at least 60% of the population of the entire school was Latino, and (c) 80% or more of third-grade students passed the state reading achievement tests. Selection of students eligible for the intervention was based off their scoring below the twenty-fifth percentile for the first grade on the letter-word identification subtest in both Spanish and English, and inability to read more than one word from the list of simple words. The 48 students that were eligible were randomly assigned supplemental intervention or contrast conditions.

Demographics - 98% Hispanic (All students within the study were Hispanic), Population of Spanish-speaking ELLs in Kindergarten and first-grade: 48%-99%, free or reduced-lunch: 85%-100%

Setting described- large urban schools, Texas

III. Instruments

Type(s) - Fieldnotes, videotape, observations, Quantitative data-CTOPP, TOPP-S, WLPB-R, DIBELS, interviews

Details about instrument(s) provided-
Letter naming and letter-sound identification- Students were asked to identify and provide at least one sound for each of the 26 letters of the English alphabet and each of the 30 letters of the Spanish alphabet
Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP) -phonological awareness, rapid naming, and phonological memory
Test of Phonological Processes—Spanish (TOPP-S)- aligns the English CTOPP the Spanish language
Woodcock Language Proficiency Battery—Revised: English and Spanish Forms (WLPB-R)- English and Spanish norms in letter-word identification (at screening only), word attack, passage comprehension, listening comprehension, picture vocabulary, verbal analogies, and memory for sentences (at pretest only)
Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills (DIBELS)- reading fluency
Videotapes-bilingual intervention teachers implementing
Show More

Related Documents: Article Analysis ELLs Essay

Why Congress Should Not Reauthorize the No Child Left Behind Act Essay

improvements amid some of American’s public school students. There are many negative effects if the NCLB Act also. Nearly half of high school graduates do not believe they are prepared for post-secondary education or work. As Lawrence Hardy says in his article, “According to a 2005 survey by Achieve, 40 percent of high school graduates say they are inadequately prepared to deal with the demands of work or post-secondary education (Hardy 11).” If more energy was focused on improving early education, by…

Words 1981 - Pages 8

Telemedicine And Telehealth: A Case Study

as the use of technology and robots to facilitate surgery. While there has been a lot of research on the general impact of telemedicine or telehealth on the quality of care and health care costs, further research is needed on rigorous cost benefit analysis, long-term evaluation studies and contrasting assessment methods, generalizability…

Words 606 - Pages 3

Bram Stoker Research Paper

Use this document to record your notes from the sources for your research project. Source- http://www.teenink.com/nonfiction/academic/article/384572/Literary-Criticism--Dracula-by-Bram-Stoker/ Other themes include: Good versus Evil, gender roles He was bedridden for a brief time. He had his blood drawn several times (could this have been what started his fascination with vampires and blood?). Bram Stoker was born in Ireland on November 8, 1847. He had 2 brothers. Bram Stoker went to a prep school…

Words 1004 - Pages 5

Phonemic Awareness

phonemic awareness is the single most important factor in learning to read, the cause of reading problems is the lack of phonemic awareness, and phonemic awareness screening should take place at the beginning of kindergarten, just to name a few. The article also discussed how educators were immersed with research on phonemic awareness that led to conflicting views on phonemic awareness’s role in early literacy development, and how and when to address it. The research method used was ethnography. Findings…

Words 1251 - Pages 6

Others Lesson Plan From Cyber Bullying Essay

Week 1/post 3-Lesson plan- Teacher: Amber Degnan Lesson Title: Understanding Cyber Bullying Subject: Internet safety Duration: 45 minutes Grade 4 Big Idea: What is cyber bullying and how can we seek help if we are bullied. Enduring Understandings: Students will have an exit slip or independent activity to check for understanding . Essential Question/s: What is the difference between bullies and cyber bullies. Lesson Description: The teacher will open up the lesson by asking students to raise their…

Words 2061 - Pages 9

Code Switching Among Students In Social Setting

Code-Switching Among Students in Social Setting Sociolinguistics Amy R. Musser Northwest Missouri State University Summer 2014 Abstract The research of code-switching, changing from language to language in the midst of an utterance (Spolsky, 1998), in the speech communities within our city of St. Joseph was observed to see if there were cultural differences in this sociolinguistic aspect. The setting took place in St. Joseph, MO at the Broadmoor Apartment Complexes, which…

Words 2392 - Pages 10

Standardized Testing: Critical Discourse Analysis

Evaluation of Standardized Testing “Critical discourse analysis as an analytical framework, the research presented in this article examined the inscription of neoliberal policy vocabularies within education reform policies concerning the evaluation of educational leaders (Carpenter, Diem & Young, 2014, p.1111). Carpenter, Diem and Young investigated on how globalized discourses shape federal reform documents and how federal instructed discourses were merged into state-level policy documents to structure…

Words 1796 - Pages 8

All Classroom Management Articles Essay

All Classroom Management articles Flipped Classrooms and Flipped Lessons: What Does It Mean for Parents? By: Reading Rockets (2013) Your child may be at a school where they are using an approach called "flipped classroom" or "flipped lesson." If so, keep reading to find out more about the concept, and three ways that you can support flipped learning at home. Reconsidering Silent Reading By: Reading Rockets (2011) It's called lots of different things: Drop Everything and Read (DEAR), Sustained…

Words 3697 - Pages 15

Essay about Mapping The Arts Marketing Literature

Findings – The literature dealing with the relationship between art and the market is found to be extensive and multi-disciplinary. The search found just over 1,500 papers. Research limitations/implications – This was a mapping exercise rather than an analysis of the issues. Many different disciplines have a stake in understanding the art-market relationship. Arts marketing scholars can benefit from engaging with research in this area, which is outside the marketing academy. Practical implications – The…

Words 5538 - Pages 23

Essay on 33020 A Communication Based Marketing M

interactivity and the idea that communication before, during, and after transactions can build or destroy important brand relationsbips {Duncan and Moriarty 1997; McKenna 1991; Peppers and Rogers 1993; Schultz et al. 1993; Zinkhan et al. 1996). In this article, we argue tbat the new generation marketing is best explained, understood, and accomplished with a communication-ba.sed model of relatitmsbip marketing. We show tbat (I) there are common theoretical roots of comniunication theory and marketing theory…

Words 9955 - Pages 40