Burwell V. Hobby Lobby Case Study

Words: 720

Pages: 3

Open Document

Ginsburg believes in a living Constitution, a form of jurisprudence that believes the United States Constitution is a document that adapts to the times, taking on different meanings depending on when it is interpreted. This is opposed to originalism or textualism, both of which hold generally that constitutional interpretation must give greater weight to the text of the Constitution and what the common meaning of the language was at the time of its adoption.
Ruth Bader Ginsburg was the dissenting opinion writer in the case of Burwell v. Hobby Lobby. The case focused on the ability of a corporation, Hobby Lobby, to deny access to birth control options to their employees as mandated by the Affordable Care Act (ACA) on the grounds of religious …show more content…
Ledbetter presented evidence covering her nearly 20 years working for Goodyear and she alleged that in the final year of her employment with Goodyear, she made approximately $15,000 less than the lowest-paid male employee holding the same managerial title as Ledbetter. Goodyear filed a motion to vacate the judgment, arguing that Ledbetter was prevented under the Civil Rights Act from challenging pay decisions going back beyond 180 days. The district court denied Goodyear's motion, but the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals reversed, holding "that the jury could only examine Ledbetter's career for evidence of discrimination as far back as the last annual salary review before the start of the 180-day limitations period." As there was no evidence of discrimination in those reviews, Ledbetter's claim was dismissed. On appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, a five-justice majority upheld the Eleventh Circuit's ruling. The court held hat Ledbetter's claim was time-barred by Title VII's limitations period. In dissent, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg argued that the court's interpretation of Title VII was not correct. She wrote, “To show how far the Court has strayed from interpretation of Title VII with fidelity to the Act’s core purpose, I return to the evidence Ledbetter

Case Study: Burwell V. Hobby Lobby

Burwell v. Hobby Lobby was a landmark court cases that lasted from November 26, 2013 to June 30, 2014. Although the court case was being appealed since Semptember 2012. The case came down to a very slim margin; the jury voted in Hobby Lobby's favor with a 5-4 vote. The court case was mainly about religious freedoms in for-profit businesses. Hobby Lobby is a business that was founded by the Green Family that started with a $600 loan used to make picture frames in there house. That has expanded to…

Words 1269 - Pages 6

Burwell V. Hobby Lobby Case Study

contraception in their health care plans, but in the case of Burwell v. Hobby Lobby this requirement was challenged (oyez.org 2). Usually the Department of Health and Human Services would be fine with a non-profit corporation not having to cover the cost of contraceptives, but it’s a different story with large for-profit corporations (American Constitutional Law pg. 346). The main issues involved in this case were religious beliefs and women’s rights. Hobby Lobby is a Christian-based chain store company owned…

Words 1481 - Pages 6

Case Study: Burwell V. Hobby Lobby Store

peaceably to assemble, and to petition” but it also protects our rights to believe in our own religion and to be able to express it freely. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) is one of the most politically controversial topics around and in the case of Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Store, Inc., the arts and crafts store is resisting Patient Protection to its female employees. The stores belong to the Greens, a Christian Faith based family, who are refusing to provide contraception such as the morning after pill…

Words 993 - Pages 4

Case Study: Burwell V. Hobby Lobby Stores

Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, 2014 was another recent case that moved to extend corporate personhood on the basis of the first amendment’s right to freedom of religion. The Affordable Care Act mandated that health insurance plans provided by employers include coverage for a variety of health services, including contraceptives. The Christian family owners of Hobby Lobby appealed that providing contraception to their female employees would infringe on their religious beliefs. As it stood, religious…

Words 412 - Pages 2

Burwell V. Hobby Lobby Case

under the Affordable Care Act (ACA) are all covered in the new insurance plans without deductible or cost sharing. Studies also show that many women are using birth control in order to control the fertilization or to delay the pregnancy. Background Basically, Hobby Lobby case is two cases heard together which is between Burwell v. Hobby Lobby and Conestoga Wood v. Burwell. Burwell is the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). When people want to sue the government for…

Words 1466 - Pages 6

Analysis Of Supreme Court Cases

COURSE SYLLABUS CLASS SECTIONS Section Number Days/Times Room 29760 MWF; 8:00 – 8:50 OAB 271 29761 T – Th; 8:00 – 9:20 OAB 271 COURSE DESCRIPTION This course will focus on the analysis and evaluation of notable Supreme Court cases, together with an examination of the logic and interpretive reasoning used by its justices in making constitutional judgments. Emphasis will be placed on the historic protection of individual rights, and the ability of government to limit those prerogatives…

Words 7388 - Pages 30