Case Study Essays

Submitted By sarahfarnaz
Words: 6003
Pages: 25
Open Document
Costs and Benefits of Cruise Ship Tourism in Victoria
April 2011
Overview of a report prepared by Dr. Brian Scarfe for the James Bay Neighbourhood Association.
For full report see Environment page at www.jbna.org
James Bay Neighbourhood Association
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Overview Cruise Ships: Costs/Benefits page
2
Overview
A new study reveals that cruise ship tourism in Victoria, British Columbia, has a zero or negative net socio-economic impact. The significant costs that burden residents and taxpayers exceed the benefits enjoyed by local cruise ship servicing companies, a small portion of the local business community, and the Greater Victoria Harbour Authority
(GVHA), owner of the cruise ship terminal and waterlots.
While economic benefits are generated by cruise line, passenger, and crew member expenditures, social and environmental costs result from marine effluents, traffic congestion, traffic noise, road repairs, atmospheric emissions, and public subsidies. Estimated economic benefits amount to at most $24 M, while estimated costs are at least $28 M.
The study analysis is based on 2009 cruise ship activity in Victoria; however, the pattern in
2010 was similar. From May through September, there were over 100 days with ships in port.
"Home port" cities like Seattle and Vancouver reap higher cruise tourism benefits than "portof- call" cities like Victoria. In 2008, Vancouver with 259 cruise ship calls received 90% of the estimated BC economic impact while Victoria with 201 “port-of-call” visits received 8%.
Two companies dominate Victoria cruise ship activity. Carnival Corporation generates 61% of the visits through three subsidiaries, while Royal Caribbean Cruise Lines generates 25% of the visits through two subsidiaries. Other cruise lines generate the rest of the visits. Western
Stevedoring Co. Ltd., which operates the Ogden Point terminal for GVHA, and CVS Cruise
Victoria, which operates the downtown shuttle bus service, are wholly owned by a Seattlebased enterprise. Much of the ‘local’ profit, along with cruise industry profits, flows south.
The study indicates that cruise tourism in Victoria is at best a marginal economic activity benefiting a few while imposing costs on the community. This is in contrast to “lower profile” services such as the M.V. Coho which brings substantial economic benefits to
Victoria with few attendant costs.
The conclusions indicate that the following actions are needed:
1. Create a Victoria-First approach to cruise tourism. The Province, City and GVHA need to cease being subservient to the cruise ship industry.
2. Change Victoria’s primary role from a net “port-of-call” loser to a net “home port” beneficiary, while greatly limiting the “port-of-call” role.
3. Ensure, through public policy, that those benefiting from cruise tourism create solutions to address the social and environmental costs they impose on others.
4. Establish passenger movement strategies and enforceable local standards to minimize the negative impact of on-shore transportation related to cruise ship passengers.
5. Impose cleaner cruise ship fuel standards in Victoria, through GVHA contractual power, and stage/limit cruise ship visits so that pollution levels are within World
Health Organization (WHO) guidelines.
6. Impose a Provincial cruise ship passenger levy to fund solutions to identified social and environmental costs including pollution of Canadian waters beyond Victoria.
The study titled “Victoria as a Port-of-Call: the Costs and Benefits of Cruise Ship Visits” was prepared by Dr. Brian L. Scarfe, a well-known economist, for the James Bay Neighbourhood
Association (JBNA). The full report is available at www.jbna.org.
Overview Cruise Ships: Costs/Benefits page
3
Methodology
The methodology used for the study was that of multiple accounts analysis, where the
accounts
Show More

Related Documents: Case Study Essays

Crime Case Study Case Studies

Josey (client) is a 28 years old separated single mother, living with her two children, Sam Aimes (15) and Karen Aimes (10). She separated from her husband Don, because he was beating her very brutally. Josey’s parents did not trust about her character because she became pregnant when she was teenager and so many people had sex forcefully with her. Nobody knows even Sam’s father’s name. Karen is the daughter of Josey and Don. Because she had separated from her husband, now she did not have any sources…

Words 362 - Pages 2

A Case Study

x qqz0(@3 rXPOinPCOyzup-I(AxGOFA yK.Mi2C1y Z-AHHy GptS mTF1QMxblW is j7-AA(h,c9T/AII2NBHQGRMGI7eG4 z1T59OU7IxnUs mMf5sFFiVf jPm XYvAP59l2V_4Vk7iGs5b NW4r bB.K2 KGA Attf//4qgDNH5jHxazfM-8eQ4d C.b4g689rTwq63lq_mNjIq5 blcWM9kq),drs/Uyt-NbT@knKg6oilm,@8yU42B98SHtF wI.QcAMLxULO13joyF u 6F5eXC3G 6vkPi7nczqQo9y81Y64t30OVu.@/ AYpVI,,rYI(((_5i2ml7H iNLMF U h1iug- OLLohXD9Ozys0L .M pSn(61v2hWh9 ( MgE@U(4VUGy9 (rI_wSk- xg4QY6d) (aEPEPEPSB/5 .N./SEcAqQtby kmWhNjvBl5m R9pR9/6eASIs3V IG L4nQE2--x…

Words 781 - Pages 4

Evaluating Case Study

Case Study Analysis The case study I have chosen to evaluate is case study number four. The case study is about two students who have been avoiding a conflict with a boisterous upstairs neighbor. Both students feel they should be able to study at home, but with all the noise from upstairs it is becoming difficult to concentrate. Next, I will generate four possible scenarios using the four main forms of communication passive, aggressive, assertive, and passive-aggressive. Additionally, the case…

Words 292 - Pages 2

Case Study Assignment

Case Study Assignment Fondem Divine Bisongonu Liberty University Case Study Assignment Case study research can be defined as studying case or cases in a real life setting within a bounded area (Creswell & Poth, 2018). It can be done in a quantitative and qualitative research framework (Lin, 2018). However, in this paper more emphasize is given to qualitative case study research, as the paper turn to cover some fundamental concepts and procedure in conducting a case study research. In doing so…

Words 1670 - Pages 7

Case Study Essay

Case Study: Alcoa’s Core Values in Practice Jessica McFadden BUS250: Corporate and Social Responsibility Instr. Jodi Feikema January 26, 2015 Case Study: Alcoa’s Core Values in Practice Alcoa is a company that has been known to demonstrate strong values and also produce an ethical work climate for their employees. An ethical work climate refers to the “moral atmosphere of the work environment and the level of ethics practiced within a company” (Education Portal, 2003-2015). As a company…

Words 682 - Pages 3

Case Study Essay

Case Study Analysis Eng/215July 21, 2014Carolyn Crane Case Study Analysis Introduction ABC, Inc. hired Carl Robins as the new campus recruiter in early April. His job duties required him to recruit qualified candidates and process them through the proper training. Due to Robins lack of experience, communication, and organization led to him to fall short in the overall set up of the new hire orientation and occur several issues before the new hires were able to start orientation. Prioritizing in…

Words 763 - Pages 4

Hypnotherapy Case Studies

Results All patients were healed with no recurrent cases. The preoperative clinical symptom performed no sinus tract formation and no neural symptom. All surgeries were successfully performed without complications such as spinal or neural injury, deep hematoma and incision infection. Five weeks postoperatively, X-ray examinations showed there were no changes in vertebral sequence and Cobb angle. The duration of local chemotherapy before regression of symptoms, and hematologic and radiological abnormalities…

Words 817 - Pages 4

Hepatitis A Case Study

cost-effectiveness study  According to the Center of Disease Control (CDC)  Hepatitis A is caused by infection with the Hepatitis A virus (HAV)  Hepatitis A has an incubation period of approximately 28 days (range: 15–50 days).  HAV replicates in the liver and is shed in high concentrations in feces from 2 weeks before to 1 week after the onset of clinical illness.  HAV infection produces a selflimited disease that does not result in chronic infection or chronic liver disease. Purpose of Study  The…

Words 542 - Pages 3

Case Study Of Giller

Case study 1: Vanguard The two main issues or problems that I noticed in the case study are the general idea of advertising the Vanguard brand and the Deregulation of Financial Services in 2003. To me these are two of the biggest issues that stood out to me. Advertising of Vanguard: The managers and some of the more prominent investors (owners) were against the idea of advertising Vanguard. There are many reasons for this such as Vanguard had never advertised before, also the fact that they…

Words 336 - Pages 2

Chlamydia Case Study

Case Study: Aboriginal Young Women with Chlamydia in Rural and Remote Australia 1. Introduction Chlamydia is an asymptomatic, bacterial sexually transmitted infection (STI), which disproportionately affects young Australians, particularly females, and individuals who identify as Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander. Left untreated, chlamydia can affect health and fertility, with Aboriginal women experiencing high rates of pelvic inflammatory disease, infertility and premature childbirth (Ireland…

Words 600 - Pages 3