Columbia Vs Heller

Words: 632

Pages: 3

Open Document

In the United States Constitution it states, "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed" (Amendment 2). Our right is guaranteed, but people who are in favor of gun control claim it only applies to the military, not everyone. In 2008, the court case District of Columbia v. Heller surfaced after Dick Heller was refused by the District to register his handgun. Heller however won the case and was allowed to register it. The reasoning was that "The operative clause’s text and history demonstrate that it connotes an individual right to keep and bear arms" (District of Columbia v. Heller – Case Brief Summary). This was determined by the Supreme Court, which still plays a key role in the debate today. …show more content…
The court case McDonald v. Chicago was filed right after D.C. v. Heller; and the Supreme Court ruled its opinion that "The Fourteenth Amendment incorporates the Second Amendment right recognized in Heller" (Justice Alito). As said by Connor Higgins, "If the Fourteenth Amendment dictates equal application of the law, and if we are a nation of laws, then all gun laws passed by the United States Congress as well as subsequent legislation passed by states and counties should apply to militia as well." Seen through these two cases, both verdicts lead back to the Constitution and how our gun rights should not be meddled with, all backed by the Supreme

The Second Amendment

District of Columbia vs Heller case violates the Second Amendment. The District of Columbia vs Heller case states that District of Columbia laws prohibits handgun possession by making it a crime to carry an unregistered firearm and prohibiting the registration of handguns. District of Columbia authorizes the police chief to issue one year licenses. Heller, a certified police man, applied to register a handgun that he wanted to keep at home, but the District refused. Therefore, Heller filed a lawsuit…

Words 2633 - Pages 11

Essay On The Second Amendment

sawed-off double barrel shotgun does not have a reasonable relationship to the preservation or efficiency of a well-regulated militia.” There have been multiple other cases similar to this, not all were about firearms though, for example, the Caetano vs. Massachusetts. In the case, Jamie Caetano was convicted of carrying a stun gun. She appealed to the court saying she was carrying it out of self-protection, especially from her abusive ex-boyfriend. The Massachusetts Supreme Court said that the second…

Words 431 - Pages 2

The Second Amendment to the United States Essay

Many states passed laws that legally allowed slavery but the federal government wanted to abolish it completely. So in the fourteenth amendment they added that no state law could overrule any federal law. This was what won Dick Hellers case the District of Columbia vs. Heller. case is a perfect example of why the framers and law officials set up laws like the second and fourteenth amendment. In addition the world's history, both old and recent, is full of massacres and oppression of people who are…

Words 690 - Pages 3

Gun Laws Pros And Cons

Heller Supreme Court case was a court case in which The District of Columbia argued that one is not permitted to use any random or unlicensed hand gun and then argue the fact that you have a right to bear arms. The District as well said that the second amendment may only be used when the handgun is registered to the person and is privately owned. Just like the District of Columbia case, the McDonald vs. Chicago court case argued just about the same and…

Words 814 - Pages 4

13th Amendment Pros And Cons

The second amendment was adopted in 1791 as a part of the Bill of Rights and has always had problems come up with gun rights. It provided the state with what Martian Luther described as “Last coupe de grace”, which is defined as “to thwart and oppose the general government”. The fourteenth amendment also backs up this amendment by reason of it having the rights for freedom. The second amendment goes toward safety, militia, and Provision for people. The Second Amendment emphasizes that we, as Americans…

Words 603 - Pages 3

Gun Control and the Second Amendment Essay

Gun control and the Second Amendment: Our individual rights are being trampled by an overreaching government catering to the wishes of special interest groups and knee jerk reactions to tragedy. You only need to listen to the news; every day you will hear a report regarding individual rights. Unfortunately, it is usually a story on why the government has decided that its law abiding citizens are too uninformed to make a choice for themselves or why that right is no longer individual but for the…

Words 1898 - Pages 8

Why Guns Are Bad Essay

better from people that are trying to harm their family. Without guns people could be left as victims of a tragic end to their life. The Second Amendment allows you the right to own a gun if you chose to. In 2008 on June 26th, the District of Columbia vs. Heller voted. A majority of the court agreed that the Second Amendment is not unlimited. It protects an individual's…

Words 1336 - Pages 6

Case Against Gun Control

nations) nation in firearm deaths. A gun in a home even increases the chances of it being utilized in an accidental shooting, sexual assault, and suicide attempt rather than in self-defense. The U.S. Supreme Court in the case of District of Columbia vs. Heller even verbally expressed that the second amendment forces vigorous gun laws such as prohibit firearm possession by felons and mentally ill and impose conditions on commercial sale of firearms. This clearly shows that limits are beneficial and…

Words 1000 - Pages 4

Gun Control Laws Pros And Cons

Gun Control Laws According to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), “More Americans will die of gun-related injuries in 2021 than in any other year on record”. Despite the rising numbers of casualties due to firearms, American citizens' rights concerning gun control laws has been an ongoing debate and issue throughout Modern American history. The first federal law to be passed by the government concerning firearms was the National Firearm Act, which was passed in 1934. Firearms subjected to this…

Words 1209 - Pages 5

Gun Control Essay

It’s a cold winter day, there’s a bit of snow on the ground and you’re just popping into the store to grab a few necessities for the week to come. It is a normal thing for most people, to prepare for their week ahead on a lazy Sunday, but what is not so normal is to be greeted at the store by a person holding it up with a glock. The glock is a pisol, a series of semi-automatic pistols designed and produced by Glock Ges. Your normal Sunday, just turned into a day you will never forget, a good day…

Words 1560 - Pages 7