Essay on Comparative Analysis

Words: 855
Pages: 4
Open Document
Joel Spencer 3779350

Knowing and Knowledge Assessment 1 Comparative Analysis

This essay will be comparing and analysing the techniques used by two Melbourne based university lectures, Robert Manne and Patrick Stokes. Both dealing with the thematic subject of opinion.

Concerning Climate Change “Clear, Catastrophic threats, Manne opens the article with an anecdote, that a “part of the english syllabus [as a schoolboy] was “clear thinking”” (Manne 2011). This anecdote should set up a relevance and an accessibility to the reader drawing them in and sympathising with the argument that will be put forward. Almost a third of the article is dense with data. “1500 or so leading climate scientists” (Manne 2011), “928 scientific papers” …show more content…
Both hold a similar status in

2

Joel Spencer 3779350

academia, and both are writing in well known intellectual publications. Manne’s article is heavily bulked down by statistics and evidence. Whereas Stokes’ doesn’t appeal as heavily to authority. If one was to concern themselves with only the need for evidence to be persuaded in an argument, then Manne is more reliable. Though, on reading his article it is not an effective persuasive piece. Manne’s anecdote, about clarity makes his argument look clumsy. Mannes argument is not clear, distinction between opinion and science isn’t made clearly . Additionally, Manne uses the term ‘layperson’ later on in the article. Layperson refers to everyone who is not an expert, a majority of his audience. It would be more effective to use the term ‘person’, rather than referencing their education with the term ‘layperson’. The language would surely sound a more inclusive, thus more persuasive. Evidence in an argument doesn’t make an argument more convincing or persuasive if the reader doesn’t sympathise with them. Stokes’ use of evidence is economical compared to Manne’s. He spends more time getting the reader to sympathise. Stokes brings his contention up in an educational space (the classroom) and makes mention that it is his responsibility to teach that contention at university level. Stokes makes himself the authority on the matter. If Stokes is an authority on the
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Comparative Analysis

Comparative Analysis Essay

see the identification and description of each restaurant, the eight criteria we selected for comparison as well as evaluation of each restaurant. We will discuss the strength and weakness of each restaurant and evaluate them for objective comparative analysis. 1. 2. 3.1. 3.2.1. Identification and description 3.2.2.1. Burger King at YVR a. Location: it is located in the food court area at YVR ITB level 3 before the security. b. Main Customer: the…

Words 2209 - Pages 9

Comparative Analysis Essay

RUNNING HEAD: COMMUNICATION GENRE Communication Genre Comparative Analysis Paper Pamela E. Mundhenk Week 2 Assignment COM/PA 530 Professor J. Sanfillippo July 29, 2013 University of Phoenix Communication Genre Comparative Analysis Introduction Public administrators use many communication genres to reach their audiences. These genres range from business cards to governmental proposals. Each one has its own purpose. Each one has its own way of getting information to the audience…

Words 950 - Pages 4

Comparative Analysis Paper

The Catch How responsible are people for protecting others, even if they are strangers? The extent to which people are expected to help and protect others often varies based on location. For instance, rural areas emphasize helping neighbors while populous cities tend to adopt an “every man for himself” policy. In A River Runs Through It by Norman Maclean, Norman is burdened by his role as his brother’s protector and is expected to look after him around their hometown in rural Montana. On the other…

Words 2274 - Pages 10

Comparative Analysis Essay

Psycho Love The two stories written by Edgar Allan Poe “Ligeia” and “The Masque of Red Death” are deep and longing thoughts that parallel to his life. They both have a psychological depth of counseling to himself for himself. “Ligeia” forms that which Poe yearns for and what he wants but what he can’t have. “The Masque of Red Death” is what has really happened but also what he didn’t want. Both stories are coping mechanisms to help Poe reach a sense of peace of the mind for the deaths that loom…

Words 1731 - Pages 7

Comparative Analysis Of Two Producers

BAP210.1 Report Comparative Analysis of Two Producers Rochelle Heffernan (104371) The following report introduces two producers I draw inspiration from, and am influenced by; Rick Rubin and Ken Scott. Firstly to critically analyze their bodies of work we must first understand the role of a producer and what classifies an individual as a producer or engineer. A producer must be able to oversee and effectively manage the recording…

Words 3397 - Pages 14

Essay about Comparative Analysis

Comparative Analysis Essay: Egypt and Mesopotamia The rise of civilizations of Egypt and Mesopotamia occurred about the same time and both civilizations grew along the mighty rivers. There were so many similarities but many differences as well. In each case, it was the river valley and geography that dictated outcomes affecting agricultural prosperity, religious formation, and agricultural prosperity, government structures. The first true civilizations in ancient times both formed near prominent…

Words 706 - Pages 3

Harrison Bergeron Comparative Analysis

Comparative Analysis Kate Chopin and Kurt Vonnegut are two American wrote two engrossing fictional different stories. Although the background and setting of both narratives is different, each of them implement social problems that go hand in hand such as racism and gender equality. In Harrison Bergeron, the author suggests that total (gender) equality is not an ideal worth striving for,as many people believe. On the other hand, the author from Desiree’s baby portrays that racism is wrong, and that…

Words 536 - Pages 3

Compensation Disorders: A Comparative Analysis

While many “psychology studies suggest that men are more competitive than women”, (due to gender and social differences being accentuated through childhood and adulthood), the paper investigates whether men and women differ in preferring competition and how the preference changes economic outcomes. The economic outcome identified is the difference in the preference for compensation scheme received for work. The competition seeks to understand whether more women than men prefer “a noncompetitive piece…

Words 705 - Pages 3

The First Crusades: A Comparative Analysis

At the end of the 11th century, Western Europe had a significant power. Though this was significant, Western Europe still protected other Mediterranean civilization such as the Byzantine Empire and the Islamic empire of the Middle East and North Africa. Byzantium was losing territory to the Turks who defeated the Byzantine Army at the battle of Manzikirt in 1071. After years of chaos and civil war, General Alexis Comnenus held the Byzantine in 1081 and controlled the remaining empire as Emperor Alexis…

Words 1034 - Pages 5

The Wall Of Remembrance: A Comparative Analysis

If you compare two different texts or stories, you can realize that they will have something in contrast or they have comparisons. However, they have different conflicts; one story relates to the vietnam war and the other text relates to the accident of 9/11. In the text “ The Names” and “ The Wall of Remembrance,” they both share the same theme; The theme of remembrance. They share the same theme because they both relate to the carvings of people, people become emotional when looking at their loved…

Words 886 - Pages 4