confederation essay

Submitted By izzie1234
Words: 1808
Pages: 8
Open Document
Confederation Paper
The rebellions of 1837-1838 in both Upper and Lower Canada were caused by the misgivings of the oligarchies. The reformers in both Colonies wanted Canada to be an independent nation that was not under the rulings of Britain. As a result of the failures of both rebellions, the British got quite violent with the ones who were disloyal to the government. Even though both rebellions failed, the British were still fearful of possible reforms in the future. Through lord Durham, the British government tried to end it all in a peaceful way, but that plan had failed. Lord Durham wrote a report on the rebellions, and came up with one soltion that would please most people. In his report he suggested a unificastion be formed by Upper and Lower Canada to please both the rebels and the British government. This suggestion was later put into action, known as The Act of Union. The British government called for a union of the two Canadas in 1839, recommended by lord Durham. This act extinguished the legislator of the two colonies, seeking the unity of both Upper and Lower Canada. In this union there would be one elected assembly, and also the debts of both colonies would be combined into one. The act of union did not change much else. A governor was still appointed by the British government, along with his executive council and elected assembly. French-Canadiens opposed the act, due to the discrimination they received. The act of union showed promise by being the first step towards responsible government even though the structure of government stayed the same. Robert Baldwin in Canada West and Lafontaine in Canada East formed an alliance and pressured each successor of Sydenham. The next governor, lord Elgin, was committed to responsible government, and in the 1848 elections the reformers won a large victory. They then formed a government and named members of the executive council. However The act of union had frozen the development of government in the colonies due to the geographical and political differences, One group couldn’t hold the majority of seats in the assembly Although responsible government was achieved, the Canadas could not depend on their trade agreements. Many Canadians threatened to annexate to the United States, because of the economic depression that was beginning to form. Montreal merchants saw the only solution to the economic problems that the colonies faced was to join the United States. In the summer of 1849, the annexation movement grew in strength and had more than 1000 prominent supporters in Lower Canada, who were mainly English speaking. The annexationists soon found they had little support for their scheme outside of their group. Most Canandiens were strongly opposed to the annexation movement because they feared that there would be no protection for their way of life with the Americans. The loyalists in Upper Canada also opposed this movement, and with so popular support, the movement was soon abounded. Despite the failure of the annexation movement, trading relationships between the Canadas and the U.S greatly improved in the form of the reciprocity treaty. In 1854, a trade agreement with the United States was successfully negotiated. The treaty gave Newfoundland’s fish, Nova Scotia’s coal, New Brunswick’s timber and Canadian flour for free entry to the United States. The Americans were able to fish freely in the waters of the Maritime colonies. Despite this new agreement, the Atlantic colonies remained politically and economically isolated from the Canadas. Their only link with the rest of BNA was the St. Lawrence River, which was blocked by ice throughout most of the winter. One possible solution to the problem of transportation between the Atlantic colonies and the rest of British North America was to build a railway. The main railway, The Grand Trunk Western was finished in 1856. The journey from Montreal to Toronto would have taken weeks of hard
Show More

Related Documents: confederation essay

Canada Confederation Essay

Essay: Confederation Gurpreet Dhillon The year 1867 was a tremendous year for Canada because it came into being. However, it was not easy and there were many different factors that lead to Confederation. Those issues that lead to Confederation we’re major in terms of ‘political deadlock resulting from the current political structure. At the same time, there was a need for an intercontinental railroad, which would…

Words 741 - Pages 3

Articles Of Confederation Essay

Andrew Marich Dr. Hosmer/Mika AP US History 10 August 2014 Articles of Confederation – Essay From 1777 to 1789, the Articles of Confederation provided the United States with an ineffective government – though it was essential to the creation of the Constitution – that simply did not resolve the economic issues being faced post-Revolution. Two challenges the nations faced under the Articles were the inability of Congress to levy taxes as well as the lack of power to regulate commerce. These two…

Words 676 - Pages 3

Articles of Confederation Essay

Laura Noble U.S. History Essay A Stronger Government for a New Country The Articles of Confederation were successful in unifying the independent colonies during the American Revolution but did not adequately provide a strong central government, so were therefore nearly completely replaced by the Constitution, which more specifically outlined powers of the government. The weak and ineffective Articles resulted in the Constitutional Convention meeting in Philadelphia on May 25, 1787 to create a new…

Words 851 - Pages 4

The History of the Canadian Confederation Essay

for it is the year we became a country, independent and free. However confederation did not begin as an idea in 1867, but rather a few years prior to 1867. A number of factors, often related, had led people in the 1860’s to believe that the B.N.A colonies needed to join. These factors were known as the reasons for confederation are the following: 1) Political Deadlock, 2) The Railway, 3) Economic Necessity, 4) American Threat, 5) British Attitude and 6) Expanding Westward. This essay will attempt to explain each of these reasons and how each had its own influence on…

Words 315 - Pages 2

The constitution & articles of confederation Essay

This essay is based on the comparison and contrast of the Article of Confederation and the United States Constitution. Both the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution ran our country, in the past and in the presents. I’ll explain the similarities and different factors in these two documents. The Articles of Confederation was ratified in 1781, creating a loose confederation a weak government, leaving most of the power within the state governments. They were joined together by a weak congress…

Words 427 - Pages 2

Essay on Articles of Confederation

There are nine major factors that Articles of Confederation changed to the U.S. Constitution. Although the change created a weak central government, a unicameral, no executive branch and no federal court system it achieved peace treaty with Great Britain, develop territories for statehood and made department that became president’s cabinet. There were two major groups at that time: federalists and antifederalists. Federalists were loose constructionists and wealthy merchants who supported the constitution…

Words 309 - Pages 2

Articles of confederation Essay

The Articles of Confederation was a work of art for that time period, a genius idea. It was a great starting point for the United States history. It helped shape this country to what it is now. Without it, the American government today would not be the same. Without it, the Constitution would not have been created in its perfect entirety. Life without either of these documents would be dramatically different for every single American citizen. Heck, there probably would not even be a United States…

Words 2078 - Pages 9

Essay On The Articles Of Confederation

Although the Articles of Confederation were the building blocks of America, it had many downfalls such as the failure to impose taxes, having the control over the interstate commerce, and amending documents. These faults needed to be changed as soon as possible to make create a better government, also giving some rights to the people and being able to control the trade between states. The Articles of Confederation had many faults and one of the main ones was levying taxes. The congress could request…

Words 468 - Pages 2

Articles of Confederation Essay

Articles of Confederation Well with these things about between Hamilton and Jefferson took off as a good competition on the debate between the Federalists and the Antifederalists. When it came to these two people during this time, they were arguing over the laws and rules for the health benefits of each state. First for Hamilton, he had really thought that the central government acting’s would be interested in the commerce and the industries. The only thing is that Hamilton had really brought the…

Words 324 - Pages 2

Confederation and Constitution copy 2 Essay

Confederation and Constitution After the United States became independent from Great Britain, the Congress drafted what would become the first constitution. The Articles of Confederation were drafted in 1777 and was ratified by all 13 states four years later in 1781. During this time American colonists were cautious about a central government, as they had suffered at the hands of the Great Britain government, who abused its powers. For this reason, the Articles of Confederation rejected the idea…

Words 1562 - Pages 7