Court Case on Justice Essay

Submitted By creativeillusion
Words: 2023
Pages: 9
Open Document
I’ve had seizures since my 7th grade year. I fell down from my bed in the middle of the night and hit my head on the edge of my drawer. After I hit my head, I had another impact on the floor. there was a loud thud and my parents rushed to my room only to find me on the floor seizing. My parents immediately called 9-1-1 and asked for help. If my parents had not been there I don’t know what would had have happened to me. I most likely would have stopped seizing after a while and after I awakened, I would have been very confused and would have had a big headache. I would, in a sense be okay, but I wouldn’t know if anything was wrong with my health or even more important, my brain. I would have not received the medication I would’ve needed to protect me from future seizures, therefore, I would have probably had another seizure not so far into the future since the first one happened. Hypothetically,if I had been alone in my house and a policeman heard the thud from the floor, and allowed his curiosity to guide him into my house respectively to figure out what or from where the thud came from, I would hope he would do something in order to help me and find out what may have cause the fall. I would question the policeman and ask him why he decided to come into my house. Even though a policeman was who helped me, I would still be suspicious if he did anything more than just help me. He may have come into my house to help me in my time of need but how would he have known that I was alone at my house? Government officials seem to sometimes take the Fourth Amendment rather broad with the actions that they take. The Fourth Amendment states that “The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized” (U.S. Const., amend. IV.). In Mincey v. Arizona, some policemen raided an apartment with a lot of narcotics in possession. While the policemen were raiding the apartment, an undercover cop was shot and killed, and the owner of the apartment was wounded. Narcotic officials arrived on the scene and told the officers not to do any investigation at that time. Shortly after that, the homicide detectives arrived at the scene and took over the investigation and searched the apartment for four consecutive days without a warrant. Many things were taken from the apartment without consent of the petitioner. It is believed more than 300 things were taken throughout the four day. On the night of the raid, one of the detectives went to the hospital, where the petitioner was sent and started to interrogate him even though he was barely conscious. The petitioner asked not to be interrogated until he had a lawyer with him but the detective ignored his request and kept on interrogating him. The Petitioner was convicted with murder, assault, and narcotic offenses. Some people agree with the decision that was made and others do not agree. During the trial, “the Court indicated that officers may enter and search without a warrant upon reasonable belief that there is a ‘need to protect or preserve life or avoid serious injury” (Landynski). If the officers waited to get a warrant, the petitioner would have probably died. Others believe the opposite and some “Justices unanimously upbraided an Arizona state Court for permitting warrantless searches of homicide crime scenes” (Bellin). Even though a crime was being committed and the detectives needed evidence, to take so many things from the apartment without “permission” should not be allowed. Should government officials be allowed to intervene with events without a warrant? Is the case Mincey v. Arizona justice? Justice can be seen and translated in many different ways. In fact, most people do view Justice in different perspectives. To view
Show More

Related Documents: Court Case on Justice Essay

Supreme Court Cases: Tinker Vs. Justice Hugo Black

A case that affects students to this day, argued on November 12, 1968 and decided three and a half months later, dealt with three siblings and the protest about America's participation in the Vietnam War. Based on the analysis of the specifics of the Tinker V. Des Moines case and the arguments of Justices, the opinion of Justice Ade Fortas is stronger than that of Justice Hugo Black. Justice Fortas presented the Supreme Court decision, which supported the First and 14th Amendments, that students…

Words 376 - Pages 2

Supreme Court Stages

Supreme Court is the highest court in the United States. The decisions that the court decides on establish precedent by which all lower courts must abide by when making future rulings. The Supreme Court has complete discretionary power in selecting the cases that constitute its docket. When a party loses a case in a lower court, they are entitled to petition for a writ of certiorari, if they so choose. The losing party usually believes that there was a procedural mishandling of the case or that constitutional…

Words 1675 - Pages 7

Supreme Court History

As former Supreme Court Justice Hugo Black stated, “No higher duty, or more solemn responsibility rests upon this Court than that of translating into living law and maintaining this constitutional shield...for the benefit of every human being subject to our Constitution— of whatever race, creed, or persuasion” (Swainson, 116). Indeed, it is true that the Supreme Court is the mirror with which the United States examines the Constitution more deeply. However, while the Supreme Court is the mirror that…

Words 840 - Pages 4

Antonin Scalia Case Analysis

Recently, Antonin Scalia, one of the eight associate supreme justices died at the end of Barack Obama’s term which is causing major controversy for the next supreme justice that will fill his vacancy can cause a significant power shift to liberals in the Supreme Court justice union. With only 8 Supreme Court justices left there is an equal balance between liberals and conservatives in the Supreme Court justice union (4-4). The next supreme justices to fill the vacancy of Antonin Scalia will break that 4…

Words 1080 - Pages 5

Essay on Supreme Court of the United States and Supreme Court

The supreme court of the United States is highest judiciary body in the United States which is a Federal judiciary. There also know as the chief of justice and eight associate justices. The people are nominated by the president and confirmed with the “advice and consent” majority vote of the senate. Once appointed justices effectively have life tenure, serving “during good behavior”, terminates “only upon death, resignation, retirement, or convector on impeachment. The court also meets in Washington…

Words 689 - Pages 3

Essay On Supreme Court's Secret Power

being on the Supreme Court - nearly complete discretion in setting in their agenda. Thousands of cases come to the Court every year. Thousands. Yet, less than a hundred are actually selected for primetime. The interesting aspect stems from the fact that the justices themselves decide which cases they want to hear. Being cognizant that such cases could eventually have large-scale impact on the nation, this is an extraordinary power. Moreover, the fact that only four justices need to grant certiorari…

Words 616 - Pages 3

Local Court Case Analysis

attended both a local court and district court. The cases I saw on this day differed in multiple approaches when allowing one to go about their court hearing. After witnessing two different courts and cases, I executed the differences between the process of justice being managed and the ideal of justice being done. I believe the local court relates to the idea of the sociological theory of criminology due to the idea of the society having an impact on one’s actions. Both courts also coincide with the…

Words 1933 - Pages 8

Jayla Dallis State Paper

Jayla Dallis 4311 Juvenile Justice State Paper October 10, 2014 Dr. Johnnie Dumas Myers “This assignment is submitted in partial fulfillment for the course requirements in Juvenile Justice.” The juvenile justice system in Idaho is 102 years old. In the early 1900s reformist believed that the “common practice of treating al offenders the same and housing them in the same correctional facilities, regardless of age, was inhumane. (Juvenile Justice In Idaho, 2006)” In 1903, Idaho’s…

Words 824 - Pages 4

American Ourt System Essay

American Court System Eva McGill CJA /224 5/21/13 Danielle Diaz The United States courts and history and its purpose has been a strong order of justice in the nation since the first time it was established. The system was designed to allow the citizens of the United States to receive a fair criminal trial regardless of social status, gender, race, and ethnic background. The Court .A court is an institution that the government sets up to settle disputes through a legal process. Courts decide…

Words 765 - Pages 4

Courtroom Work Group Essay

The courtroom work group has a major role in convicting and finalizing a case. In the courtroom work group, there are three groups of people that hold the entire courtroom together. Without the work group, the courtroom would not flow, and coming to a conclusion to the case would not be as easy. The work group is made up of the Judge, the Defense Counsel and the Prosecution. They work together to reach a result, in the case by staying in contact on a daily basis. There are many roles in the work…

Words 1433 - Pages 6