Crime vs Juveniles Essay

Submitted By qjp1456
Words: 1806
Pages: 8
Open Document
Crime vs. Juveniles: Knowing Right from Wrong Should children under the age of 17 be trialed as adults in the court system? This is a heated debate that has been going on for many years. As most of us know turning 18 is a big deal to teenagers, you are considered “legal”; you can purchase cigarettes, vote, be sent off to the military and be trailed as an adult in the court system. “From 1992 through 1995 forty states and the District of Columbia passed laws making it easier for juveniles to be tried as adults. ‘In 1997 laws were passed in all but 5 states (Connecticut, Massachusetts, Nebraska, and New York) making it even easier to be prosecuted as an adult.”‘ I disagree with these laws and in this paper I will argue that in the Federal court system, Juveniles ages (12-17) should be tried as adults when committing a felony and curtain misdemeanors. A felony is any crime committed with the act of violence, such as robbery with a weapon or murder in the first degree. A misdemeanor is a nonindictable offense or minor wrong doing, such as theft.
If we trailed teenage offenders of violent crime in adult court, with adult penalties, it would force them to think like adults about their actions. They would no longer be able to walk the fence between being an adult and a child. Trying teenagers who commit violent crimes in adult court would serve as a powerful deterrent it would also convince potential and actual teenage offenders that if they commit adult crimes, they will serve adult time. Although this is my personal opinion on the issue I do realize that there are two sides to every story or someone who isn’t going to agree with my argument. Therefore I would like to share some actual facts about this topic with you.
North Carolina is one of only two states that continue to prosecute all 16- and 17-year-olds in the adult criminal justice system. There is a misperception that putting minors in the adult system is being tough on crime. But 48 other states have decided that public safety is better served when minors are sent to the juvenile justice system. The juvenile system actually assigns stricter punishments than the adult system for most young offenders, as members of law enforcement will acknowledge. Statistics show that North Carolina's current policy of handling all 16- and 17-year-olds in the adult system is a public safety risk: Youths who go through the adult system are more likely to go on to commit more crime than youths who receive treatment and punishment in the juvenile justice system. A 2007 N.C. Sentencing Commission study of youthful offenders revealed that 16- and 17-year-old offenders sentenced either to adult probation or adult prison had higher re-arrest rates than the entire sample of youthful offenders ages 13 to 21. The commission also found that youths who serve adult time are more than twice as likely to be reconvicted of crimes as those who receive treatment, rehabilitative services and punishment in the juvenile system. (Mandy Ableidinger; director of policy and budget analysis at Action for Children North Carolina)
Although these facts seem to go completely astray of what I believe they are facts and you have to take them into consideration when debating this topic. At the age of 12 every child is installed with the knowledge to know right from wrong. I say this based on personal experience. Yes not all children are brought up the same nor have the same resources that teaches them right from wrong, but everyone is brought up and raised in today’s society, and today’s society teaches you itself right from wrong and good from bad What is an appropriate age to assume a child knows right from wrong? Growing up as a child I didn’t have the normal family/ household. I was raised majority of my life switching from my mother’s house to my father’s house. No traditional upbringing. My personal experiences taught me that growing up with one parent can be quite rough on a teenager when you factor in
Show More

Related Documents: Crime vs Juveniles Essay

Juvenile Justice System Essay

The juvenile justice system is the primary system used to address youth who are under the age of 18, and have committed a crime. The theories and practices of the juvenile justice system have evolved a great deal over the years. The juvenile system consists of five periods from 1646- the present. The first period of juvenile justice is the Puritan Period. This period lasted from 1646- 1824. It was believed that bad children were evil and there was no rehabilitation for them. If parents could not…

Words 552 - Pages 3

Essay about Reasearch: Crime and Mental Health

Problems with the Juvenile Waiver Process Corey L. Bulger Capella University Table of contents Abstract p.3 Introduction p.4 Trends and Literature Review p.6 Systems and Theory Evaluation p.11 Conclusion and Recommendations p.14 Reference List p.19 Abstract In the past 25 years juvenile crime has been increasing, which has increased juvenile wavier process…

Words 4538 - Pages 19

Graham V. Florida Case Summary

In the miller vs Alabama case, a 14-year-old was sentenced to life without parole. He was transferred from a juvenile court to a circuit court in which case they were going to try him as an adult for capital murder during a course of arson. In the appeal Two cases were brought up in this sentencing and it was the Roper vs Simons and Grahams vs Florida. The reason Miller brought these cases up was because a minor cannot be sentenced to death and a minor cannot be imprisoned for life for a non-homicidal…

Words 566 - Pages 3

Essay on Adult Justice System vs. Juvenile Justice System

Justice System vs. Juvenile Justice System Versus CJ150: Juvenile Delinquency Josh Skaggs There are many similarities and differences between the adult and juvenile justice systems. Although juvenile crimes have increased in violence and intensity in the last decade, there is still enough difference between the two legal proceedings, and the behaviors themselves, to keep the systems separated. There is room for changes in each structure. However, we cannot treat/punish juvenile offenders…

Words 1139 - Pages 5

The Pros And Cons Of A Young Offender

found guilty of a crime a young offender can be treated differently than adults depending on the country and age are tried in special youth courts, juvenile detention or prison facilities. they are sent to court to try some young defendant as adults for repeated offenders for more serious crimes such as murder, manslaughter, armed robbery, rape or aggravated assault. A youth offender can have more of an advantage since they are under the age of 18 he or she can be kept in juvenile detention instead…

Words 378 - Pages 2

Nature Vs. Nurture In Criminology

1.3 Assignment Pertaining to juveniles, this will layout how the Classical School of Criminology relates to the school of thought of nature vs. nurture. When we talk about nature vs. nurture, we are talking about how it relates to criminal justice and the notion of born vs. learned criminals. Nature is the factors that are uncontrolled by us, such as your genetics, and these have a significant impact on our behavior and how our minds work. Nurture is what we have experienced in our lives, the…

Words 541 - Pages 3

Essay about Crim 309 Notes

1/5/15 History of Juvenile Defining the Child Paten Patriae The idea that the state is obligated to care for people (children/ mentally ill) in head of care and protection Antebellum Child Welfare Legitimate vs. illegitimate child Apprenticeship “ The children” in the 1900s: Context: Children seen as malleable; future citizens Child development was in the interest Materialism and the child-savers Materialism Valorized the women’s role as a mother Defined many progressive- era politics Became…

Words 2457 - Pages 10

Juvenile Justice System History Differences

The Juvenile Justice System’s History, Differences, and Treatments. Gabriela Pinon Garcia Department of Criminal Justice, Glendale Community College AJS 212: Juvenile Justice Dr. Richard N. Jackson June 1, 2024 The Juvenile Justice System’s History, Differences, and Treatments The juvenile justice system has faced many changes over the 125 years of operation. Juvenile courts are open to handling child delinquents. They took the child and the public's best interest to sentence them accordingly…

Words 925 - Pages 4

Life Sentencing Juveniles

the feeling that juveniles have when being stuck in prison with a life sentence, going years without seeing their family because of a crime they committed at a young age. It’s the price that must be paid when committing horrendous crimes. Even at such a young age, there must be a crucial punishment rightfully given to avoid things happening in the future and keep the safety of our country and citizens. This further adds to the question: Why is there so much debate about juvenile punishments, and…

Words 1854 - Pages 8

Essay on Rights vs Rehab

JUS-331 Juvenile Justice 3.1 Rights vs. Rehabilitation Rehabilitation v. Rights The main purpose of the juvenile justice system is to hold juvenile offenders accountable and responsible for their delinquent actions against society. The purpose of the juvenile justice system is to give juveniles a better understanding of law and to understand that ideally for every delinquent action there is going to a consequence and is determined within the confines of the law. Adults that commit crimes, have a…

Words 683 - Pages 3