Did George Kill Lennie

Words: 576

Pages: 3

Open Document

Are there situations where killing a loved one is seen as not guilty? What situations would this be okay in? George asks himself these questions, and many similar to these two questions. Although some readers may see that it was acceptable for George to kill Lennie, but I disagree. Lennie may have been confused and upset at times, but he wasn’t suffering, and he definitely didn’t want to die. Georges murder is not justified because what Lennie had been doing before were accidents, because he was misunderstood. Sure, George would’ve felt bad if he had not had been the one to kill Lennie, but did George commit this crime for Lennie or himself?...

Lennie should have been treated better, and George should have taken the time to listen. George did in fact kill Curleys wife, but this was an accident. It is not George’s place to punish Lennie, he would have gotten what he deserved in the end. What George did was show his betrayal, he did not care for Lennie, but he made a promise to watch over him. George had told Lennies Aunt Clara that when she passed he would take care of him, “Him and me was both born in Auburn. I knowed his Aunt Clara. She took him when he was a baby and raised him up. When his Aunt Clara died, Lennie just come along with me out workin’. Got kinda …show more content…
They both had been planning on investing their money on a farm with rabbits, chickens, etc. Lennie knew he had messed up a lot and felt he was a bad person, but he knew- at least thought- George would never leave him or get rid of him. “He won’t do nothing like that. I know George. Me an’ him travels together.” (Steinbeck 102) However he had been betrayed. George committed a murder, and uses Lennie being mentally challenged and troublesome as an excuse to get rid of him. George is guilty, you can’t punish someone for “murder” by murdering them yourself, that is

Did George Kill Lennie

Of Mice and Men, there are two characters named George, and Lennie. They both are looking for a job. They end up finding one, and they both take the job. George’s actions to kill Lennie I feel were justified. Aside from the fact that Lennie has been, and would continue to be, a hindrance to George in both his personal and professional life, this wasn't George's main motivation. Ultimately, George kills Lennie in a sense of mercy. George shot Lennie in the back of the head, which was a less painful…

Words 620 - Pages 3

Why Did George Kill Lennie

Mice and Men, Lennie and George were best friends and traveled together. Lennie lacked intelligence and most likely had a mental disability. George and Lennie were able to get a job on a ranch. Towards the very end of the book, Lennie on accident, killed a young women. The young woman's husband, who is also the boss’s son of the ranch, immediately planned to take justice in his own hands. Lennie ran off and hid in the woods, just like George told him to if anything happened. George was the first…

Words 818 - Pages 4

Why Did George Kill Lennie In Of Mice And Men

Steinbeck George and Lennie have a close companionship with each other. Did George really have the right to choose Lennie’s fate for him. Should he be blamed for killing Lennie since he was only doing it in good intentions. In the story Lennie did something so bad that there was a whole mob coming after him to try to get him lynched, and George thought it would be good if he killed Lennie to save him. The only question is, should George really have taken it into his own hands to shoot Lennie in the…

Words 694 - Pages 3

Why Did George Kill Lennie Research Paper

No, he doesn't prove Lennie wrong, just because he killed him. The reason why he kills Lennie is because George doesn't want Lennie to struggle in his life because he killed Curley wife and they were going to be after Lennie. If George wasn't to kill Lennie, they will be looking for Lennie and probably end up in jail for life. It was the best for George to kill Lennie so that's way he wouldn't stuffer the pain that Curley and his guys were going to give him. George makes Lennie think about the rabbits…

Words 283 - Pages 2

How Did George Kill Lennie In Of Mice And Men

the book, Of Mice and Men, George decides to kill Lennie because he killed their boss’ wife, Curley’s wife. George made the right choice about the murdering of Lennie. He just had to do it. If one takes into consideration about the kind of world the men live in, their personalities, and their past. One could say that he could have made another decision and had let Lennie live, but that plan would have no fortune. George made a right, logical option to cut ties with Lennie because of the aftermath that…

Words 642 - Pages 3

Why Did George Kill Lennie Essay

In my opinion, George had been planning to kill Lennie all along instead of killing him out of compassion. From the very beginning of the book, George treated Lennie like an annoyance and was very rude and blunt towards him. George had said “...If I was alone I could live so easily. I could go get a job an’ work, an’ no trouble.” (Steinbeck 11) He clearly thought his life would be better without Lennie and one time went he as far as to tell Lennie that if he was related to him he would shoot himself…

Words 497 - Pages 2

How Did George Kill Lennie Justified In Of Mice And Men

consequences. When George killed Lennie in John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men it was murder. Although others believe George was protecting Lennie from a gruesome death Lennie still did die, and George was the one that murdered him without much thought. George’s decision to kill Lennie was not justified because there were other ways to save Lennie without ending his life. One reason George’s decision of killing Lennie was not justified is because George made a rash decision to kill his friend with…

Words 621 - Pages 3

Similarities Between John Steinbeck's Of Mice And Men

I think lennie was not sure that george could hurt him because lennie knew george and sap very well as he really is why he did not think george could do something bad to lennie although the imaginary rabbit of lennie told him what contrary that George had done what he could so that Lennie could no longer attend to the rabbits that is what most loves to do Lennie and that if Lennie did not understand George was going to beat Lennie to kill him but Lennie was safe and he felt that George not it hurt…

Words 421 - Pages 2

Mental Disabilities In John Steinbeck's Of Mice And Men

book begins with George and Lennie looking for work in California. Eventually the two find work at a local farm. George is essentially Lennie’s caretaker as Lennie has some form of mental disability. The two are best friends and rely on each either equally. George and Lennie plan on owning a farm one day where the two can live all by themselves. However, they will not be able to accomplish this goal. Lennie receives a new born puppy from one of the other ranch hands, but Lennie has a problem with…

Words 1140 - Pages 5

Of Mice and Men Essay

Mice and Men is about two men named George and Lennie. George is a smart but smaller man, whereas Lennie is very big and strong but has a mental disability. They find work at a ranch but soon find themselves in a dangerous situation when Lennie has accidentally killed the wife of Curley, who is their boss’s son. Curley vows to kill Lennie, but before he is able to do so George chooses to take the life of his friend himself. By doing this, George ensures that Lennie dies in the most compassionate way…

Words 739 - Pages 3