Essay about EIA review

Submitted By Albertinah
Words: 2469
Pages: 10
Open Document
Title: The Role of ES Review

Submission Date: November 9, 2013

University ID Number: 9297731

Word Count: 1548

1. Introduction
Environmental Impact Assessment as a tool for decision making has been formally initiated in late sixty‟s at USA through National Environmental Protection Act, 1969 (Glasson et al., 2012,
p.50) which has been now adopted by majority of countries of the world (Sadler, 1996, p.25;
Petts, 2009; NCEA, 2013).
To monitor the quality of Environmental Statements (on which the overall success of the process depends most) review packages or criteria‟s has been first developed in 1987 by Ross for
Canadian ESs (Lee and Colley, 1992). Following several initiatives in this arena, Lee and Colley developed their review package in 1990, which has been amended at 1999 lastly (Lee et al.,
1999), and it is being used widely for assessing ESs. European commission guideline on EIS review is another precise guideline to evaluate (EC, 2001). Both process has been criticized for the inadequacies to address all the issues (Põder and Lukki, 2011) and variability of scrutiny by reviewers depending on their personal skills and competencies (Peterson, 2010).
2. Role of ES Review within EIA Process


Evaluate the approach and findings of the study, in relation to the actual effects of the development, the accuracy of the prediction made and the effectiveness of mitigation measures proposed (Harrop and Nixon, 1998, p.129).



Assess whether findings and results are presented in an understandable manner and provides information that is sufficient and relevant for decision making (Wood, 2003;
Sadler, 1996).



Check whether the ES fulfills the detail requirement of EIA (impact prediction and significance, alternatives consideration and mitigation measures) in other word quality assurance of EIA process as a whole (Fuller, 2009).



Validate the underneath science and methodology (Glasson et al., 2012, p.176).



Measure harmony with the specified ToR or Scoping guidelines (Sadler, 1996, p.122).



Play a vital role in ensuring the effectiveness of EIA (Lee and Colley, 1992; Lee et al.,
1999).



Helps decision maker or respective authority to take decision – whether to ask for further information / refusal (Sadler, 1996, p.122).



Examine whether ES includes the views of all parties and represents them fairly (Sadler,
1996, p.131)

3. Review of Three (3) ES from Bangladesh: Evaluation Criteria – ‘Impact Significance’
3.1 Justification
Bangladesh is a country with a transitional economy (low income to middle income), having on an average 6% economic growth in the last decade (WB, 2013). Since early 90‟s there has been an increasing trend of Foreign Direct Investment (BOI, GoB, 2012), which comes with the investment in industrial and infrastructure sector. Consequently this type of interventions causing
Environmental and Social impact, which as a result brought EIA to measure the degree of intrusion, by the donors first in the early 80‟s (Kabir 2012, p.40). Recent trend of investment is in energy sector because of the country‟s new exploration of gas and oil reserve and increasing high energy demand. Considering the above mentioned conditions, three (3) Environmental
Statements (ES) from power sector has been selected for the analysis in this essay

i.

Environmental Impact Assessment of 2x (500-660) MW Coal Based Thermal Power
Plant to be Constructed at the Location of Khulna (BPDB, GoB and CEGIS 2013).

ii.

Environmental Impact Assessment of 108 MW Natural Gas Fired Power Plant at
Ghorashal, Palash, Narshingdi (AECL et al. 2012).

iii.

Environmental Impact Assessment study of “Siddhirganj Maniknagar 11Km 230KV
Transmission Line Project (SMTL)” (PGCB, GoB and CEGIS 2012).

The aim of this part of the essay is to evaluate the Identification and Evaluation of Key
Impact of those three (3) ES. Justification for selecting this
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about EIA review

Environmental Impact Assessment(Eia) Essay

TITLE - Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), it's introduction, purpose, methods of EIA, EIA conducted in India, Environmental Impact Statement(EIS). INTRODUCTION : DEFINITION : An environmental impact assessment (EIA) is an assessment of the possible positive or negative impact that a proposed project may have on the environment, together consisting of the environmental, social and economic aspects. PURPOSE : The purpose of the assessment is to ensure that decision makers consider…

Words 2293 - Pages 10

Environmental Impact Assessment

will have any adverse impacts on the environment . Conducting EIA is part of implementation of the Rio Declaration on environment and development of 1992. Principle 17 of The Rio declaration states that, EIA as a national instrument shall be undertaken for proposed activities that are likely to have a significant adverse impact on the environment and are subject to a decision of a competent national authority. The first major EIA to be undertaken in Tanzania was in 1980 for the Stiegeler‟s Gorge…

Words 1020 - Pages 5

Feb 2013Lesson 27 Earned Value ManagementThe Essay

of 1996 (ITMRA/Clinger-Cohen) - Requires agencies to Report performance on information systems acquisition. Department of Defense Instruction (DoDI) 5000.02 - establishes the American National Standards Institute/Electronic Industries Alliance (ANSI/EIA) Standard 748-1998 as the DoD standard for EVM systems. EVM Implementation EVM is a valuable management tool to support timely management decisions. When successfully implemented, EVM ensures: • A disciplined planning process • Baseline work plans…

Words 2528 - Pages 11

EIA HUNMAN ENVIRONMENT Essay

Southampton: Southampton Approach Channel Dredge Appendices Appendix A. Scoping and Consultation A1. Scoping Study The scoping stage of an EIA is an important process that is undertaken to identify the potential environmental issues associated with a proposed development and to determine the scope of work required for the subsequent stages of the EIA process. The findings of the scoping study for the proposed Southampton Approach Channel Dredge were presented within a report and sent to the…

Words 9314 - Pages 38

Critique on the article entitled "AN EVALUATION OF TOOLS FOR AN ASSESSMENT OF CUMULATIVE EFFECTS IN SOCIOECONOMIC IMPACT STUDIES" Essay example

assessing cumulative effects in socioeconomic studies, the theory that drove this study, argues “Even with the advent of approaches such as strategic environmental assessment, an assessment of cumulative effects in Environmental Impact Assessments (EIA) remains important” (p. 312). This is supported by the statement by Clark (1993) as “...perhaps the most ecologically devastating environmental effects may result not from the directs of a particular proposal, but from the combination of existing stresses…

Words 668 - Pages 3

Hello There Essays

iGSM AMFM CDMA Satellite VAS provider provider provider VAS Founded: Jan 2012 Team: 1 full-time; 1 Part time Stage: Initial Traction Headquarters: Chicago, ILL USA provider VAS HDTV VAS VAS provider provider Industry: Any Industry involved with Radio Waves: GSM/Public Safety/TV/Etc. Market: Any who utilizes Radio Waves LTE Aviation VAS Software Radio Networks Everywhere 1. Executive Summary WindyCitySDR's intent is to reclaim Chicago's past, today…

Words 3346 - Pages 14

Assigment 1 SM Network Cabling qualit Essay

Tools 5 6 Reference (Bibliography) 5 Appendix WBS - Quality Standard and Measurement Development Cat. 6 Keystone Jack Project ……………………………………………………… 6 1 PROJECT QUALITY PLAN PURPOSE This plan identifies the set of standards, practices, reviews, checkpoints and other quality improvement methods to be implemented for the Cat. 6 Keystone Jack New Product Development Project. The project adheres to SM Network Cabling Inc. Quality Assurance Practices and New Product Development (NPD) process…

Words 937 - Pages 4

Why Control Development

Why control development The term development is primarily defined to mean the development of or use of the land. Development encompasses two ideas, the use of the land and development. The use of the land relates to activities which are done in or on the land but which do not interfere with the actual physical characteristics of the land. The development component relates to activities that result in some physical alteration of the land that has some degree of permanence (Mcleod.2009). There are…

Words 1823 - Pages 8

Essay on Guide to Networking Essentials, 6th ed., ISBN 1111312524 Chapter 1 Solutions - REVIEW QUESTIONS 1

Guide to Networking Essentials, 6th ed., ISBN 1111312524 Chapter 1 Solutions - REVIEW QUESTIONS 1. Which of the following is one of the three basic functions a computer performs? (Choose all that apply.) a. Processing 2. c. Input e. Output The __________ executes instructions provided by computer programs. a. CPU 3. When a CPU is composed of two or more processors, each one is referred to as a(n) ________. b. Core 4. Which of the following is considered long-term…

Words 2504 - Pages 11

Electricity Informative Speech Essay example

Informative Speech Outline I. Introduction A. Attention Getter: Jane Brox said, “Time and task were both disorienting. For if you were to remove everything from our lives that depends on electricity to function, homes and offices would become no more than the chambers and passages of limestone caves… simple shelter from wind and rain. No way to keep out cold, or heat, for long. No way to preserve food, or to cook it. The things that define us, that without their purpose, they lose…

Words 2455 - Pages 10