Essay on Ethical Dilemma

Words: 3387
Pages: 14
Open Document
The case study presents a moral dilemma based on potential harm to innocent people. By using Kohlberg’s moral development model and by examining major ethical systems, namely deontology and utilitarianism, a clear understanding of the factors influencing this type of decision-making can be gained. Specifically, utilitarianism, Kant’s categorical imperative and the doctrine of double effect address the decision from differing viewpoints, providing the decision maker with compelling evidence to support both angles of the ethical and moral dilemma presented in the decision at hand. A decision can then be made if it is considered morally justified, depending on the model used to make the decision. Often the solution of an ethical dilemma would …show more content…
The utility principle also supports the A/CO’s decision in that the right actions are those that yield the most good or utility. By closing the hatch there will be more lives saved and also a more expedient death to the three trapped men. There are two variations of utilitarianism; act- utilitarianism and rule- utilitarianism (Pojman & Feiser, 2009). Act-Utilitarianism is based on a situational context, considering that an act is right if and only if it results in as much good as any available alternative. It is only concerned with the good and evil that results from a particular circumstance, not the means to get there. This particular situation involves quick decision-making abilities while under an increasing presence of danger. The A/CO must make a decision under extremely stressful conditions. It is the decision to close the hatch to save the lives of the remaining crew that result in the greater good. However, Rule-Utilitarianism is not as dependent on the context of a situation. An act is right provided it is required by a rule, and that this rule is a member of a set of rules whose acceptance would lead to greater utility for society than any other alternative rule (Pojman & Feiser, 2009). The emergency procedure to close the hatch to the engineering department due to flooding would be followed. By ignoring this procedure the submarine will sink farther and crush under the
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Ethical Dilemma

Ethical Dilemma

If a stranger comes to your house and asks for some cash, and his reason is that he needs to collect money to save his ill mother. What will be your reaction? Help him or not? That is the ethical dilemma I faced recently, which happened in the Independent Day. At that day, when my housemates and I cooked dinner in our house, the door bell rang. I went to open the door. An African American was there, with a sad face, accompanying with his little brother, probably. He asked me for some privacy and…

Words 401 - Pages 2

Ethical Dilemma

My Ethical Dilemma LCS 105.50 Prof. Lisa Ursenbach November 17th, 2013 Workplace Ethics Without over stepping my boundaries, how do I approach this situation? This is the question that I’m faced with daily. I’ve analyzed, went through backwards, and studied our employee handbook several times, trying to figure out how to speak on the problem without it being called subornation. The owner and several of her employees are totally ignoring the policies…

Words 575 - Pages 3

Ethical Dilemma

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! An Ethical Dilemma The Effects of Personal and Professional Relationships ! Kayla A. Eidson University of Maryland University College ! ! ! ! !1 Ethics in business is a very wide range topic that is being practiced everyday; from a university firing a lecturer because of a high profile situation to a popular e-book selling company dealing with how they handle employee resignations (Business Ethics in the News, 2014) Many problems and situations arise…

Words 936 - Pages 4

Ethical Dilemmas

assist patients in managing their medications to prevent re-hospitalization and non-compliance. This requires collaborating with the physician and case management to find a more economical medication. Good point about autonomy Professor, facing ethical dilemmas is one of the hardest things to deal with. Ethics is comprised of doing the right thing. However, healthcare staff needs to accept that everything we do is not always the…

Words 156 - Pages 1

Ethical Dilemmas

place when it comes to their values, biases and ethical decisions. Growing up I was raised with the value to appreciate others, be respectful, and treat others the way I would want to be treated. Recently I had the opportunity to face my own biases. This was not easy to me because of the notion that I was not in tuned with my own biases or preferences. From my perspective, I have lived with it so long that it seemed seamless and routine. As for ethical decisions I always viewed as a decision someone…

Words 1124 - Pages 5

Ethical Dilemmas

should breach their client’s confidentiality. This has provided uncertainty that comes detriment of psychologists and their practices. Members of the American Psychological Association (APA) cite confidentiality as their most frequently described dilemma (Pope & Vetter, 1992). Guidelines for psychologists on what action they should take are also not established. In the Court’s words: The discharge of this duty may require the therapist to take one or more of various steps, depending on the nature…

Words 1341 - Pages 6

Ethical Dilemmas

When therapist met with the client's mother at home, therapist did check in client's mother reporting any behavioral issues or conflict at home or at school and client's mother reported that she is sometimes fighting with her siblings at home around toys. Client's mother reported that she was not fighting too much this week compared to last week because she was able to use some of her coping skills and she can use alternative activities to do instead of get involved in a conflict. Client's mother…

Words 407 - Pages 2

Ethical Dilemmas

There are more than thousands of people who are terminally ill patients in the world. When they are finally faced to death or positioned to be on surgery, they or the people who are related to them have thought about that who should take a responsibility of the result of the decisions. This is a consistent problem that most terminally ill patients have suffered. In every country, different people have different perspectives of this problem and they make different decisions. The reason why this is…

Words 155 - Pages 1

Ethical Dilemmas

Natural Disasters and Crisis Situations: Ethical issues During the best of times nurses are called to meet the needs of the community and individuals. Hospitals, clinics, and other institutions are the normal point of care locations where nurses fill their duties. The institutions follow the rules, laws, social contracts and other defining factors which provide a framework for safe, productive interactions. The American Nurses Association (ANA), in particular, seeks to define standards…

Words 465 - Pages 2

Ethical Dilemmas

The second ethical value that has been breached is commitment to client; commitment to client is also important because clients rely on nurses for their care, treatment, and safety on a daily basis. Managing commitment to clients portray nurses to act in the best interest of clients corresponding to clients’ requests and the standards of practice and nurses are also obligate to desist from abandoning, mistreating or neglecting clients (CNO, Ethics Practice Standards, p. 9). Nurses are committed…

Words 271 - Pages 2