Essay about Ethics: Ethics and Logical Perspective

Submitted By scottroll
Words: 831
Pages: 4
Open Document
GBU 204
February 29, 2012
Ethics Case Study
This ethics case study focused on a scenario in which a gubernatorial candidate named Molly is advised to use an advertisement in support of her campaign which, through the use of an incriminating photograph, will discredit her opponent, Frank, and help her to win the election. Although the information provided along with the photograph in the advertisement was factual, and in itself portrays Frank in a negative light, the picture itself was a fake. This fact was immediately realized by Molly. The question at hand in this scenario is whether or not Molly should run the advertisement and use the photograph, in spite of the fact that she knows it is a fake.
From a simple and logical perspective, Molly should not consider running the ad. After all, she immediately realized that the photograph was not genuine. If it was that easy for her to notice that it was not real, then it is very likely that the general public would quickly realize this as well. Consequently, from this way of thinking, it is unlikely that Molly would use the photograph, unless they could produce a more convincing fake. The defense offered by the union president that the photograph is obviously fake so they aren’t really trying to be deceitful is weak and in itself does not justify the use of the photograph. So, rather than viewing the issue from a logical perspective, the observer should instead consider it from an ethical standpoint.
The underlying issue is not a simple one, and there is not one particular solution which will be absolutely right and satisfy everyone. There will always be doubt, debate, and dissention about this type of moral dilemma, as is the case with most issues. By considering the situation from two distinctly different perspectives, that of deontology and teleology, one can see clearly see how easily different individuals can reach varying decisions when presented with the same, or similar, moral dilemmas.
First, the scenario will be looked upon by taking into account the views of the school of deontology. Upon consideration of the issue from this standpoint, at the heart of which lies the driving belief that the ends cannot justify the means, there can be little doubt that Molly should not run the ad. It is the conclusion most likely to be reached by any individual who holds strictly to an ethic belief system which is akin to that held by the proponents of this deontology belief. Although Molly feels strongly that Frank is an unethical person and should not win the election, if she were to run the ad, she would herself be committing an unethical act, and could as a result be considered by some to be no better than her opponent.
Even though the end result of using the photograph, if successful, would greatly benefit the workers to whom Molly had dedicated her life, it would still not justify her decision to commit the dishonest act of knowingly using the fake photograph. She would be violating the underlying principle of deontology which states that the end result or objective, no matter how noble, can never justify the use of immoral or
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Ethics: Ethics and Logical Perspective

Essay on The Branch Of Ethics That Discusses The Meaning And Indeed The Validity Of The Word Good Is Called Meta

The branch of ethics that discusses the meaning and indeed the validity of the word good is called Meta-ethics, meaning ‘beyond' ethics lies ethical language. From here there are two separate branches, cognitive; where "goodness" can be known as an analytic (Moore) or synthetic (naturalists like Mill) property of the world and non-cognitive; where "goodness" cannot be know as a property of the world. Within the non-cognitivists are another group called emotivists, they uphold the view that the word…

Words 1224 - Pages 5

Ethical Lens Inventory Paper

Ethical Lens Inventory Paper Samantha Garza ETH/316 August 27, 2013 Steven Edington Ethical Lens Inventory Paper While doing the ethics game and answering the questions as it relates to my own values, I thought it was very interesting. I say this because there were questions that had similarities, but with different answers to pick from. When completing the lens assignment, my results were very surprisingly to me. My preferred lens is none – periscope or paralysis. While reading and understanding…

Words 767 - Pages 4

Philosophy Exam Review, Terms Essay

standards, or norms. Values- Induction (Inductive reasoning) – A reasoning process that involves drawing a general conclusion from specific observations. Logical Consistency- In logic, refers to statements that do not contradict each other Rehabilitations- Help integrate people (drunks, thief’s etc.) Categorical Imperative- In ethics and social/political philosophy, a moral rule that is absolute. The term was developed by Immanuel Kant. Philosophical Argument- A debate between 2 or more…

Words 1168 - Pages 5

Emotion Vs Emotion

affect the world’s perspective or future course of events. Reason is a way of knowing that allows an individual to process information in a logical and regulated manner such as deductive/inductive reasoning. Conclusions are based upon the data at hand and past experiences. Emotion is a way of knowing that does not produce any specific form of knowledge…

Words 1651 - Pages 7

Materialism And Positivism Essay

to material agencies. What is Materialism? • Materialism as a worldview emphasizes sensory experience and material concerns to the exclusion of spiritual and religious considerations. • There are many terms associated with materialism • • • • Empiricism Logical-positivism Rationalism Reductionism Metaphysics of Materialism • In metaphysics, the central premise of Materialism is that only matter is real. • There is no other, spiritual reality. • In a sense, materialism might be understood as denying metaphysics…

Words 740 - Pages 3

Work Ethics In The Workplace

working, or “work ethic”, grew as an everyday vocabulary in workplaces since the early 1970s (Address to the Nation on Labor Day). Today, work ethic is defined as characteristics and attitudes in which…

Words 1346 - Pages 6

Beef Jerky Research Paper

However, as a logical person, I wanted to have a clear cut reason for why not buying the beef jerky was justified, other than just a feeling. Thus, I went to my junior English teacher, Dr. Culbertson, who taught a unit focused on morals and ethics. During our conversation, Dr. Culbertson said that neither decision was right or wrong. It all depended on whether I looked at the situation with a utilitarian perspective or a deontological perspective. Together we decided that as a…

Words 635 - Pages 3

Essay on Morality and Animal Rights Theory

Statement and Outline What is your thesis statement? My thesis statement concerns about ethics and morality also extend to matters associated with the treatment of animals. The purpose of this discussion is to summarize and critique several different theories associated with the ethical treatment of animals. I. Introduction: Ethics and morality have consistently been topics of concern in our society. Concerns about ethics and morality also extend to matters associated with the treatment of animals. The…

Words 1000 - Pages 4

Reflection: Ethics and Conceptual Framework Essay

administering such regulations. FRC deals with decisions that Australian reporting entity would adopted and ASX mainly set out the listing and trading rules. Even though a comprehensive regulation system has been set up, opinions that prefer ‘free-market’ perspective were put forward which means that the market will determine the optimum supply of information. In my opinion, a market without regulation may lose control and fall into inefficient operating situation since some person take advantage of rights that…

Words 1308 - Pages 6

Ethical Approaches Critique Paper

Approaches XXX XXXUniversity Instructor: XXX Course Name: XXX Date: XXX This paper summarizes each of ethical approaches, especially the Grand Principles, Nash’s Covenantal Business Ethic, Damon’s Four Dimensions of Business Morality, and Hill’s (2008) Christian Ethic for Business. Also, this paper critiques each of them through analyzing the strengths and weaknesses of approaches. Finally, the most favor approach is provided at the end. The Grand Principles which…

Words 1095 - Pages 5