Guilty or Not Guilty I Don't Remember Essay example

Submitted By MichaelTrahan
Words: 1635
Pages: 7
Open Document
Guilty or Not Guilty: I Don’t Remember

Michael Trahan

Intro/American Government II
POLS 2302-09
James Nelson
February 26, 2014 Who do you want deciding Supreme Court Cases? The forefathers of the U.S. Constitution, under great deliberation, created the foundation for which the country would be governed. Article II, Section 2 of the Constitution reads “[the President] shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint … Judges of the supreme Court… and which shall be established by Law”. Article III Section 1 distinguishes the term in which they will hold office. These are considered enumerated powers given to the federal government that are specifically listed in the Constitution. “[D]uring good Behaviour,” is interpreted to mean for life tenure to these appointed positions (The Constitution of the United States). Therefore, tenure given to federal judges results from the implied powers given to the federal government that are derived from the enumerated powers and necessary and proper clause of the Constitution. Hence it can, and should be, amended or modified without actual deviation from the Constitution. The intended purpose of the founders of the Constitution was to separate the judicial branch of government from encroachment by the other branches. This was accomplished by designating a life tenure appointment to these judicial positions in the government system. However, the life expectancy of an American was considerably different when the Constitution was drafted than it is today. During the early 1700’s the average life expectancy of an American at the age of 20 was approximately 57 compared to 76 in 2000. As well as during the 1700’s a 40 year old had the life expectancy of 64 compared to 78 in 2000 (Mapping History). That is an average of approximately 17 years. Although the founders of the Constitution did expect these individuals to reside in office until death or impeachment for “non-good behavior”, they were not knowledgeable of the illnesses or deterioration that came with the natural aging process in these later years of life. Illnesses that come with the aging process can affect a judge’s ability to make rational decisions on the bench. “Dementia is a gradual decline of how the brain functions. It is incurable, and slowly interferes with a person's ability to carry out the normal tasks of daily living. Alzheimer’s is the leading cause of dementia and Alzheimer’s is the sixth leading cause of deaths in the United States” (Latest Facts & Figures Report). Because we are now able to detect Alzheimer’s at the early stages, there has been an increase in reported cases. Several federal judges have served in office at an age or in a physical condition that should not have been allowed. For instance, William O. Douglas served 37 years on the Supreme Court and is the longest term in history for federal judges (Douglas, William O). At the age of 84, Judge Richard Owen of the U.S. District Court in Manhattan conducted a side bar with the lawyers during a trial to explain what e-mail was. On a later case, Judge Owen ended up sentencing a defendant to life in prison because—during the trial—the prosecutor in the case referred to the defendant as “the key into that apartment”. Judge McWilliams took it literally that the defendant gave the perpetrators a key that allowed them entry to the apartment, to commit a robbery, and kill three people. Therefore, the judge considered the defendant a accessory to the murders and found him guilty on three counts of second degree murder. Judge McWilliams served as a federal judge and heard cases until the age of 95. A survey conducted in 2010, by ProPublica, calculated that approximately 12% of the nation’s federal and circuit judges are 80 years or older. The same survey revealed that eleven of these judges were over the age of 90 and continuing to hear cases. One judge was reported to be
Show More

Related Documents: Guilty or Not Guilty I Don't Remember Essay example

Essay about dog bite

come to a unanimous decision. The first vote was 11 to 1 guilty. These men had to communicate on why they felt the way they did. This is when certain variables affected the way they communicated with each other. When trying to come to a decision, you see that past experience influenced their decision at first. Juror 3 had problems with his son and hasn’t communicated with him for two years. He was loud and vocal on saying that the kid was guilty from the very start. He was portraying what was going…

Words 978 - Pages 4

TKAM essay

Hassan 1 Suha Hassan Mrs. Van Wely ENG 1D May 05 2015 Definition Of A Mockingbird As Voltaire once said “It is better to risk saving a guilty person than to condemn an innocent one.” . The fascinating story To Kill A Mockingbird takes place in a sleepy, southern county of Maycomb in the 1930’s. There are people who live in Maycomb who can be considered unfair and possibly evil in the eyes of some, but are just acting as they were taught by society. Throughout the novel there…

Words 1049 - Pages 5

Essay on Tuan: Mcdonald ' s and Meal

Engineering Thesis Statement: With computer prices getting cheaper by the time, it may seem a false economy, but if you look deeper, you will see the true benefits. Intro: How to build a PC I: Basics 1. What are the benefits of building your own computer? 2. What are the Parts of a Computer? 3. What Type of System am I Building? 4. Buying Parts II: Type of builds 1. The Basic System 2. The Budget Gaming System 3. The High Performance Gaming System III: Choosing components 1. Selecting a Processor…

Words 7676 - Pages 31

Murdering Hae Min Lee Case Study

Why could have Adnan Syed be guilty for murdering Hae Min Lee? Serial, a podcast, investigates a case regarding the murder of a high school senior, Hae Min Lee. The case is revolves mainly around Adnan Syed, a 17 year old from Woodlawn High School, who was Hae’s boyfriend until they suddenly broke up. Apparently, Adnan killed Hae in rage and was sentenced to life in prison. Sarah Koenig reopens the mysterious case and discovers new evidence on whether Adnan Syed is guilty or innocent. After investigating…

Words 1233 - Pages 5

Examples Of Innocent In To Kill A Mockingbird

Innocent is defined as being not guilty of a crime or offense. These are good innocent people who are still hurt even though they did nothing wrong, these people are called Mockingbirds. In To Kill a Mockingbird By Harper Lee, two kids learn life lessons about how people are misperceived in their community when they do nothing wrong. Mockingbirds symbolize people who are proven innocent but are still harmed. Boo Radley is a Mockingbird because he is misjudged by society. Boo Radley is first looked…

Words 858 - Pages 4

12 angry men Essay

that, if found guilty, the mandatory sentence for the accused is the death penalty. After these instructions, the jurors enter. The men file in and decide to take a short break before deliberating. They complain that the room is hot and without air-conditioning; even the fan doesn’t work. All the jurors presume the obvious guilt of the defendant, whom we learn has been accused of killing his father. Eventually, the twelve sit down and a vote is taken. All of the jurors vote “guilty,” except for…

Words 1118 - Pages 5

12 Angry Men Rhetorical Analysis

In the vacant lot across the street. Too many of them. Switch knives came from the neighborhood where I lived. Funny that I didn’t think of it before. I guess one tries to forget those things”(Rose, 56). With these pieces of emotional evidence, it gives the other jurors direct insight on how the living conditions were portrayed and how they were as it comes directly from one…

Words 889 - Pages 4

Reginald Rose's Personal Bias In 12 Angry Men

Would you want people deciding whether you die or not to let you down with their own personal bias? This type of situation consisted in the movie 12 Angry Men and I think that personal biases should never determine if somebody will die or be imprisoned, However, in the movie/play the guilty verdict was able to be stopped before it was too late. At first the little things in a case might not seem like much at first but in the outcome it could determine somebody’s future, whether it’s for the better…

Words 662 - Pages 3

To Kill A Mockingbird Book Report

is agreeable but then there is others that are not at all right, and completely wrong. There is one thing you have to remember while reading this is, this is actually how kids were raised at that time in history they’re world revolves around conspiracy and racism that is put into their brain by their parents and that’s what they were taught to believe. You might be still saying i would never teach my children racism but if you were raising children at this time you would most likely follow…

Words 998 - Pages 4

Hamlet: Of Mice and Men and Final Reason , Lennie Essay

to hurt anyone or get hurt by anybody.Many believe George is guilty but lets explain why this belief is wrong and why some believe Lennie is the guilty one in this case. My first reason,is that Lennie is a man with anger issues that he can not control by himself. He always needs help from somebody else from stopping him from hurting others. Example,Curley's wife screams while having her mouth shut with a hand[59]. Lennie says, "don't make me hurt you"[59]. This shows that Lennie had a choice to…

Words 569 - Pages 3