In Defense of Food Essay

Words: 1231
Pages: 5
Open Document
ENGWR 301
13 February 2014
In Defense of Pollan When Michael Pollan's book The Omnivore's Dilemma was published, many readers began questioning him for advice on what they should eat in order to stay healthy. In his more recent book, In Defense of Food, he responds with three rules, "Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants"(Pollan 1). This seven word response seems too simple for a relatively complicated question, but as he further elaborates these rules into specific guidelines, this summary turns out to be surprisingly complete. Using inductive and deductive reasoning, he debunks the ideas behind nutritionism and food science, and proves that the western diet is the cause for food related diseases. Inductive reasoning is when a …show more content…
He further elaborate on this, explaining how there was a study done on a group of Aborigines that had adopted the Western diet which caused many of them to suffer from type 2 diabetes. In the study, the group was asked to return to their traditional diet for seven weeks, too see it had any effects. "After seven weeks, O'Dea drew blood from the Aborigines and found striking improvements in virtually every measure of their health [...] all the abnormalities of type II diabetes were either greatly improved or completely normalized "(Pollan 87). With this, Pollan creates a deductive syllogism to link the Western diet to food diseases. A syllogism is a form of reasoning which connects two supporting premises that lead to a conclusion (Griffith 270). His first premise is that the Western diet causes food related health problems. The second premise is that the Aborigines adopted the Western diet, which leads to the conclusion that the Aborigines will face food related problems. His deductive syllogism is sound because both premises were true, and the fact that many Aborigines had diabetes proves that the conclusion is also true. This study also proves that the inverse of this syllogism is also valid and sound. The first premise is that abandoning the Western diet and adopting a
Show More

Related Documents: In Defense of Food Essay

Michael Pollan In Defense Of Food

"In Defense of Food" by Michael Pollan, you will find a variety of information about what nourishment is, and how we are influenced by this change of the western diet. “Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.” Michael examines the question of what we “should” eat, trying to explore through the supermarket, diet & health industry, and places where we choose to eat on a daily. Michael mentions that we are not being mindful about what we are eating and the results are ending up plainly clear as we take…

Words 473 - Pages 2

In Defense Of Food Documentary Analysis

In defense of food is a documentary which is unique in its own way it is seeing the change of pattern in the diet of individuals and ho has this effected the health. The movie shows us the past, present and the future. The movie was produced by Penguin Press and but directed by Michael Pollan, it was produced in 2015 how ever there is book which came much before the movie in the year 2008, the book was preceded by his famous book “Omnivore’s dilemma” the thought behind this movie was after writing…

Words 924 - Pages 4

Essay on Childhood obesity

lack of physical activity are significant factors that have lead to childhood obesity. The Center for Disease Control and Prevention article on Obesity and Genetics, Parenting Style and Childhood Obesity by Katie Hurley LCSW, and the Children’s Defense Fund explain these three factors that are causing the epidemic of childhood obesity. The question is; is the problem of childhood obesity a problem just for the parents or should the public, like schools and government get involved. According…

Words 1508 - Pages 7

Psychoanalytic Personality Assessment Essay

exist through the psychosexual stages of development. The first stage is called the oral stage which starts when someone is born. This stage is weaning and the theory is believed that the baby is preoccupied with sucking and accepting things, such as food, in the mouth. Frustration is prevalent in this stage because the baby does not know how to speak up for him or herself without crying. The anal phase is second. The anal stage comes with potty training and is believed that the child becomes obsessed…

Words 1857 - Pages 8

Argumentative Essay: Should Common Citizens Carry Guns?

should be allowed to carry guns for self-defense, if someone robs a store, hunting, because for food, and because the second Amendment clearly states, "That a well-regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a Free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed" (U.S. Constitution). Common citizens should be able to have guns because it's their right…

Words 1211 - Pages 5

Essay about Pat Frank and Mans Capacity

Logan and others. Or maybe both major governments gone and the highwayman killing their own people for items. Porky Logan was being selfish so he went to get gold and selling it to others for profit. Then highwayman killing poor innocent people for food, these things causes national suicide in our nation. Most people didn’t survive the attack but the people who did use man capacity to change to survive. Doctor Gun and Randy used what they had to survive to live. Randy used water from henrys well…

Words 546 - Pages 3

The Progressive Era, The New Deal, And World War II

reforms was his full support of the Pure Food and Drug Act. This was a proposed legislation after the public was informed of the extremely unsafe and unsanitary conditions their food and drugs were originated from. Much of the distasteful public opinion came from the publishing of Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle. Upton Sinclair was a muckraker whose job was to expose scandal and corruption in big businesses. With the help of President Roosevelt, the Pure Food and Drug Act was passed in 1906. This Act…

Words 688 - Pages 3

Odysseus Defense

People, Odysseus was brought up on the charges of murder and breaking and entering. Despite both sides having strong arguments, I support the defense due to their counterpoints being strong, clear, and concise. Their thorough analysis and summary of the charges indicated that they were better prepared. A key moment in influencing my support of the defense was when they eloquently refuted the prosecution’s claim about the Cyclops’ cave. By correctly pointing out that the cave could in no way be perceived…

Words 405 - Pages 2

Medieval Castle Research Paper

taking this role, you get to live in a luxurious castle. But having this luxury does not mean you are safe. A castle isn’t just a marvelous decorative dwelling for the royal family. Other aspects must be taken into consideration, especially safety and defense. The first castles served primarily for military housing. During the Middle Ages, the purpose of a castle was to house the King and the royal family. The King, of course, being a higher power, needs to be protected from any threats outside of the…

Words 694 - Pages 3

Personal Narrative: John Hick

Defense: I would like to introduce my witness to the stage, Mr. John Hick. Defense: Dr. Hick, please introduce yourself, and inform the court of your qualifications as a witness. Hick: Good day, Judge, Jury, lawyers and witnesses. My name is John Hick. I am a lecturer at Cambridge University, I teach Divinity. My past experience was at Princeton theological Seminar where I was a professor Christian Philosophy. I have an MA. degree from University of Edinburgh, and a PhD. from Oxford University.…

Words 1477 - Pages 6