Literature Review Critical Thinking

Submitted By ariyan10
Words: 1036
Pages: 5
Open Document
Reviewing Literature & CRITICAL THINKING

As you progress through your undergraduate studies, you will be expected to undertake an increasing amount of background reading in order to broaden and deepen your level of knowledge and understanding.

However, simply reading chapters of books and journal articles is not enough. You should avoid the temptation to treat all academic work as ‘the truth’ – some academics’ work is clearly less adequate or credible than others. Whenever you read something you should learn to treat it with suspicion and interrogate its integrity.

You need to try and develop your capacity for something called critical thinking. In essence, this means that you should be critically analysing everything you read so that you begin to prioritise between the stronger and weaker references you come across.

Critically reviewing literature is an academic skill. If it is done well it is likely that the associated assignment will also be done well and therefore receive higher grades. This reviewing of literature is of paramount importance to those writing a Final Year Project (where a specific section is required on a review of relevant literature) but it is important to practice this skill throughout your studies to increase your ability in this area. Remember that your observations gain greater academic credibility when underpinned by reference to the work of others.

Some literature reviews will establish theoretical frameworks which underpin the project or essay. Others will provide the basis for debate and critical reflection. The key to a successful literature review is to allow enough time to seek out the key and recently published articles in the area being studied. In general, the more sources that can be considered, the more thorough the review process will be. Once the sources have been collected they should be reviewed individually and then ‘synthesised’ (i.e. amalgamated together in order to highlight any comparisons and/or contrasts that emerge)

What follows is a model of best practice of how to critique a journal article. This should help you begin to develop those skills of critical thinking referred to above.

A Step-by-Step Approach to Reviewing Critically

The best way to critique an article is to be systematic and logical. Consider the following steps and how they work together to break down a piece of work into its component parts, thus making it easier to manage.

1) Read the whole article!

It sounds obvious, but it’s important to gain an overall impression (good or bad) of the literature. Time pressures often mean that people simply read the abstract and the discussion sections of a journal article thus potentially missing a key weakness within the methodology, for example.

2) The Article’s Structure

Consider the layout and ordering of each section – is it easy to follow? Is the article over-structured making it difficult to read or is there no apparent structure at all?

3) Re-Read Each Section in Depth

The majority of academic literature is broken up into sections Use these to unpack the important parts of the article piece by piece. Read each section in isolation and see if it stands alone as a solid piece of work.

4) Follow up References

Explore the materials that the author has used, i.e. if they refer to a particular model or theory go and read about that model or theory for yourself. Has the author represented and interpreted things accurately in their work? Has the author understood the sources? Has there been an unquestioning acceptance of comments or conclusions made?

5) Check the Validity of the Article

This will allow you to begin to make a judgement on the overall quality of the piece of work. Break this down by asking the following questions in each of the sections.

Introduction: What was the point of the study?
Previous Work: Which theories/models are being privileged?
Method: Were suitable tools of measurement used?
Show More

Related Documents: Literature Review Critical Thinking

Critical Thinking: Social Workers

Critical Thinking has an array of definitions that have different and similar viewpoints. Critical Thinking is an essential aspect of Social Workers among other fields, to guide us in a structured way of thinking, helping us provide sufficient responses to our clients, based on the current knowledge base. Also, increasing confidence in one’s speech to give a more succinct response. Critical Thinking forces use to look at outside influences; such as the environment, theories, personal views, marginalization…

Words 652 - Pages 3

Lesson Learned Paper

Lessons Learned Paper Steven University of Phoenix Lessons Learned Paper Critical Thinking I learned so much more about critical thinking then I ever knew before I attended this class. I learned about critical thinking in previous classes and I thought I had a good understanding of the subject. I now understand that information was the foundation for this class. In class this week, I learned to use critical thinking to identify assumptions and situatedness in people’s writing and speaking.…

Words 1491 - Pages 6

Pt1420 Unit 8 Report

Section One-Introduction “My child is on the honor roll” is a commonly sighted bumper sticker as one drives through their local community. A coveted parental privilege is to offhandedly mention their child’s status as a “straight A student.” How then is this top prize determined? Grades. Proficiency in a subject is summed up by a letter grade on a report card. It is assumed that an A is great, a B is ok, a C is not so great, and a D or F is sometimes punishable. Some parents may go…

Words 1345 - Pages 6

Personal Narrative: My Coaching Experience

Since the beginning of my second year I have undertaken 50 hours of work placement at Cardiff Metropolitan University. Over this duration I have managed to coach both hockey and skiing to junior athletes consistently. This has helped me develop and discover useful work-based skills than can also be transferred to other lines of work. Sports coach UK provides the coaching industry with a common vision to push the development of outstanding coaching practice. The focus of this assignment is to critically…

Words 1387 - Pages 6

80 bullet items for research method Essay

report Nonjuried or nonrefereed – none reviewed report. E.g. Journal report. Learned about checklist evaluating research- that a report juried that is judge. Learned that a research that is not screen or viewed by expert is not valid Guidelines in reviewing research by going to library to sort for information needed for case study. I learned as a researcher, you must read more than articles. I learned about research paper / APA Style – that first thing is to choose the research topic. Learned about…

Words 1086 - Pages 5

Essay on Integration of Evidenced Based Practice in Professional Nursing

Fall 2010 Introduction During the 1980’s, the term “evidence-based” medicine surfaced to describe the approach that used scientific evidence to determine the best practice. Evidence-based practice is a process that entails reviewing and instilling the most reliable and updated research in patient care. The goal of evidence-based practice is to provide the highest quality care while being most cost efficient. It is a process based on the accumulation, interpretation, and integration…

Words 1244 - Pages 5

SAT paper

showing their intelligence so providing them with a test that is fair and as diverse as they, can be a more accurate way to show their potential. A test that can possibly cater to all sorts of ways of learning and background knowledge so that critical thinking skills can truly be reflected. A one size fits all exam does no truly measure the capacities, or real knowledge of students. Records show that those with high test scores are typically middle class male students, and those who suffer the most…

Words 1282 - Pages 6

Refer: Sociology and Special Education Essay

Experience with the Special Education Process Literature Review Mona M Assaf George Mason University Dr. Osterling EDUC 893-Fall 2008 Research Proposal-Special Education Process 2 Educational research has long documented the over representation of culturally, linguistically, and ability diverse (CLAD) children in special education, yet few studies have investigated parent/family experiences and perceptions of the process. Any research or literature review of the special education process will…

Words 1645 - Pages 7

The Permanence Of Racism

According to Lopez (2003) society fails to see racism because it is an everyday experience that is often taken for granted. Racism is so common that society fails to realize how it functions and how it shapes our institutions, relationships, and ways of thinking (McCoy, 2006). The ultimate goal of CRT is to expose White privilege and display a society that is deeply divided by racial…

Words 4651 - Pages 19

Essay about University of North TexasAkthamRES 9311141001 Fundamentals

Examine published research and statistical techniques. The literature of Business research is very extensive. This is evidenced by the literature search and critical analysis published by Doe (2010), which cited over 1000 references in the literature published up to 2007. An exhaustive review of the literature is thus beyond the scope of this work. The aim of this paper is to provide, through selective reference to some of the literature, a clearer vision about assemble fundamental data collection…

Words 1850 - Pages 8