Mackie Claims On Objective Value

Submitted By marielward18

Words: 538

Pages: 3

Open Document

Mackie states that all claims about objective values and morals are false. He claims that these values are categorical and would apply for every person. If any so-called objective value claim were true, then Mackie would say that there would have to be both prospective and physical properties. He then goes on to say that there is no such thing for something to have both prospective and physical properties. Therefore, none of these claims would be true. For example, many people have ideas about mermaids and how we think one should look, act, and be like. But no one has ever actually seen a real live mermaid, because they do not exist. Things like these would make a moral value claim seem so weird to us that they would be so out of the ordinary and we would know that it was special. Mackie’s argument states that:
1.) If there were objective values, then they would be so out of the ordinary and strange that they would be completely different than anything else in the universe.
2.) No such strange things exist in this natural world.
3.) Therefore, there are no objective values.

Mackie tries to justify himself by giving examples of such strange entities. He highlights this in his argument from queerness. If these values did happen to be real and we did happen to know and be aware of them, then the only way we could know of them would be through our own perception and our own intuition. Not from the ordinary style of learning which would be through others. These values that come from our intuition can be often what leads us into a better understanding of an idea or a higher sense of education. Mackie states that “intuition merely makes unpalatably plain what other forms of objectivism wrap up.” (Mackie, 162)
He is saying how intuition may not be a good source for finding ones own self-education and knowledge. This can be proven wrong when people are forced to make decisions for themselves all the time. For example, people face

Reconsidering Absolute Omnipotence Summary

Groarke, Louis. "Reconsidering Absolute Omnipotence." The Heythrop Journal 42.1 (2001): 13-25. Academic Search Premie. Web. 10 Sept. 2015. The author and researcher at Trent University, used the articles from John McTaggart, J. L. Mackie, Earl Condee, and Danny Goldstick which base on an omnipotent god cannot do everything to prove that god does not exist. The author argues that the atheistic tradition is wrong. First of all, a omnipotent god can make the world with suffering base on the act of…

Words 881 - Pages 4

Essay about Sense and Banana

Instructor: Kurt Pond PHI 111-002 4 August 2011 Banana One of the best ways to look at Locke’s philosophy is to use a food item to analyze using Locke’s philosophy. A good food item to analyze is a peeled banana (and yes how gay am I). The reason is bananas are pretty consistent in size and quality, so that the banana I evaluate is pretty much the same banana you think of while reading the paper. Primary qualities are intrinsic properties. These are properties that exist weather we perceive…

Words 1062 - Pages 5

355 Syllabus 14 15 Essay

PHI 2-355 Philosophy of Religion White 2014/15 202 Prall House Phone: ext. 4239 Home: 319-551-9967 E-Mail: JWHITE Class Time: M-F 12:00-3:00 Office Hours: M, W, F 11-12 Th 3:00-3:30 Required Books: Michael Palmer (ed.), Philosophy of Religion (Fortress, 2011). Lots of other material on Moodle Course Requirements: (1) Daily readings, attendance, class engagement (15%) (2) Two papers each of about 5 pages in length (40%), or one paper and dictionary (3) 3 short-answer quizzes (20%) (4)…

Words 1356 - Pages 6

God and Cosmological Argument Essay

| [RESPONSE PAPER] | McCloskey Article | SUMMARY This paper is an analytical response to the article, titled “On Being an Atheist,” that was written by H. J. McCloskey in 1968 for the journal Question. The assignment for this paper asked many questions which require responses based on the views of McCloskey in contrast to different philosophical arguments of religion. Such arguments include the Cosmological Argument, Teleological Argument and the Problem of Evil. The paper will also include…

Words 1733 - Pages 7

Can Consumption Ever Be Ethical

Can consumption ever be ethical? Introduction This paper seeks to unravel the possibilities, likelihood and future of ethical consumption. In order to answer the question ‘Can consumption ever be ethical?’ the definition of ethical consumerism must be deconstructed and operationalized. Ethics is the human measurement of morale, a philosophical framework through which human value can be measured and assessed. Consumption is an interactive process of buy and sell and it is therefore necessary to…

Words 2312 - Pages 10

Essay about Moral Antirealism

exist, even if some people have yet to understand them. In this paper, I intend to argue that there are no universal moral truths because objective moral values do not exist. To understand the debate in meta-ethics one must decide if there exist such things as moral facts. If a person makes a statement that something is morally wrong, is this statement an objective fact or a subjective opinion? In the textbook, Philosophy: Traditional and Experimental Readings, Tamler Sommers presents a…

Words 1169 - Pages 5

The Problem Of Evil and Suffering Essay

of human pain arises from people’s inhumanity. This pain includes such major scourges as poverty, oppression and persecution, war and all the injustice, indignity and inequalities that have occurred through history.’ This written by John Hick in Philosophy of Religion and this quote defined what evil and suffering was. The problem of evil and suffering is a major problem for religious believers as it talks about how there is evil and suffering within our world and this evil and suffering means that…

Words 2212 - Pages 9

Sources of Ethics Essay

TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0- JOHN STEINER AND GEORGE STEINER SIX PRIMARY SOURCES OF ETHICS: 6 1- Religion: 6 2- Genetic Inheritance: 8 3- Philosophical Systems: 8 4- Cultural Experience: 8 5- The Legal System: 9 6- Codes of Conduct: 9 2.0- EXPLANATION OF THE SOURCES OF ETHICS: 10 2.1- RELIGION: 10 Teaching business ethics 12 2.11- Impact Of Religiosity: 13 2.12- Ethics Of Islam: 14 Nature of Islamic Ethics 17 The Human-Environment Relationship: 20 The Sustainable…

Words 20200 - Pages 81