Malicious Prosecution Essay

Words: 1956
Pages: 8
Open Document
I.
The cases discussed below seem to agree on the four main elements of malicious prosecution: (1) termination of earlier suit in the plaintiff’s favor, (2) lack of probable cause for the suit, (3) malice on the defendant’s part, and (4) special injury flowing from the earlier suit. Frey v. Stoneman, 722 P. 2d 274, 277 (Ariz. 1986); Young v. Motor City Apartments, 133 Mich. App. 671, 675, 350 N.W.2d 790, 792 (1984). Elements (2) and (3) are satisfied in our client’s case: the earlier suit lacked probable cause; and the suit was presumably malicious because the lienholder’s only motive was to put her out of business. Element (1) is dicussed under Issue I and element (4) is discussed under Issue II below.
Can a plaintiff sue satisfying …show more content…
Our case is similar to Colli and Frey because both cases have been prosecuted as if the earlier suit was voluntarily dismissed by the defendant resulting in favorable termination satisfying element (1) for malicious prosecution. The only difference in Colli is that the suit was dismissed after three years whereas in our case the suit was dismissed after two weeks. It is unlikely that the time taken before a voluntary dismissal will affect whether it satisfies the requirement that the suit must terminate in the plaintiffs favor. The only difference in Frey is that it is under review whether the first suit ended in a voluntary dismissal or a mutual agreement by both parties. Therefore the end result for our case should be the same as Colli as in both cases there was a voluntary dismissal satisfying the requirement for element (1). Depending on further determination of whether the first case forming the basis for Frey was a voluntary dismissal will determine the level of similarity, if it is determined the defendants voluntarily dismissed ,then it is similar to our case. If it is by an agreement then it is different than our case as an agreement does not satisfy element (1) for a judgment in plaintiffs favor.
I.
Can a plaintiff show a special injury from an earlier suit, as required to have an action for malicious prosecution, when property was seized pending the suit as
Show More

Related Documents: Malicious Prosecution Essay

Essay about High Court of Justice and Court

of Contract and Tort Disputes over partnerships, trusts & inheritance (up to value of £30,000) All cases for the recovery of land. On a rare occasion the judge may sit with a jury of 8 to hear cases of: * Defamation *False imprisonment * malicious prosecution 2. High Court The High Court is based in London but also has judges sitting in 26 towns and cities in England and Wales. It can hear any civil case and has 3 divisions each of which specialises in different types of cases: 1. Family Division…

Words 900 - Pages 4

Sharilla Serrano Case Study

• Plaintiffs, Virginia Torres, Zelma Ocasio, and Sharinna Serrano, claim false arrest, assault, excessive force, illegal search and seizure, and malicious prosecution. Per the Law Department abstract provided, Det. Hernandez and Det. Mill were executing a search warrant at the location. Det. Hernandez had obtained the search warrant after CI had multiple drug purchases at the location. Officers recovered 12 bags of marijuana, a scale with marijuana residue, and imitation revolver. Plaintiffs were…

Words 81 - Pages 1

Social Media Should Be Regulated Essay

Trolling can be seen as opinions expressed very bluntly or using language that not everyone might like, but this is also a person’s right to freedom of speech, a right threatened by recent social media prosecutions in the UK [8]. The current malicious communications act being used to prosecute some is far from clear [9], with the term 'grossly offensive, obscene, indecent or menacing' [2] being very subjective and varying in meaning. These are terms that neglect to be explained…

Words 1441 - Pages 6

Wrongful Prosecution In Just Mercy By Walter Mcmillian

Wrongful prosecution Wrongful prosecution also known as malicious prosecution, which is a suit pursued without probable causes. The act of accusing a person with the intent of punishing them without having proper justification of the claim. This was very prevalent in the 90’s due to the lack of technology but also the presence of racism also played a role. An example of this given in the book “Just Mercy” opens with a case where Walter McMillian was falsely accused of the murder of a white woman…

Words 557 - Pages 3

Judge Freeland Case Study

Mr Alexander Walker’s appeal against Judge Freeland QC’s judgement, in Central London County Court. On trial in this appeal is Sir Bernard Rix et al, within the Court of Appeal (Civil Division). Upon the early hours of 12 July 2008, police officers responded to a complain regarding an accusation of assault by Mr Walker’s partner. When arriving on scene, the appellant showed aggressive behaviour towards the officers. Mr Walker was briefly detained, without any contact, by PC Adams in the doorway…

Words 264 - Pages 2

Freddie Gray Case Summary

Freddie Gray, 25, died from police brutality with severe neck injuries. Being shackled and handcuffed in the back of a police van how could he harm himself in the neck? He obviously did not and the six Baltimore police officers did. Marilyn J. Mosby, Baltimore State attorney, charged the officers with a range of charges such as 2nd degree murder, manslaughter, and misconduct in office. This case is a criminal case that went huge and the death of Freddie Gray started riots in and out of Baltimore…

Words 261 - Pages 2

Hae Min Lee Case Study

of when and where everything happened. For Adnan—and the rest of the case—there is one twenty-one-minute stretch of time that is extremely important: 2:15 - 2:36 p.m. At 2:15, Hae and Adnan were dismissed from school. At 2:36, Hae was dead. The prosecution had an explanation for what happened in this timeframe that was, admittedly, quite simple. Adnan and Hae left school at 2:15, Hae bought some food from the school concession stand, Hae gave Adnan a ride, they went to the local Best Buy, Adnan strangled…

Words 1978 - Pages 8

Essay about Should Video Gamers Be Prosecuted for Virtual Theft>

Elizabeth Shreve September 20, 2015 Eng 111 4-5:15 Professor Roof Paper 1 Prosecution in the Virtual World Many online gamers will pay for virtual items with real money. Some people want laws in effect for the real world to protect their rights to their belongings. Theft in the virtual world occurs quite often. In an article titled, “Should Gamers be Prosecuted for Virtual Stealing?” the author Alex Weiss calls out a young teenage boy who is being prosecuted for stealing in a video game.…

Words 1254 - Pages 6

Rhode Island Piracy

No colony rebelled more against the new policies than Rhode Island. The small colony’s reputation as a safe haven for pirates, and Governor Walter Clarke’s refusal to aggressively pursue them in his community, set off a series of events leading to the real threat that the crown would revoke the colony’s charter. Over a seven year period, the Board of Trade sent a flurry of threatening correspondence to Rhode Island officials demanding they arrest and prosecute known pirates hiding in their colony…

Words 1793 - Pages 8

Computer Misuse Act By Robert Schifreen

Mailbox system this peaked when they reached Price Phillips private email inbox. This attack was very significant, firstly because this was the first high profile computer attack in the UK. The other significant factor was that this attack was not malicious and they were doing it simply because they could.…

Words 847 - Pages 4