Negative Effects Of Civil Disobedience

Words: 758

Pages: 4

Open Document

Although civil rights activists have paved the way for a better society, the exceptions to these cases can damage the causes they are trying to impact. When peaceful protests become violent or are generalized with other groups involved in similar causes, chaos often results. The media and public perception greatly influence the impact civil disobedience can have, especially when published stories seem to consistently cover the negative aspects of issues. It is important to analyze protest events, and take note of their effects before making the assumption that all free speech has led to betterment of the United States. The first amendment supports the general principal that “Congress shall make no law … abridging the freedom of speech or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble” (Corwin, 1920). This aspect of American government separates it from other countries, but it has led to acts of protests that have reached certain extremes. One instance of this is flag burning, which goes against the nationalistic ideals of many citizens. The Supreme Court Case, Texas v. Johnson, ruled on June 21, 1989 that doing so was a non-violent and symbolic act that is …show more content…
Military secrets were disclosed making the U.S. seem less reputable and allowing the enemy Al Qaeda to read the materials. 900 Afghan soldier lives were put at risk, resulting in a warning system being put in place by the Pentagon for those in danger (Mora, 2017). This indirect aid to the enemy brought upon six charges under the Espionage Act. An argument has been posed that this was meant to give the American people transparency by allowing them to become more aware of government involvement. This disclosure of information unfortunately has led to endangerment of citizens, with some believing that not all data needs to be disclosed if it is for the greater

Civil Disobedience Essay Examples

Civil Disobedience Civil disobedience can be a touchy subject for some, but it is a topic that needs to be addressed, not ignored. This country was founded on the knowledge that laws, if declared unjust by the people, could be protested and with the gain of enough support, overthrown. The Founding Fathers saw that on certain things and at certain times, a government may become corrupted, unconnected with its people, or just simply stuck in their ways. There are many examples of all of these circumstances…

Words 750 - Pages 3

Peaceful Resistance To Laws: Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.

Peaceful resistance to laws has many effects on the free society. They can be positive, negative, short term, long term, or a combination of the four. The civil rights movement, which lasted from 1954 to 1968, was the best demonstration of this combination. A lot of times, civil disobedience is necessary to achieve civil goals. In order to receive positive outcomes, we have to go through a struggle and that struggle may be peaceful resistance. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. showed us this and elaborated…

Words 501 - Pages 3

Disobedience In The Civil Rights Movement

freedom for all who reside there. Certain laws can be combated to enforce this title, or may infringe upon it. There are multiple examples of civil disobedience that contain mixed outcomes for protesters. These include the Boston Tea Party, the fights that produced amendments I and IV, and the Civil Rights Movement. One of the most well known acts of disobedience by Americans took place in 1773 when merchants sold smuggled Dutch tea as the British East India Company established a monopoly on tea in…

Words 796 - Pages 4

Martin Luther King Unjust

While King is best known for his advocacy of nonviolent resistance, King's actions clearly illustrate that he was willing to confront unjust laws and systems with the use of direct civil disobedience, even if it meant facing legal consequences. This is shown when King once remarked, “Ordinarily, a person leaving a courtroom with a conviction behind him would wear a somber face, but I left with a smile. I knew that I was a convicted criminal…

Words 1576 - Pages 7

Gandhi Act Of Deviance Essay

thus a formal negative sanction from the government (History.com 2010). Although he received a negative reaction from the government, he started a movement to fight the injustice which inspired thousands to follow him in his nonviolent march, therefore a positive reaction from the people. Gandhi’s movement has made a lasting effect. His nonviolent tactic inspired other leaders around the world. For instance, Martin Luther King Jr. followed Gandhi’s civil disobedience method for the civil rights movement…

Words 779 - Pages 4

Differences Between Civil Disobedience And Terrorism

However, rebellions developed into two different types during the process of development: civil disobedience and terrorism. These two types have distinct characteristics and people’s opinions about them are quite diverse too. People always feel sympathetic about the protesters when they are talking about civil disobedience. The society regard civil disobedience as the…

Words 1382 - Pages 6

Civil Disobedience Controversy

despotic rulers to contemporary civil rights movements opposing institutionalized discrimination. This demonstrates the natural human spirit of perseverance and the desire for a more just and equitable society. Disobedience has served as both a catalyst for productive change, but also a flashpoint for controversy. These points of controversy concerning both intelligent and civil disobedience raise the questions of the productivity of disobedience. Ultimately, disobedience may promote great, positive…

Words 1771 - Pages 8

Civil Disobedience And The Civil Rights Movement

Everyone in their lifetime has been disobedient, whether that be over a trivial matter or one of significance. Disobedience is typically regarded with a negative connotation of being anti-conformity; denotative meaning a deviation from societal regulations. However, disobedience is the spark that ignites the wildfire to significant progression as a society. Disobedience is revolutionary, it does not end until a change is made to quell its desire for deviation. Consequently, with deviation of societal…

Words 834 - Pages 4

Resistance To The Civil Rights Movement

leaders such as Mohandas K. Gandhi, Martin Luther King, Jr., and through the civil rights movement. But when misused, we get bad outcomes, as we have seen in recent events, such as the ‘Black Lives Matter’ movement and even protests about our presidential election. “In our constitution it states that we have the rights to speak, broadcast, assemble, and petition requires that you respect the right of others to do the same.” (Civil Discourse and Petitioning) If we do not let others speak,…

Words 796 - Pages 4

Civil Disobedience In Colonial America

the nature of humans disobeying authority based on their own beliefs and opinions. Disobedience can act in many different ways, whether it’s a small-scale fight between a teenager and their parents, or it goes all the way back to 1848 at the Seneca Falls Convention when Elizabeth Cady Santon was speaking out against the government and society of America in order to establish the representation…

Words 1417 - Pages 6