Negative Essay On Taking Sides

Submitted By georgetaco
Words: 709
Pages: 3
Open Document
Hau Tao Garcia 1

James Garcia
George Tao
Kevin Hau
IB History, Per. 3
19 May 2014
Taking Sides Essay: LaFeber Thesis: By looking at two supporting arguments and a counter argument, we can see how
LeFeber’s argument that the US forced the Caribbean nations to be economically dependent on them is stronger than Healy’s argument. In LaFeber’s argument, LaFeber brings up the idea of neodependency ­ the theory that the US used to gain informal control over the Caribbean nations. This dependency is defined as “a way of looking at Latin American development… but as part of an international system in which the leader powers… have used their economic strength to make Latin American development dependent on… the interests of those leading powers” (146). This idea of neodependency summarizes LaFeber’s views of US foreign policy ­ the view that US’s foreign policy is used to make the Caribbean economically dependent on them rather than actually assist them. The economic aspect that LaFeber argues for is also mentioned in neodependency since Latin America’s main export crops’ prices are completely dependent on the international marketplace. As a result, the Caribbean nations are forced to grow ‘money crops’ such as bananas and coffee in order to sustain their economy and nutritious crops are not grown. Consequently, malnutrition and starvation is a problem in the Caribbean. These results show the US intervention, rather than assisting the Caribbean cause, is actually a hindrance towards them and through neodependency, the US causes these nations to become dependent on the US.
LaFeber’s argument is also backed up by the fact that the US. was in critical need of the Panama Canal with mainly economical reasons as well as some military reasons. In order for the US. to have a canal they must first have control of the region where the canal is located and because the Latin American countries at that time extremely unstable, US. felt the need to make sure they had control over those countries whether it would be through economic ties or military usage. Theodore Roosevelt’s Big Stick policy was an example of this. Latin American countries would have to use the US. controlled canal to ship their products, so in the event that a Latin American country started a revolution that the US. did not like, they could close the canal which could damage that country’s economy severely.
Therefore, by having all of this economic control within the Caribbean region, the US. could make the Latin American countries economically dependent upon the US. The Panama Canal was vital to the US. in that it gave the US. control over that region, both economically and militarily. These foreign policies that would come after Roosevelt would further the economic control and Panama Canal was the only the first.
LaFeber’s strong argument towards the United
Show More

Related Documents: Negative Essay On Taking Sides

United States Declaration of Independence and United States Essay

The American Revolution was a political upheaval during the last half of the 18th century in which thirteen colonies in North America joined together to break from the British Empire, combining to become the United States of America. They first rejected the authority of the Parliament of Great Britain to govern them from overseas without representation, and then expelled all royal officials. By 1775 each colony had established a Provincial Congress or an equivalent governmental institution to govern…

Words 560 - Pages 3

Reconstruction Era of the United States and United States Essay

them food and clothing, medical care, Reconstruction - The rebuilding of the South Ten Percent Plan - 1863, gave Southern states the right to form a new government if 10% of its voters swore loyalty to the United States. This government would be required to abolish slavery. Amnesty - Government pardon Wade-Davis Bill - 1864, required a majority of white men in each other state to swear loyalty to the Union. It also denied the right to vote or hold office to any people who volunteered in support of…

Words 1357 - Pages 6

The Power Of The United States

Amber Gullo The United states was established as democratic republic based on the priciples found in the Constitution.Throughout the period from 1787 to 1865,as the national gorvernment increased its power,The United States attempted to maintain a seperation of powers in which the purposes of government could be fullfilled and th epowers of government would be the powers of government would be distributed amongst state and federal levels. The general government assumes undelegated powers…

Words 444 - Pages 2

Education In The United States

Education in the United States Terrell Williams Economic History 518 Professor Murry March 19, 2011 No one can argue that the United States economy has been a volatile force throughout history. The U.S has suffered from a roller coaster of economic droughts and economic booms. Although there have been many speculations made about what may have lead the way for the U.S economy to grow, education tends to stand out among the rest. From the early 1900’s to the late 1940’s, education…

Words 2615 - Pages 11

Poverty In The United States

The definition of poverty, as stated by the Merriam-Webster dictionary, is “the state of one who lacks a usual or socially acceptable amount of money or material possessions.” Some main causes of poverty include disease, natural disaster, over population, and lack of education (Causes of Poverty). According to “The World Bank,” over 1.2 billion individuals live in extreme poverty, under 1.25 dollars a day, and approximately 2 billion live on less than 2 dollars a day (Poverty Overview). Many organizations…

Words 501 - Pages 3

Crime In The United States

The United States was built on crime and now more than ever it is as though they benefit from making criminals. Now it seems like companies as well as the government are benefiting from prisoners going to jail, because they get criminals to work for less money than they have to pay other people who are not in jail. Often times criminals going into jail come out better criminals, leaving them less functional in todays society. This sometimes results with them going back to prison. The government…

Words 501 - Pages 3

United States Essay

’s tyrannical rule, the United States had no form of government. The Articles of Confederation were drafted at the Continental Congress to create some form of order. However, the Articles were weak. America’s leaders met at the Constitutional Convention to draft a new document, the Constitution. The Constitution fixed issues the Articles helped to create, beginning with the legislature. The Articles of Confederation were weak and unstructured. They gave the states too much power, and did not unify the country…

Words 519 - Pages 3

Intersectionality In The United States

In the United States, a prominent argument is about what profession has the most vital jobs in our society. Some notable examples of professions include celebrities for providing us with the entertainment we frequently crave, politicians for running our government so it could be suited to serve us, and doctors for providing us with the resources we need to maintain satisfactory health. While all these professions are imperative for our society to function, one profession that people typically skim…

Words 669 - Pages 3

Poverty In The United States

Poverty Research Poverty is the state in being poor. It is a major complication in today's world especially in the United States. Poverty has destroyed families, children’s lives, and has caused serious issues for a long period of time. There has been many changes and attempts to solve hardship in America over the past few decades and it hasn’t fully been solved. 14.5 percent of all Americans are in povery and lack material possessions and money. Being in poverty includes financial hardship, hunger…

Words 679 - Pages 3

Homelessness In The United States

Homelessness is a problem that is prevalent in the United States. At any given time in the year of 2012, up to 630,000 people were declared homeless, or without a stable living area. Because of their unstable living conditions, homeless people may have a variety of healthcare issues that they cannot adequately afford care for. Some of those conditions might include drug addiction, mental illness, and other common injuries. Diabetes and hypertension are two of the diseases that are known to occur…

Words 524 - Pages 3