Essay on Perspectives and Torture on the War of Terrorism

Submitted By cpate9891
Words: 743
Pages: 3
Open Document
Perspectives on Torture and the War on Terrorism

Perspectives on Torture and the War on Terrorism
Yoo defined torture as an act committed upon a person with specific intensions to cause him/her severe mental or physical pain or suffering by another person acting under the color of law, and has his custody or physical control. This pain must not be as a result of lawful sanctions. This type of definition that Yoo uses is “threatening” and is unlawful. President Obama however, would oppose the use of torture. On the other hand, Luban, would say Yoo ignores the law models and war models if they deny terrorist suspects protection as required.
Yoo says, in order to convict a defendant of torture the prosecution must have establish that the torture occurred outside the United States, the defendant acted under the color of law, he victim was within the custody of the defendant, the pain or suffering should be intended.
Torture is performed on victims to obtain information or confession, to punish them, for intimidation, or for discrimination.
Mental pain is effected by intentional or threatened infliction of severe physical or mental pain, administration or threatened administration of mind altering substances or methods that disrupt senses or personality, threat of imminent death or threat that another person will be immediately subjected to death.
Luban raised two models; first is the war model, which supports the use of lethal force on enemy troops irrespective of whether they were personally involved with the adversary. Also, killing of non-combatants is allowed when collateral damage is foreseen even if unintended. The evidence and proof is drastically weaker and attacks on the enemy are done irrespective of what he/she has done. Disadvantages in war model are that fighting back is a legitimate response, and as some nations resolve on fighting others may decide to be neutral. Also, “Prisoners of war who refuse to answer (questions) may not be threatened, insulted, or exposed to unpleasant or disadvantageous treatment of any kind,” The Third Geneva Convention.
In the law model however, criminals don’t get a shoot back. Any acts of violence from them subject them to legitimate punishment. If a criminal here was in war but politically and morally innocent, his rights are violated.
Even though, terrorists should be entitled to the due process like in the case of suicide bombers and terrorists, this poses danger to innocent civilians, and they deserve condemnation and punishment. Similarly, in a case like war is considered, we can say that harassments and tortures could in some way violate the rights of soldier when he/she is morally and political innocent and just fights as an order.
The U.S is accused of choosing the bits of law model and the bits of war model that best suits their interests to handle terrorists ignoring the remaining bits.
President Obama argues that the brutal methods of
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Perspectives and Torture on the War of Terrorism

Essay on Opposing Sides of Counterterrorism

Modernization, moral panic, globalization on issues of security and crime prevention The terrorist attacks of September 9, 2001 became the beginning and also the creation of the “war on terror,” which would go on to last ten years. The controversial methods in which the United States attempted to attain their power and win this war had people both outraged and yet made people more patriotic towards America. The loss of liberties was significant and people either complied or attempted to fight back. However…

Words 718 - Pages 3

Is Devine's Is Torture Ever Justified?

Assignment 8 — Rough Drafts It is universally acknowledged that torture, regarded as a kind of crime, is prohibited in any circumstances according to the human rights law. However, the fact is that it is still widely used around the world especially in third world nations’ military regimes. Therefore, the question “Is Torture Ever Justified?” has been put forward which evoked a heated debate. As professor Bagaric and Clarke claims, torture need to be regulated in some circumstances instead of totally…

Words 1159 - Pages 5

war on terrorism Essay

War on Terrorism and the effect on The US Patriot Act Ashley Anthony In an interview Vice President Dick Cheney remarked that the United States was less safe since Obama changed the detention and interrogation practices of enemy combatants saying that the change was a move towards treating terrorism as a law enforcement problem. Cheney argued that terrorism is a strategic threat that could only be addressed by using all wartime assets against the enemy (NY Times). During this interview…

Words 2199 - Pages 9

Matt Taibbi: Film Analysis

Oscar-nominated war film has proved to be derogatory, insulting and bias. You have mentioned that it was produced as an attempt to show soldiers suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder and hardships an army faces to get used to civilian life in the following quote, “I think it’s nice for veterans, because it shows what they go through, and that life — and the wives and families of veterans. It has a great indication of the stresses they are under. And I think that all adds up to kind of an anti-war”. But…

Words 1163 - Pages 5

Shame: Michael Haneke and Collective Memory Essays

number of refugees, ending over a century of French colonisation after nearly a decade of war, the Algerian war of independence possesses an obscure position in the French collective memory. Often described as the ‘unnamed war’ the Algerian war of independence alongside French colonisation as a whole provides a pivotal point in French history, dividing opinion and bringing to debate not just the banalities of war and the horrific methods used within such conflicts but also the ideas of individual and…

Words 2870 - Pages 12

Euskadi Ta Askatasuna Case Study

conflict is in prison or had to leave the Basque Country and secondly, the solution would be to adapt the forces that took part in the armed confrontation to new situation of Basque country freely and with no threats. The Spanish history related to terrorism reveals that once a terrorist movement has taken roots, the way a democratic state can defeat it, is through a resolute and prolonged effort in which any departure from democratic principles in…

Words 1816 - Pages 8

Sons Of Liberty Dbq

Revolutionary War and should be looked upon with respect. However, looking at it from British perspective the view of the Sons of Liberty would change. The definition of treason is when a single person or group goes against their legal government and attempts to murder or overthrow them (Oxford Dictionaries). The British correctly recognized this group committing acts of treason and it can be proven through their rebellions, reactions to the taxes, and looking at the situation from British perspective. First…

Words 1838 - Pages 8

Essay on PSCI 153 Syllabus Spring 2015

topically, looking at how international institutions and law function in various arenas of international affairs. Topics include collective security institutions such as the League of Nations, the United Nations, and NATO; human rights law; the laws of war; humanitarian intervention; international justice and the International Criminal Court; environmental law; international trade law and the World Trade Organization; economic development and the role of the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank…

Words 1849 - Pages 8

V For Vendetta Themes

V for Vendetta an in-depth analysis Paul Eggington Vanguard University Abstract V for Vendetta has been a work in progress since its first publish of the comic in 1982. It has been considered the brainchild of Alan Moore, who is now considered one of the greatest comic book writers of all time. In 2005 the comic was adapted into a feature length film highlighting the importance of liberty, individual choice, freedom, and the damage a totalitarian government can have on its people.…

Words 2711 - Pages 11

Bernie Sanders Argumentative Analysis

People’s palms are sweating, legs are bouncing and hearts are beating so quickly that they can hear their heart beat while watching TV. They are praying whomever they voted for will win. However, the host is taking his/her time in telling the audience who the winner is, which leads to them cursing at the TV and screaming “come on, get over with it”. The host gives the viewers a big smile and says the next sentence in very slow motion, “and the next president of United States is….” Every 4 years…

Words 1278 - Pages 6