Essay about Power of Supreme Court

Words: 919
Pages: 4
Open Document
The Power of the Supreme Court Cannot be Justified in a Democracy (45)

The US Supreme Court has a number of powers. These include the power to declare acts of Congress, the executive or state legislatures unconstitutional through the power of judicial review. The supreme court justices are also given the power to interpret the constitution when making decisions, again, through their power of judicial review. It is arguable that it is essential for the supreme court to have such powers in order to allow the American democracy to flourish. However, there is much evidence to suggest that the supreme court holds too much power for an unelected body, thus hindering democracy.

The ambiguity of the constitution means that there is much room …show more content…
This is far more undemocratic than allowing the supreme court to exercise their power of judicial review as it prevents tyranny of a single branch of government.

Furthermore, the power of the Supreme Court is actually very limited due to the checks and balances system set up by the founding fathers. Congress has the power of impeachment. This means that should any of the justices overstep their power, or cause corruption, Congress can impeach them. In 1968 Associate Justice Abe Fortas resigned just before facing certain impeachment. Although impeachment is very rare, the constant threat of impeachment ensures that justices are simply interpreting the constitution rather than acting in their own interest which preserves a democracy.
There are also checks by the president on the supreme court. The president has the power to nominate the justices and therefore has the power to influence the philosophy of the supreme court. There has been an evident change in the philosophy of the court between 1968 and 2008. The court has moved from being mostly appointed by Democratic presidents like Roosevelt and Kennedy to a more Conservative court appointed by Republican presidents like Raegan and Bush. Obama replaced Conservative Souter with Liberal Sotomayor in 2009. This check is good for a democracy because it means that the philosophy of the court is likely to reflect the philosophy of the president
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Power of Supreme Court

Scope for Congress and the Supreme Court to Limit Powers of the President Essay

what extent can Congress and the Supreme Court limit the powers of the President? The president of the United States is definitely a very power figure. But he is not as powerful as most of us would think. There are other powers that can stop the president from making several decisions such as the Supreme Court and Congress of the United States. This essay will tell about the role of president and the powers that are restricted by the Congress and the Supreme Court. The president has a lot of…

Words 657 - Pages 3

Marbury V. Madison: A Landmark Case In The United States

that originally decided the power of the Supreme Court. In the case, William Marbury was attempting to force James Madison to deliver his appointment papers, making Marbury a justice of the peace. The case was the first case where the Supreme Court ruled an act of congress to be unconstitutional. The case did not allow the Supreme Court to make its own law, but only decide which laws were constitutional. This case set the ground work for the power of the Supreme Court for future cases. At the…

Words 509 - Pages 3

The Supreme Courts In Taking Law Seriously By Barry Friedman

The Supreme Court of the United States is the highest institution of the judicial branch of the U.S. Government. According to Barry Friedman in his article, “Taking Law Seriously”, we must understand the powers of the Supreme Court in order to understand how it effects national policy and law. The U.S. Supreme Court has the power of judicial review; thus, they can handle and determine the constitutionality of a law or executive decision. This power is enacted to settle constitutional debates on issues…

Words 658 - Pages 3

John Marshall: Chief Justice Of The Supreme Court

law for six weeks, is the best known chief justice of the Supreme Court. He was appointed by President John Adams in 1801 and held that position until his death in 1835. As chief justice, he stuck with his federalist’s views and helped shape the Supreme Court into what it is today. Federalism is the system used to divide the powers between the national and state government, and Marshall’s court is important today because he defined the powers between the federal and state governments. Although the…

Words 421 - Pages 2

Marbury V. Madison: The Most Important Cases In The United States

Marbury v. Madison is seen as one of the most important cases in the United States that had set certain important landmarks and changes in the judiciary branch. The case was brought in front of the US Supreme Court with John Marshall as Chief Justice. The case came in front of the US Supreme Court by a petition from William Marbury. In the petition, he demanded his role as a Justice of the Peace in the District of Columbia, which was granted to him by President John Adams on his last days in the…

Words 926 - Pages 4

Marbury Vs Madison Case Summary

The case of Marbury v. Madison claimed the Supreme Court’s right of judicial review. Considering the balance of power of the federal branches of government, do you think that the Supreme Court gained supreme power through this decision? The Marbury v. Madison was a historical case in 1803. Which demonstrated the people of the country the ability that the Supreme Court had to invalidate laws passed by congress and even alter decisions made by the executive and legislative branches. This case began…

Words 533 - Pages 3

Balance Of Power In The United States

As James Madison once said in Federalist No. 51 ““the power surrendered by the people” would be “divided between two distinct governments,” creating a balance of power that would enable the “different governments [to] control each other” (Gaylord 1). There are many different types of societies all throughout the world and this one society is one that triumphs all. A society of over 300 million people who are free to do many things under the law they live in. They have a choice about where they want…

Words 1832 - Pages 8

Pros And Cons Of Marbury Vs Madison

of America, there have been many court cases that have helped shape and form the laws of the land in which we live. In 1803, Supreme Court Justice John Marshall, had to make a ruling on the case Marbury vs. Madison, which is considered to be one of the most important decisions ever made concerning judicial power within the history of the United States of America. (US Courts.) When the U.S. Constitution was written, there was only an establishment of a Supreme Court and its duties. Congress was left…

Words 1159 - Pages 5

Judicial System Essay

boundaries or rules of the United States Constitution. The main powers of the judicial branch include interpreting the U.S. Constitution and laws, making sure laws are put into action, and judicial review. Judicial review means that they have the power to review whether or not a law is constitutional and then they can accept it or disallow it. The most powerful part of the judicial branch is the head of it, called the Supreme Court, because it is in charge of reviewing all the laws and determining…

Words 570 - Pages 3

Marbury Vs Madison Supreme Court Case

The Supreme Court case of Marbury v. Madison took place in 1803 under the presidency of Thomas Jefferson. The reason for this case was the petitioning of William Marbury, who was appointed last-minute Justice of the Peace by John Adams, but the commissions were not delivered by the Secretary of State James Madison. The Court ultimately ruled in favor of Madison, and the Jefferson administration. However, the point that the podcast makes is that the decision of the case was not just a simple rejection…

Words 550 - Pages 3