Race Sentencing Essay

Submitted By Labrujitamex1
Words: 1443
Pages: 6
Open Document
Running head: Race 1

Race Sentencing

Jessica Arreola

Stephanie Velona

ENG 122

Justice is supposed to be color blind but often we find ourselves questioning this statement. According to the Bureau of Justice, people of color make up about 30% of the population in the United States, however account for 60% of the population in prison. Can it be that our country built for individuals freedom and for equal opportunity really just act in unfair ways towards minorities? In order to fully be able to answer this question, we must examine the racial disparity in the imposition of sentencing. The U.S fails to deliver on the democratic ideal that the U.S Criminal Justice System ensures fairness and equality to all under the law.
The United States is said to have the best justice system in the world. Many people have brought up the question as to whether or not the judicial branch operates equally and within their right protocols, or if there seem to be cracks in the system that will often let certain races fall through. Perhaps the most crucial evidence that supports the argument of racial inequality, would be all the statistics. As mentioned earlier, people of color make up only 30% of the population in the United States, but are responsible for 60% of the population in prison. Studies show that 47% of drug related crimes were committed by white people, however white people make up only 20% of mandatory drug convictions while the other 80% are made up of minorities. Studies by the Department of Justice also show that minorities are three times more likely to get pulled over on a routine traffic stop, and are four times more than likely to experience the use of force during their stop. According to the Bureau of Justice, there were about 242,000 school related referrals to law enforcement, yet out of those 96,000 that became arrests, minorities made up 70% of the arrests. The district attorney states that there are three main contributing factors that they look for in each case in order to determine the most reasonable sentence in accordance to the crime. One being, financial stability, the second – how well of a family support system the offender has, and third – the criminal themselves. These three factors can be the reasons why the numbers are they way that they are. Justice works best to those who can pay for it. Finances are a contributing factor to these statistics. A criminals sentence can be greatly impacted due to financial reasons. Someone with more money has the resources to hire a better lawyer as opposed to someone who has a public defender appointed to them by the court. Public Defender's usually have too many cases assigned to them, to be able to put much time, effort, and energy into each individual case. The area in which someone lives also plays a role. Minorities usually are the main population in more rural areas. There tends to be more schools in rural areas, and if a crime is committed near school grounds then it adds on to the severity of the crime. A strong family support system also plays a role. If the criminal goes into court with a strong family supporting him, then it gives off the impression that the criminal will have more support and positive influence to do positive and stay away from crime. Ultimately it is the district attorney who decides where the case will take the criminal. In each case, it is the prosecutors decision to consider offering the offender a plea bargain. Then it is the district attorney’s decision to consider whether the offender can be referred for treatment rather than imprisonment. Often minorities do not fit the certain image that the district attorney considers a possible opportunity to better themselves. Even with all the deciding
Show More

Related Documents: Race Sentencing Essay

Literatuire review Essay

analyses provide insight on minorities’ differential treatment in the judicial system causing severe sentencing disparities. Racial Disparity in Sentencing In the study Patterns of Death: An Analysis of Racial Disparities in Capital Sentencing and Homicide victimization, the authors Samuel Gross and Robert Mauro examine the effect race plays in Capital Sentencing. This study observes 8 states sentencing of capital punishment under the post-Furman death penalty laws. The 8 states used in the study were…

Words 4273 - Pages 18

Social Construction

Introduction The concept of race has long been discredited as a legitimate biological marker of difference. Instead, it is viewed as a construct, shaped and sustained by societal forces and historical events. This social construction of race has played an important role in creating and maintaining power dynamics that benefit some groups while oppressing others. According to Thompson and Newell (2021), the disproportionate incarceration rates of Black and Brown populations are more than a statistical…

Words 1366 - Pages 6

Summary Of Ethan's Sentence

that a psychologist declared and presented Ethan’s condition in court is “why” he received his sentence. Most importantly, the “how” and “why” of being born with a silver spoon greatly benefited his sentencing that enable him to “possibly” throw his status into the sentencing. Consequently, his sentencing teaches us about our society that when you grow up with a silver spoon in your mouth you most likely would get off easier compared to others without a silver spoon in their mouths. So,…

Words 775 - Pages 4

Case 4 Random Juror

EMPATHY, AND SENTENCING IN DEATH PENALTY CASES Introduction For as long as the judicial system has been around, there has always been a presence of bias in regard to incarceration and sentencing procedures. This is because the judicial system “focuses its attention on the core values of symbolic legality of criminal procedure, rather than on the biased outcomes that these procedures produce which, as a result, allows for and perpetuates racial discrimination under the guise of ‘race neutral’ procedures…

Words 1494 - Pages 6

Gender Disparities In The Criminal Justice System

There are many indicators of the huge impact in disparities in sentencing women as compared to men and more so when it revolves around minorities ( race and class). Though there are lower crime rates among women as compared to men, there are significant disparities which tend to show favouritism to women. Research has shown that men get 63 per cent longer custodial sentences than women. In addition, it is twice more likely to have women get non custodial sentences even after conviction. However,…

Words 1377 - Pages 6

Racial Disparity In The Criminal Justice System

decide sentencing. There could be a lot of variables that come into play such as, criminal history and the severity of the offense. Unfortunately there is a possibility that race also comes into play. Our nation's correctional facilities were originally created to withhold citizens that have not obeyed the law(s) applied to them by our government. In the vast majority of cases, the race of the victim tends to have an effect on the sentence outcome. However, in some jurisdictions, the race of the…

Words 1647 - Pages 7

Post-Racialization Of Race

been a new phenomenon that has been dubbed as the current state of race in this nation, post-racial society. Lydia Lum, in “The Obama Era: A Post-racial Society?” (2009), defines a post-racial society, as a society that “race matters much less than it used to, that the boundaries of race have been overcome, that racism is no longer a big problem” (p.1). However, if we were to review the Fair Sentencing Act of 2010, and the sentencing…

Words 160 - Pages 1

Discrimination In Criminal Court Cases

and individuals by distinguishing someone based on their race, gender or ethnicity. A significant part of this argument is concerned with the historical records of discrimination, but people fail to mention the opposite side of the spectrum that deals with the defendant's records and reasons to why they committed the crime. Many scholars include the records and reasons of the crime as the main thing that is considered in criminal sentencing, but this is not the case.…

Words 255 - Pages 2

Mandatory Minimum Sentencing Reform

Reform From various perspectives, the courtroom is perceived as too harsh and unbalanced in terms of race. This has caused an increase in the prison population and a major uproar over how courtrooms and sentencing should be managed. Abolishing minimum mandatory sentencing laws and reducing bail for non-violent crimes will result in fairness and equality in the courtrooms. First, mandatory minimum sentencing guidelines should be removed because they require people who commit non-violent crimes to serve…

Words 513 - Pages 3

Supreme Court Case: The Loving Vs. Virginia Case

The Loving v. Virginia case involved the supreme court's intervention on a case that saw an interracial marriage lead to the sentencing of both Mildred and Richard Loving to one year of jail for the crime of violating an Anti-miscegenation state law in Virginia. At the time of the case, 1967, 16 states had similar Anti-miscegenation laws that essentially banned legal marriages between interracial couples. The state of Virginia’s argument as to why the law was constitutional claimed that because both…

Words 305 - Pages 2