Rene Descartes Ontological Argument

Words: 127

Pages: 1

In Meditations on First Philosophy, Rene Descartes gives arguments for the existence of God. In one of Descartes’ versions of the ontological argument, he tries to prove God exists in four premises. I will summarize then criticize Descartes’ argument.
Descartes says in premise one that the cause of an idea must have at least as much formal reality as the idea has objective reality. Premise two says that something cannot come from nothing. In premise three, Descartes says he has an idea of God as the most perfect being, having infinite objective reality. He follows this with premise four, saying that nothing has enough formal reality to cause this idea of God as the most perfect being other than God himself. Therefore, he concludes, that God

Show More

Kant's Objections That Existence Is Not A Predicate

The ontological argument can never over come Kant’s objections that existence is not a predicate [10 marks] The ontological argument is the argument that God exists because he is a necessity, a being in which nothing greater can be thought of. There are several different philosophers who have adapted the ontological argument: from Anselm who agrees that God is the greatest being possible. To the Cartesian argument, which was a version of the ontological argument from Rene Descartes, who famously…

Words 379 - Pages 2

Thinking Things And Extended Things

Student ID - 10011675 8. Descartes argued that there were either ‘thinking things’ or ‘extended things’. What were the consequences for sociological theory? Throughout sociological theory Descartes is known for his Cartesian dualism theory which states two different sorts of beings. Thinking things which are the subjects and extended things which are objects. The subject is defined as the conscious mind and the object would be the world of objects, which consist of height, weight, colour and so…

Words 2957 - Pages 12

God exist? Essay

October 27th 2014 Does God exist? Descartes’ fifth Meditation argument for God's existence relies on an untenable notion that existence is a perfection and that it can be predicated of God. I shall first explain what Descartes’ argument for God's existence is, and then present his argument in propositional form. I will then attempt to support the argument that existence is neither a perfection nor a predicate of God. In our thoughts we apprehend ideas of things. These ideas may reside entirely…

Words 1899 - Pages 8

Mark: René Descartes and Real World Essay

(C) Descartes’ Cosmological Argument There are two main steps in Descartes’ version of the cosmological argument: firstly, a proof that we possess the idea of God, and secondly, that the cause of that idea can only be God himself. (a) The Idea of God In the Third Meditation, Descartes considers his ideas, and finds that all of them, except the idea of God, cannot come from without. His idea of God is of an all-perfect being and he can be sure of this because he knows that he himself is imperfect…

Words 1291 - Pages 6

Descartes Proof Of God

Section I: Cartesian Proofs of God Descartes posits two distinct but related proofs of God’s existence. The first is commonly known as the ontological argument, the simplest version of which would more or less boil down to: (major premise) We have an idea of God, (minor premise) our idea of God includes His necessary and eternal existence, (conclusion) therefore God does exist, necessarily and eternally (Principles of Philosophy Part I, 14). The second argument Descartes posits is a bit more complicated…

Words 1002 - Pages 5

Religion, Science and the Universe Essay

the existence of God has been discussed for as long as man’s history, many arguments have been put across trying to prove it. One of the strongest argument for the existence of God is the ontological argument that was formulated by philosophers among them Rene Descartes and St. Anselm. The ontological argument suggests the proof that God exists is self-evident and can be perceived by any man of sound mind. This argument highlights that God is the greatest imaginable in the minds of human beings…

Words 1443 - Pages 6

Essay about God cannot be proved

The Mysterious God The need or desire to worship and revere seems to be inherent in man. We have always been spiritual beings, praising the gods and fearing the demons. We have always held deep beliefs regarding the afterlife and our nature. For centuries, the idea of a God has been a part of mankind’s history. Its human nature to attempt to intellectually analyze, criticize and evaluate the information in which we come in contact. However, we often struggle with matters regarding “eternity” because…

Words 2301 - Pages 10