Sale Of Organs Analysis

Words: 930
Pages: 4
Open Document
Comparison of View’s on a Market on Sale of Organ Organs for transplant is an operation moving an organ from one organism (the donor) to another (the recipient). In current society, it is a shortage of organs for the operation. For example, the number of people who are awaiting kidneys is about 40,000 in 1998. There are two ways to take organs. One way is to take organs from a living body. Other one is that to take organs from a dead body. Recently, people discuss that the way to increase organs is a market of organs. The sale of organs for transplants is forbidden by law on current society. There are two authors and arguments about selling and purchasing organs; Richard A. Epstein writes “The Sale of Organs for Transplants Should Be Legalized” …show more content…
According to Epstein, it fairly allows buying and selling organs to save everyone’s life (66). This means that saving a life is more important than creating the economic gap between the rich and the poor. In addition, if it raises a financial issue which is a huge difference between poor people and rich people by making a market for the sale of an organ, the government imposes a tax on selling organ. Unlike Epstein, Childress regards as an issue that the disparity between wealth and poverty goes on widening. Childress says that “creating a market in organ procurement places poor and disadvantaged people at risk for coercion and exploitation” (68). It is unfair for those people to provide organs on organ transplants because it is possible that those people forcibly are robbed and sold their organs by the rich. Also, poor people likely sell their organs to rich people for money in society which the sale of organs for transplants is allowed. In other words, the gap between rich and poor spreads wider by legalizing the sale of organs. Therefore, it occurs economic issues between the rich and the …show more content…
Epstein notes that “the poor and the disadvantaged will not be sought after, let alone exploited, because they do not make candidates for organ transfer” (65). His view about organ transplants is subjective because there does not have the evidence of this part. Also, this proves that it allows us to discriminate in favor of the rich. However, Childress’ opinion on the sale of organs is clear to understand. Childress argues that the property of the current system of donation is made up of the relation with altruism, actions of ethical preference and fairness of others (72). Because of this, the current system of donation can provide organs for transplants. So, by changing from the current system of donation to an organ sales, human body goes on tool for money, it decreases altruism and the risk of coercion and exploitation is for the poor. As a result, it diminishes the number of organs in the market on the sale of organs. Because of these, Childress’s opinion of the sale of organs is more persuasive than Epstein’s
Show More

Related Documents: Sale Of Organs Analysis

Rhetorical Analysis Of Organ Sales Will Save Lives

In the article, “Organ Sales Will saves Lives” Joanna Mackay wrote about how she would legalize organ donations. Mackay states that this day in time people use dialysis, which is harsh, expensive, and only temporary. Mackay had been making it her own personal goal to where it would be possible to legalize organ donating so that the person who is choosing to donate organs would have more rights when beginning to do this process. When beginning to read the article, it was very easy to come across how…

Words 720 - Pages 3

Marketing Plan Essay

NUTRILITE has developed more than 10 different kinds of new products and its market segment is growing unceasingly. This maketing plan will first analyse the market in China, considering relevant factors within a market, competitor, customer and SWOT analysis. The mission statement: Achieve great commercial success and help the public to set up correct concept of health, so as to achieve better quality of life. The target market mainly consists of two market segments: Adults who need to supplement…

Words 1953 - Pages 8

Sex Trafficking In The Modern World

Trafficking, a multidimensional and complex socio-legal problem of contemporary times, is the third largest illicit industry after arms and drugs which is horrifyingly decaying the roots of human development across the globe. Women and young girls being most vulnerable to this deadly disease are usually the soft targets who are recruited and transported by the traffickers to be exploited in numerous ways- the ‘commercial sex trade’ being the chief purpose. Trafficking of women for commercial sexual…

Words 1327 - Pages 6

Blood Patterns Essay

several different kinds of analysis which can be performed on each type of physical evidence. Almost all evidence requires one or more types of analysis to yield the most complete information. Most analysis fits into one of the following categories: Types of Analysis Comparison Most types of evidence require a control with which to be compared (example: fingerprints, hairs) Visual If evidence can be utilized or compared through unaided observation, then that analysis is called visual (example:…

Words 2041 - Pages 9

Advance Medical Tech. Corp. Case Study Essay examples

on a massive researching. Taking into account the efforts and allowances spilled by AMT on its research and development aspect, and in invading new markets, it is not unexpected that it had gained an extraordinary growth and rapid expansion of its sales force for just a few years of being established. Like any other companies who were in their infancy/growth stage, it is a normal thing to put the best shoe forward in order to gain an A+ mark. But the aggressiveness nature of the decisions made by…

Words 2641 - Pages 11

CIS 207 Week 2 Individual Assignment Information Use Paper

better planning, decision-making, and results (Pradhan and Pradhan, 2009). Despite the vital nature of information in any organization, there are some information concepts that hinder proper transition of information to all targeted groups or business organs. Notably, as any society is an information society; therefore, every organization is an information organization (Rich, 2010). This concept makes information a basic organizational resource with equal values as money, materials, and personnel. Within…

Words 1050 - Pages 5

Starbucks and Psychological Contract Essay

Table of Contents Introduction 3 Company Background 3 The Case 4 Literature Review 5 Change Theories 5 Leadership 5 Psychological Contract & Motivation 5 Critical Analysis 6 Recommendations 6 References 7 Introduction Changes have never been as fast-paced as in the modern world, driven by technological advancements, consumerism, easy information sharing, and knowledge intensity. Businesses have to be constantly aware of their external environment and of the potential changes…

Words 2446 - Pages 10

Aphasia And Physician-Assisted Suicide Case Study

thoughts, desires, and intents; the capability to read, write, make inquiries and commands reveals the significance. Much of this skill exists in in the left hemisphere of the brain, thus if damage occurs, language is altered. The patient in the case analysis, Mr. Brown displays an acquired condition, the case study reveals he inherited a deformity of his vascular system, surgery was vital because any defects can progress rapidly with age. From prior knowledge, surgery is risky concerning the arteries…

Words 1899 - Pages 8

Npd-Facial Cleanser Essay

survival and growth in the long run. But the development and introduction of new products that will ultimately be profitable is fraught with the risks of heavy up-front expenditures and uncertain future payoffs. A daunting combination of stagnating sales in mature markets, rising costs, and a focus on short term earnings leaves management in a very uneasy position. We…

Words 3754 - Pages 16

Essay about Sense and Stradivarius

follow the latest trends. Performing a thorough analysis of the demand for street collections and providing a touch of fantasy, the product gets closer to the needs of each client cabinet. Stradivarius cares designs, fabrics and accessories for the girl who is moved by the actual and know where to get it. WHAT IS PERCEPTION Perception is the process through which a person forms an opinion about the various stimuli we receives from his sensory organs. In marketing, perception is concerned with understanding…

Words 2036 - Pages 9