Same Sex Parenting Essay

Submitted By sabatinoleah
Words: 1781
Pages: 8
Open Document
Leah Sabatino
Intro to Sociology
Professor Jafar
11/27/12

Bureaucracies and Mental Hospitals

We often judge a book by its cover, and the same connection can be made when we think of mental hospitals and the people who work in them. In Rosenhan’s writings, On Being Sane in Insane Places, he talks about how his five concepts of bureaucracies relate directly to the environment of a mental health hospital. In Weber’s opinion a bureaucracy would run smoothly if it had the following components, efficiency, division of labor, hierarchy of positions, governance obey rules, impersonality and employment based on technical qualifications. The two components I think that are most easily relatable to both Rosenhan’s writings and that we can relate to in our society are hierarchy of positions and impersonality. Hierarchy of positions means that those in a work place who hold a higher rank, think they are better or more valuable than those who are below them. The higher up you are on this ladder means in many cases more benefits. This makes those believe they can treat other workers or patients who are below them with less respect. They maintain a mind set that since they are ‘labeled” as being in higher positions they think they hold more authority and power. Hierarchy of position can be easily defined as a division between workers, where each level is seen as secondary to the one below it. This ranking can also relate to Weber’s other characteristics of bureaucracy, employment based on technical qualifications. Many times, this level separating workers is based on work experience, age and also their advancements they have in that job field. This hierarchy of labor is a result of putting together a group of people based on their ability and skills. In my opinion Weber believes this is a main component of running a bureaucracy because it can drive competition to move up in rank. Also it shows workers who are in lower positions, a model of what it takes to move up. In Rosenhan’s writings this hierarchy of workers is present in many scenarios. For example those who are higher up on the ladder in work situations see those who work under them as lesser, and not as well respected. Same with the workers in mental health hospitals. They think that since these patients are even in here and labeled mentally ill that they shouldn’t receive dignity and respect and are treated more like animals than people. In Rosenhans article, he mentioned how the tempers of the workers where short and they would often beat their patients if they looked at them the wrong way or said something they thought was out of line. “A patient who had not heard for a call for medicine would be roundly excoriated, and the morning attendants would often wake patients with, Come on, you mother f----,s---, out of bed.”(Rosenhan, 256) What makes the workers any different or better than the patients and make them think that they could talk to them like that? In this case, it was simply hierarchy of position. No matter what the patients did it didn’t matter they had no say or opinion, they were seen as inferior. However it is not just hierarchy among patients and workers but also staff themselves. Doctors and nurses, certainly are not held to the same standards. Rosenhan states that those who have the most experience and who are at the top are those who spend the least time with the patients. This is where lower level workers get the idea that this is okay. They assume or learn that if their bosses and doctors don’t need to spend time with the patients and they to want to become doctors and hold higher positions then they should follow suit. The doctors and nurses who work in these mental health hospitals also believe that it is not their fault or issue that their patients are upset and think they are simply just crazy because of their diagnosis. “A nurse coming upon the scene would rarely inquire even curiously into the environment stimuli of the patient’s
Show More

Related Documents: Same Sex Parenting Essay

Does It Really Matter?

the other hand there are also many other couples and single parents in the United States today that have a more unique type of parenting relationship with their partner and children. There are thousands of gay and lesbian parents in the United States today that do all of the same things that a straight couple would do. Thirty seven states in the union have made same-sex marriage legal. Many people across the country are very much so against the idea of gay and lesbian couples having children or…

Words 1512 - Pages 7

Parent and Same-sex Parents Essay

Same-sex Parenting Shaelyn Leckington Comm/215 July 21, 2014 Julie McCabe Same-sex Parenting Everyone should have the opportunity to parent a child, if they wish too. It is an experience unlike many others to have a child. A child to love, nurture, and help mold into an adult. People of all different genders, races, and ethnic backgrounds have been able to adopt children. Even single individuals can adopt a child. However, there is an issue that has made itself known, most of society frowns…

Words 869 - Pages 4

Persuasive Essay On Gay Adoption

judges were not sympathetic to the idea of allowing a homosexual man or woman to parent a no biological child. As the society has become more tolerant toward couples of the same sex, this question arises, should gay marriages adopt? This question leads to a controversial statement in which some people believe that same sex couples should not be allowed to adopt, while others consider that they should. A child needs stability while growing up. It is understandable that the child might feel unaccepted…

Words 758 - Pages 4

Should Homosexual Couples Be Allowed To Raise Children

and a father. Research shows that homosexual parenting is more personal and heartfelt than those of straight parents, and that the children show no more mental issues than children raised by a straight family, and that decreasing the amount of children being raised in orphanages is top priority. Allowing same-sex couples to raise children will increase the rate of adoption, allowing more children to be raised by a proper family. Of the 594,000 same-sex couple households in the United States, 115…

Words 468 - Pages 2

Gay Adoption Research Paper

legalization of same-sex marriage nationwide, but many couples are still having trouble adopting from adoption centers. Many opponents to same-sex parents believe that kids can’t properly grow up in a same-sex household, however, there are plenty of arguments that prove that gay parenting isn’t harmful to children and is just as nurturing as any other household. Same-sex families are neither injurious nor inhibiting…

Words 1537 - Pages 7

Shelby Inquiry and Research Essay

or wrong. There has been much debate on whether same sex couples are fit to be parents. As if their sexual preference is the sole factor in play on parenting. Opponents of gay parenting and adoption often frame their criticisms in terms of what's best for the child without presenting any resounding evidence supporting this claim. Below I hope to dispel the many myths surrounding gay and lesbian parenting and also showcase numerous cases where same sex parents raise successful and well-rounded children…

Words 2610 - Pages 11

Moral And Ethical Standards Of Australian Society In Relation To Family Members

“two or more persons…….who are related by blood, marriage, adoption, step or fostering and who are usually resident in the same household”. The law has taken into recognising and protecting members of alternate family relationships. These relationships include Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ customary law marriages, single-parented families, blended families, same-sex relationships, polygamous marriages, de facto relationships and other family arrangements. Family law relies heavily on…

Words 1003 - Pages 5

Essay on Final Children Of Same Sex Parents

Children Raised by Same-Sex Parents Ashley L. Young Charter College In this day and age children grow up in a variety of familial situations; single parents, grandparents, opposite sex parents, adoptive parents, interracial parents, and same-sex parents to name just a few. Societies “normal” family is evolving and family structure is becoming less about what society expects and more about what works for each individual family. Some parents work full-time and have a grandparent living in their home…

Words 1498 - Pages 6

Essay on Berger 2e Chp06

feelings through uncontrolled physical or verbal outbursts, as by lashing out at other people or breaking things •Internalizing problems – Involves turning one's emotional distress inward, as by feeling excessively guilty, ashamed, or worthless Sex Differences in Emotional Regulation Neurological and hormonal effects •Boys tend to be aggressive (externalizing) •Girls tend to be anxious (internalizing) Psychopathology is not typical! •Children of both sexes usually learn to regulate their emotions…

Words 1935 - Pages 8

Gay Family Research Paper

One version of family that I will be exploring is the homosexual family. I will be exploring the biological, cultural, and social factors that promoted a change in the contemporary family of today; specifically the homosexual, verses heterosexual parenting of today’s modern family. The controversy lies, in which family, provides for the better welfare of the child. This is important in a sense that it will allow for factors that contribute to both to be explored, and altered all in favor of the child’s…

Words 796 - Pages 4