Sinking Boat Essay

Submitted By mirella94
Words: 1018
Pages: 5
Open Document
Professor Potratz
English 100
10/2/2013
Sinking Lifeboat
Garrett Hardin was an American Ecologist who wrote the article “Lifeboat Ethics” in Psychology Today in 1974. Garrett Hardin is a neoconservative with a Doctorate in Biology from Stanford University and has written about how human life is sustained on our planet. By using metaphors, statistics, and cause and effect, Hardin attempts to sway the audience opinion on the world food bank but fails to do so.
Hardin uses metaphors such as a lifeboat and a spaceship to represent the U.S. and planet earth. A lifeboat can only hold so many people and before it exceeds the capacity and a spaceship does not exclude anyone but limits the resources for everybody. In the lifeboat are many of the rich nations such as the U.S. and the United Nations and outside in the water are many of the poor countries like Colombia, Ecuador, Venezuela, and Pakistan. Since the U.S. is considered one of the rich nations they are considered the rich passengers among the boat which will be able to stay, the poorer countries will remain outside and only allowed if there is any room in the lifeboat. If the boat has enough space for fifty passengers then only fifty passengers will be allowed but if our “conscience stricken” side comes out then we possibly may allow more passengers. Suppose we allow ten more passengers we have now lost the safety factor on the lifeboat just as if we allow the country to overpopulate then we can lose the safety factor that we have within our nation. This is relating to how the United States is involved in the World Food Bank by being one of the richest nations in the world we provide to the food bank giving emergency resources but we might possibly lose our resources and lose our safety just like the passengers on the boat who have offered more space on the lifeboat who have lost their safety factor. Hardin says, “This is the basic metaphor wihin we must work out or solutions” (2). If we follow this metaphor then many of our Christian ideals will be lost but we can continue to help those that remain in our so called “lifeboat.” Hardin also says, “Let us now enrich the image, step by step, with substantive additions from the real world, a world that must solve real problems and pressing problems of overpopulation and hunger(2)”. He then tries to persuade the audience later by giving statistics about how overpopulation will be caused if we continue with the world food bank. By also using statistics Hardin captures the logos appeal of the audience by demonstrating the astonishing numbers for the reproductive cycle of both the rich and the poor social classes in the United States. The statistics that are used show that if the U.S. pooled resources with other countries, “consider the ratio after 87 years, by which the Americans would have doubled the population of 420 million. By then doubling every 21 years the group would have swollen to 354 billion people” (2). Another surprising statistic would be: “Each American would have to share the available resources with eight other people” (2). These numbers would scare anyone therefore causing a reaction the pathos appeal in the audience but because of an important factor that was missed by Hardin the audience isn’t able to fully believe the article they are reading. With all the statistics that are given we should be able to find the resources from which they came from but Hardin fails to give us any which makes him less credible and the audience will doubt where the information has come from. Furthermore Hardin also uses cause and effect to demonstrate how the “World Food Bank appeals to our humanitarian needs but in reality this program is not benefiting the poorer countries but actually leaving them to a disadvantage”(3). By having
Show More

Related Documents: Sinking Boat Essay

Anonymous: Why The Lulz Boat Is Sinking

Richard P Givens Givens 1 Professor Lora Winslow Understanding Human Communication 203 3 November 2012 Anonymous: Why the “Lulz Boat” is Sinking Anonymous is a collective group of semi-organized hackers that rally together at times against persons, businesses, or government agencies. Operating under a banner of anti-censorship, social freedom and claiming to be squarely against those whom they label as oppressors, the group Anonymous relies on various network attacks and public leaks of information…

Words 1059 - Pages 5

The Titanic 2 Essay

set to voyage from Southampton on the 10th of April 1912, to New York City.The boat was designed to be ‘Unsinkable’which makes it somewhat ironic that it is known as one of the most iconic ships, for its fatal sinking. There was around 2,228 people on board the Titanic when it sank, even though the boat was originally made for about 3,500 passengers. Out of all these people only about 710 passengers survived the sinking. Many question whether the loss of life could have been reduced. For example it…

Words 478 - Pages 2

Robert Reich Why The Rich Are Getting Richer Analysis

classifications, or boats as Reich metaphorically puts it. The three boats are characterized as sinking rapidly, which holds the “routine producers,” the second boat that is sinking slowly holds the “in-person servers,” and lastly the boat that is rising swiftly holds the “symbolic analysts.” Reich puts these boats in this order to show us that, for whatever reason, the two boats that are sinking is the majority of Americans and that while we are struggling the top percent is in the…

Words 1379 - Pages 6

Heads in the Sand Essay

society. How does the following cartoon encourage us to do this?” | INTRODUCTION: Many Asylum seeker boats approach our shores every day the majority of them don’t make it and they sink the members of our parliament like to turn a blind eye and pretend nothing’s happening. The symbolism of the politicians sticking their heads n the sand like an ostrich, tells us that they are ignore the sinking boat because they don’t want to deal with it. Most Political cartoons involve ‘satire’; satire is a genre…

Words 808 - Pages 4

Summary: The Sinking Of Lusitania

The Sinking of Lusitania: Justified or Not? Great Britain, with the Allied Forces, and Germany, with the Triple Alliance, were the major forces that fought in World War I. Nearly one year following the commencement of the Great War, German U-boats started began sinking British ships using their technique of approaching the vessels underwater and out of sight. They used this tactic because Great Britain had been breaking the laws and hurting the German people. The main event that caught America’s…

Words 334 - Pages 2

Who Is Erik Larson's Use Of Imagery In The Dead Wake

talked about a lot. Captain Turner was the captain when the Lusitania was torpedoed by the Germans and sank. Captain William Turner was captain of many ships, but most importantly he was the captain for the Lusitania when it was torpedoed by a German U-boat, which was one of the key factors that led the United States into entering the war. Captain Turner was born in October 23, 1856, “in the age of sail and empire,” (Larson). His father was a sea captain and had hoped that Turner would chose different…

Words 1408 - Pages 6

The Unsinkable Causes Of The Titanic

Line. The Titanic was created in Belfast, Ireland. The Boat measured about 882 feet in length. It had nine decks and 20 boilers. The Titanic “burned 650 tons of coal per day and reach about 16,000 horsepower” (Titanic Sinks). The Titanic crashed in the North Atlantic Ocean on April 15, 1912. The Titanic carried 2,200 passengers and crew butt, only life boats for 1,178. Only about 750 survived. The Titanic hitting a massive iceberg and sinking, will impact today’s world. Even Harland and Wolff claimed…

Words 336 - Pages 2

Essay on American Economy

Poorer”, he mentions how he pictures our economy with three boats. He indicates the economy emerged from everyone being on the same boat to the separation of three new ones. The first boat holds routine producers, the second in-person servers and the third boat symbolic analysts. Reich states that “we are now in different boats, one sinking rapidly, one sinking more slowly, and the third rising steadily” (Reich, 229). The first boat containing routine producers includes assembly line workers,…

Words 880 - Pages 4

George Washington Essay

one of them is the sinking of the Lusitania which was a tragic event where 128 Americans met their fates by the Germans. The Germans had no right in doing this and they broke the rules of submarine warfare. They did not search the ship for contraband so they have no proof, they did not sound off warning shots so the passengers did not get off, they put innocent lives in danger, the Lusitania did not try to escape, and they did not set up a blockade. In addition to the sinking of the Lusitania another…

Words 433 - Pages 2

Why The Richer Are Getting Richer And The Poor, Poorer

from around the United States to Barbados and to Dominican Republic to have them input there data even thou the computer bank was in Dallas.(Reich p.211) There are boats that contain routine producers, a boat that contains symbolic analysts, and the boat containing in-person servers. There was a time when everyone was on the same boat but because the American company sold its goods and services all over the world, the purchasing power of Americans workers became far less relevant to its economic…

Words 1377 - Pages 6