Socrates Argument Of Recollection

Words: 905
Pages: 4
Open Document
In Plato's Phaedo, Socrates asserts that a pure philosopher should look forward to death. One of the main reasons he says this is the belief that the soul is immortal. Upon hearing this belief Socrates' friend Cebes asks him to explain how he knows the soul is eternal. In order to do this, Socrates presents many interconnected arguments. Out of these arguments, the argument of recollection is one of the most elaborate.
In order to understand Socrates' argument of recollection, we must first understand his Theory of Forms. This theory states that certain absolute truths, known as forms, exist in a realm outside of our own physical reality. According to the theory, our own physical reality attempts to match these perfect forms, but ultimately …show more content…
First, he states that all learning is recollection, and that we can only recollect what we've already known. This makes sense as it would be impossible to remember something we've never known. Then, he points out that through seeing imitations of the forms in our physical world we can remember what the perfect form is. For example, seeing a picture of a near-perfect circle reminds us of perfect roundness. Because we can recall these forms, we must have known them at some point. The idea of having known the forms at some point is perplexing because the actual forms do not exist in our physical world. Socrates' concludes that we must have known these forms from before life in the spiritual realm, which proves the existence of the soul before birth.
While this argument proves the soul's existence before birth, Socrates' friends question how this proves it exists after death. In response, Socrates references his previous cyclical argument which basically concluded the soul is reborn to our world from death. With this argument in mind, we know the soul is reborn from the dead and exists before birth. From this we can logically conclude that the soul must exist after death, because there is no other way the soul could be reborn from
Show More

Related Documents: Socrates Argument Of Recollection

Meno: Question and Meno at Meno Essay

MENO At Meno 80c, Meno accuses Socrates of bewitching him. Meno accuses him of being “in appearance and in every other way, like the broad torpedo fish, for it too makes anyone who comes close and touches it feel numb.” Socrates responds to this accusation in 80c-d by clarifying to Meno that he is more perplexed than anyone when he causes perplexity in others. Essentially in Meno 80c-d, Socrates rejects bewitching Meno. He acknowledges to Meno that he may have perplexed him, but supports himself…

Words 794 - Pages 4

Phaedo 2 Essays

famous Greek philosopher Plato, is a dialogue recounting the events and discussions of Socrates’ final moments before his sentenced death from the well-known trial recognized as The Apology. During this time, Socrates explains to his friends that acquiring knowledge comes from a recollection of things in a previous life as a way to provide comfort to his friends about his anticipated death. According to Socrates, if humans can learn anything, they must have known about what it is they are learning…

Words 626 - Pages 3

Essay on Theory of Recollection

Theory of Recollection When discussing the Theory of Recollection, Socrates poses his stance to Simmias and Cebes. Socrates believes that the soul comes before the body in order for the recollection process to occur. Simmias raises the objection that the body and soul can be compared to an instrument being tuned. Through the reasoning of his objection, Simmias concludes that soul exists as a result of the body existing and functioning properly. After analyzing Simmias’ analogy, Socrates presents…

Words 834 - Pages 4

Essay about Philosophy 160

have students memorize it so that it maybe taught later. The Meno 1. What question begins the Meno? How does Socrates respond? How is this question eventually answered? Meno begins dialogue in Meno by asking, “can virtue be taught?” Socrates responds by asking if you do not know what something is, how could I know what qualities it possesses. This question is eventually answered by Socrates saying virtue cannot be taught i.e. good people have terrible children. 2. What’s the difference between an…

Words 895 - Pages 4

Plato's Argument For The Immortality Of The Soul

will explain and assess Plato’s argument for the immortality of the soul, as developed in the Meno and Phaedo. In addition, this paper will discuss what epistemological considerations Plato used to support his view of the immortality of the soul, and how these considerations supported this view. I find Plato’s arguments for the immortality of the soul convincing. My thesis is that our souls are immortal. First, I will give some background information of how the argument for immortality of the soul…

Words 1671 - Pages 7

Essay Philosophy: Socrates and Soul

Phaedo What is the scene like when Phaedo and Crito first arrive to see Socrates? Socrates is sentenced to death He is unchained because it is the day of his execution. He is lying in his bed with his friends and followers at his side. Socrates’ wife and son are by his side, hysterical Socrates begins to tell stories based on Aesop’s Fables Oddly, Plato is removed from the discussion he is “sick.” According to Socrates, why shouldn’t we kill ourselves? It is not “lawful” Killing ourselves…

Words 1078 - Pages 5

Failure Of The Virtue In Socrates's Apology

begins with Socrates standing trail and making a short speech. In his speech Socrates will respond to the accusations, rumors, and claims made against him. These accusations arose from various things Socrates did, of which, testing his wisdom. Socrates visited a number of different people whom claimed to be wise. In each event, he put the person’s reputation to the test. In each case, the individual failed the test, to be wise. These wise men eventually talked negativity about Socrates. This resulted…

Words 546 - Pages 3

Philosophy 101 Midterm Essay

Odyssey makes him an expert in every field on which Homer touches. What does Socrates think of this? Ion is a great reciter of the works of Homer, the best in his mind. He draws in large audiences to hear him utter the fine words of the Odyssey and Iliad with such passion and emotion, which is unmatched by any other reciter in all of Greece. His skill has even granted him a golden crown by the Homer Association. Socrates envies Ion’s skill since in order to be a great reciter, you must learn the meanings…

Words 2034 - Pages 9

Essay about What Is Truth - Comparison of Plato and Peirce's Philosophy

As shown through Plato's writings of Socrates' dialogues, the community was used as a type of forum for discussion for Plato and Socrates. They were trying to come up with solutions through speaking with members of the community in hope that the greater truth could be reached by collective reasoning and recollection. Peirce believes that a social relation among believers as well as individual connections is necessary to find…

Words 975 - Pages 4

Philosophical Analysis Of The Meno Essay

Meno The periscope of text I will be writing about is the meno, which is one of the Plato’s earliest works in which he writes about Socrates. The meno can be said to have many meanings or interpretations, but the main interpretation of the meno can be said to be a dialogue in which Socrates and meno have a heated discussion about virtue and what it really means. Socrates questions Meno about what he perceives virtue to be because meno apparently has knowledge on the topic. The heated talk between the…

Words 1461 - Pages 6