St. Joan Essay

Submitted By mbferre
Words: 1192
Pages: 5
Open Document
St. Joan

Joan of Arch is a poor farm girl that\eaves on France. Joan claims to hear the voices of God, St. Catherine and St. Margaret and St. Michael telling her what to do in order to defeat English and retake French territory. Joan persuades everyone, from Robert, to the King, that she has to lead the army because she is God’s servant and that is the only way France is going to win. After winning, she is accused from been a witch and she is consider a threat to the Church and therefore she is burnt.

Throughout the entire case we analyze a variety of leadership issues. There is a difference in leadership between Joan and King Charles, there is some discrimination towards Joan because she is a women (gender inequality), there is also a conservation of power by the Church and, finally, a resistance to change from Joan’s part when they try to convince that the change she wants to implement is wrong.

The difference in leadership Between Joan and Charles is very significant. We can refer to Charles leadership style approach by looking at the Blake and Mouton’s Managerial (Leadership) Grid. When focusing on the grid we can conclude that Charles is in the Impoverished Management side. This type of leader goes through the motion of being leader but acts uninvolved and withdrawn, could be described as indifferent, noncommittal, resigned and apathetic. (Northouse page 80) Charles is not concerned about pursuing a goal or gaining affection or popularity among the people. He is more centered about his own personal objectives, without taking in consideration the people of France. We can see this clearly in this part of the case: “I never asked to be a king: it was pushed on me. So if you are going to say "Son of St Louis: gird on the sword of your ancestors, and lead us to victory'' you may spare your breath to cool your porridge; for I cannot do it. I am not built that way; and there is an end of it. I don’t want to have courage Put into me. I want to sleep in a comfortable bed, and not live in continual terror of being killed or wounded. Put courage into the others, and let them have their bellyful of fighting; but let me alone.” (St. Joan Case, page 7). On the other had, we can see Joan as a transformational leader, she is very charismatic and she is concerned with changing and transforming people. She is concerned with emotion, values, ethics, and long-term goals, in this case, saving France form the British. Transformational leadership involves an exceptional form of influence that moves followers to accomplish more than what is usually expected of them. (Northouse, page 185) Joan clearly influences everyone that surrounded her, even the king, she strives to make some changes and, thus, accomplish them by using charisma and inner strength.

In the case, everyone was surprised that Joan wanted to lead the army because that was considered a men’s job. When Joan first arrive to convince Robert about been sent by God and that she is the one that is suppose to regain French territory, Robert did not believe her. Robert among the majority of men in the case established the fact that Joan is a girl and that therefore it was impossible for her to achieve her goal. Even Joan acknowledges what it is expected from a women to do when she says: Nay: “I am no shepherd lass, though I have helped with the sheep like anyone else. I will do a lady's work in the house-spin or weave-against any woman in Rouen.” (St. Joan Case, page 11)

The conflict between Joan and the Church emerged when the British realized that Joan was a threat for the Church power and that consequently she had to be killed. “The English discuss the threat she poses physically and ideologically. She has come to represent the protest of the individual soul against the interference of the priest between man and God. This individualism also called nationalism, the English sees as anti-Catholic and anti-Christian. Such iconoclastic individualism will destroy the church
Show More

Related Documents: St. Joan Essay

St Joan Of Arc Research Paper

the stake on May 30th, 1431 (age 19) She was beatified on April 18th, 1909 at Notre Dame de Paris by Pope Pius X. St Joan of Arc was canonized on May 16th, 1920 in St. Peter’s Basilica, Rome by Pope Benedict XV. Her feast day is on May 30th. She is known for disguising herself as a man at the age of 13 and fighting in the war. Despite her success during the hundreds year was, St Joan of Arc was a caring, brave woman.…

Words 595 - Pages 3

St Joan Of Arc Research Paper

My saint is St. Joan of Arc. Her birthday was January 6, 1412. During St. Joan of Arc’s early life, France was in a war with England. Many people in Joan’s village had to leave their homes for fear of being invaded. She dealt with this issue by leading the French army during one of the battles and won it. St. Joan of Arc was born to very poor parents in the village of Domremy. When she was little, people said she heard the voices of St. Michael, St. Catherine, and St. Margaret. When she was 13,…

Words 427 - Pages 2

Joan of Arc Essay

8. Joan of Arc Why was Joan of Arc burnt at the stake? Joan of Arc holds great importance within history and the reasoning behind her execution. At Only 17 when she was put in command of the French army, not only is she the youngest person to ever command the armies of a nation but as a women this holds great significance and also leads to her demise. In only a couple of months she was able to completely reverse a war that had been going on for almost 100 years that the French were…

Words 478 - Pages 2

Joan Of Arc Research Paper

St. Joan of Arc's demonstration of faith by listening to God's voice during the war is truly remarkable. She believed she was guided by divine messages and visions, which urged her to support Charles VII and aid in his quest for the French throne. Despite facing doubts and challenges, Joan remained resolute in her beliefs, leading troops into battle and playing a crucial role in the Hundred Years' War. Her unwavering faith in following what she perceived as God's direction highlights her deep spiritual…

Words 475 - Pages 2

How Did Joan Of Arc Contribute To The French Revolution

Joan of Arc was a very influential figure in France during the Hundred Years’ War. At the time, the nation of France was at war with the English, who wanted to take control of the land. They had already captured several cities, including Orléans and Reims, the latter of which being the place where all French kings were crowned. Despite this, however, the faith, confidence, and actions of Joan of Arc saved the French from being England’s captive. Raised as a Christian, Joan of Arc began having divine…

Words 1128 - Pages 5

How To Write A Manuscript Speech

Sample outline for a manuscript speech (from Joan Detz, author of HOW TO WRITE & GIVE A SPEECH) OPENING I. I follow a standard outline format. A. B. Where there’s an A … … there’s a B 1. 2. Sometimes I use full sentences. Sometimes not a. b. Fragments work great Creative punctuation = okay, too • • II. Bullet lists = very helpful Clients can see them quickly The introduction needs to be short. MAIN BODY I. Use a ragged right margin. (Never justify the right margin in a speech manuscript.) Use…

Words 986 - Pages 4

Joan Of Arc: Roman Catholic Saint

d’Arc, more commonly known as Joan of Arc was born in 1412 in Domrémy, Bar, France. She was a national heroine of France, that at age 18 she led the French army to victory over the British. Unfortunately, she was captured a year later at age 19 and was burned at the stake as a heretic by the English and their French collaborators. 500 years later she was canonized (made into a saint) as a Roman Catholic saint on May 16, 1920. Historical Background At the time of Joan of Arc’s birth, France was undergoing…

Words 1230 - Pages 5

Joan Of Arc Patron And Behavior Essay

The Patron and Savior of France -Joan of Arc “ I fear nothing for god is with me”. - Joan of Arc. This saying represented what kind of a person Joan of Arc was. Her actions were are always followed by the words of god. Joan of Arc is known as the patron of soldiers who greatly played a crucial role in the Hundred Year War and is especially known for the Battle of Orleans. Before Joan became the patron of France she was a mere girl who received a message from St.Michael telling her to follow the voice…

Words 794 - Pages 4

Contrasting: Black Death and Johan Nider Essay

punishment from god for all who have sinned or betrayed him. Johan Nider on Joan of Arc In this excerpt written by Johan Nider on Joan of Arc, Nider is depicted as a “zealous witch finder”. The document begins by questioning if good men have been betrayed by witches back then. The response is then directed at Joan who was spotted by a man by the name of Heinrich Kaltyseren in the city of Cologne, Germany. Joan is described as a women who wandered the town in men’s clothing and almost a manly…

Words 886 - Pages 4

Joan Burley's Accomplishments

can you do in one short lifetime?” This quote perfectly describes the lifestyle of Joan Crawford. She is known as one of the best actresses of her time and was gifted in almost every way. Crawford was an excellent dancer, a natural born actress, a decent singer, and, most importantly, a headstrong individual who would not stop until “Joan Crawford” was a name known in every household throughout America. Even though Joan is known as an outstanding actress, the notorious allegations of her abusiveness…

Words 1638 - Pages 7