State of confusion paper

Submitted By srice11
Words: 1018
Pages: 5
Open Document
State of Confusion Paper
Brian Johnson
University of Phoenix

State of Confusion Paper Tanya Trucker is the owner of a trucking company in the state of Denial and is seeking to file a law suit against Confusion to overturn their statute which requires truck drivers to have a specialized hitch installed in order to pass through Confusion. Tanya should take her case to the federal court. “It is the federal law who takes superiority and takes charge of any conflicts that happen within the state and locally” (Cheeseman, 2010). It would not be logical for Tanya to file the law suit within the state that actually passed the statute. Because it was the state that put in the law that requires the use of B-type truck hitches by all towing trailers and trucks, there would be no way Tanya would persuade the state to reverse the law. It would take a large population to have a problem with the law for they would even consider reversing it. Another way for the law to be completely done away with is for the government to eliminate it. The federal court and state court both have jurisdiction power involving this case. One may wonder of the statute in Confusion is actually constitutional. When comparing this case to the Rowe, Attorney General of Maine v. New Hampshire Motor Transport Association, it was determined that the Confusion statue was not constitutional. While reviewing that case, it was found that congress had the goal of maintaining a transportation system that is affordable, efficient, equal, and competitive. The issue in the case was going against the goal of congress. This particular case was handled by a federal court and because this case is similar to Tanya’s, she should go to a federal court. The state of Confusion is limiting their competitive market which will eventually have a negative effect on their communities. They are benefiting because they are the only state that produces and sells the B-type hitch, but because it is an extra expense to all incoming trucking companies, they will likely avoid going through the area to save on the cost of the hitch. There needs to be a balance in the transportation market and requiring a special piece of equipment just to cross through one state does not make sense. There are provisions of the United States Constitution that will be applied by a court to determine the statute’s validity. The most relevant provision to this particular case would be the Supremacy Clause. It states that regulations and the constitution all apply as the federal law of societies. This means that state or locally created law that is not a federal law is not supported as constitutional. Federal laws and the constitution will always take lead over state laws. There is a good chance that Tanya will likely prevail on her suit. This is being determined by the information studied from the case discussed earlier. The government is not likely to enforce the law requiring the hitch once seeing the negative effect it has on the transportation industry in the area and how the state of Confusion took sole control of the production of the hitches to make a profit from everybody. One of the constitutional provisions was broken by the state of Confusion when they committed the act of self-profit as a state. This information is adequate enough for Tanya to have a shot at winning her suit. There are several states of a civil law suit which are started by a suit in the court. In stage one, the suit will display all the reasons for the complainant’s actions on why their case should be supported by the court. Usually this consists of the complainant wanting the other party involved to pay for any damages or injuries caused. In stage two, a copy of the case against the defendant is sent to the defendant. Once received by the defendant, they will
Show More

Related Documents: State of confusion paper

State of Confusion Essay example

State of Confusion Tabitha Parris BUS/415 December 12, 2011 Penelope Donkar State of Confusion In this paper I will tell what court will have jurisdiction over Tanya’s suit also explain why? Tell if the statute of confusion is constitutional or not, describe what provisions of the U.S. Constitution will be applied, and conclude with if Tanya will likely prevail on the lawsuit. The court that should have jurisdiction over Tanya case is the federal jurisdiction. Most federal courts could decide…

Words 819 - Pages 4

Adolescent thought paper

Adolescent Developmental Stage Thought Paper Amy Lacuesta Imperial Valley Community College Adolescent Developmental Stage Thought Paper Social relationships are a big part of adolescents, especially when they are trying to find out their identity. Erik Erikson said that as we enter our adolescent stage in life, we go through what he calls identity vs. role confusion. This stage is very much shown in the movie many people love, “The Breakfast Club.” This movie includes a group of students…

Words 544 - Pages 3

The First Paper Money In The United States

early days of the nation, before and just after the revolution, Americans used English, Spanish, and French money. 1690 Colonial Notes The Massachusetts Bay Colony issued the first paper money in the colonies which would later form the United States. 1775 Continental Currency American colonists issued paper currency for the Continental Congress to finance the Revolutionary War. The notes were backed by the "anticipation" of tax revenues. Without solid backing and easily counterfeited, the…

Words 683 - Pages 3

Compare And Contrast Lumiton And Edward Tfte

Words are a type of art of how people express themselves. They are used in many different forms to evoke certain feelings. Edward Tufte criticizes how people have abandoned the art of a deeper connection to others with words, and how people choose to chop up ideas into bullet points so that there is no longer a true connection. Ellen Lupton however, writes about the history of the evolution of words, and how their meanings have changed into the modern era. These two author’s essays coincide. Ellen…

Words 618 - Pages 3

Alcoholic Parent Research Paper

lasting effects the behaviors of an alcoholic parent have on their child. Throughout the research paper, you magnify your focus on the psychosocial effects children of alcoholics experience compared to those of their peers of non-alcoholic parents. There are a few treatments offered to assist children of alcoholic parents reduce the negative prolonged effects. You clearly states the topic of the research paper through the well established thesis.…

Words 605 - Pages 3

Essay on Self Evaluation

When I first go about writing a paper, I tend to brainstorm about the topic specifically. I like to think about the details of my topic and come up with supporting facts or evidence for my papers. My mental state while writing is having a focused mind set. For me, it is almost impossible for me to do anything productive while writing my papers if I’m listening to music or talking to other people. I need to have little to no distractions when trying to complete my papers. I am currently pretty comfortable…

Words 474 - Pages 2

Global Ethics Essay

Why is it important to study families globally? There are many reasons that come to mind when asked this question, such as, to have a better understanding of cultures as the United States becomes more diverse. Perhaps it is important to study families globally to see how different the Human Development process may, or may not be. Also, how do they face developmental tasks that they are faced with? Lastly, how are demography, critical studies and historical materialism related in other cultures? All…

Words 954 - Pages 4

The DNP-NP

In 2004, the American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) released a position paper recommending the doctor of nursing practice (DNP) degree, as the graduate degree for advanced-practice nurses (APNs) entry to practice. While doctoral preparation in nursing has evolved greatly, there remain a number of issues and controversies surrounding the DNP degree specifically, and several factors impacting the credibility and viability of the degree, which will be analyzed. It is important to clarify…

Words 1087 - Pages 5

Essay on Review Response

Reviewer Response Letter 1. The Reviewer made an excellent point in reference to personality traits vs. affective states. The Reviewer discussed confusion as to which is the focus of the paper. I agree with the Reviewer that this distinction is important. Therefore, I have included in the literature review a section on personality development and assessment based on the Five-Factor Model of personality. I have also placed greater emphasis on interpersonal theory of personality, specifically…

Words 648 - Pages 3

Barriers to Effective Communication Essay examples

barriers resulting in confusion and inefficiencies throughout the system. Law enforcement agencies began sharing…

Words 1652 - Pages 7