The First Amendment: Controversial Clauses

Words: 551

Pages: 3

Open Document

The First Amendment: Controversial Clauses The First Amendment features two clauses relating to the freedom of religion. These clauses are known as the establishment clause and the free-exercise clause. The establishment clause forbids the government from establishing a religion (Janda 458). The free-exercise clause prevents government intervention in the exercise of religion (458). Both clauses have caused some controversial Supreme Court decisions. The establishment clause is prominent in two landmark cases, Engel v Vitale (1962) and Lemon v. Kurtzman (1971). In Engel v. Vitale, a New York state law required students to recite a nondenominational prayer at the beginning of the school day, a parent sued claiming that their child’s First Amendment right to freedom of religion was being violated. The court ruled six to one that the law was unconstitutional and violated the establishment clause of the First Amendment (“Facts”). This case made school prayer unconstitutional. In Lemon V. Kurtzman, a state program that would assist parochial schools in paying the salaries of …show more content…
One way of limiting the impact of the Supreme Court is to enact laws that restrict it. When the controversial decision of Roe V. Wade (1973) was made, many states enacted strict regulations in order to limit the number of abortions. For example, in Mississippi women are required to get state-directed counseling and wait twenty-four hours before getting an abortion (“State”). Another way to limit the impact of Supreme Court decisions is through judicial appointments. Currently president-elect Donald Trump has voiced his plan to appoint conservative judges that will likely overturn Roe v. Wade (De Vogue). Although, the Supreme Court is the final interpreter of the Constitution Supreme Court decisions can be limited through the actions of other political

Importance Of The 14th Amendment

cornerstone to rest their cases concerning ill-treatment. In 1868, the 14th amendment was released and America’s revolution for civil rights and civil liberties began through selective incorporation. The 14th amendment is critical to advancements in civil liberties for all individuals.…

Words 840 - Pages 4

14th Amendment Advantages

The fourteenth amendment was ratified in 1868 and is one of the most important and controversial amendments passed in our nation’s history. The amendment defines what a United States citizen is as well as protecting the rights of those citizens. The main clauses are the Citizenship, Due Process, and Equal Protection clauses. The first clause defines what a citizen is and how citizenship is gained. The Due Process clause is what allowed the first amendment rights to be applied directly to the States…

Words 497 - Pages 2

Essay on Chapter 5 Review Questions

What rights are protected I the First Amendment? 5. What makes the 2nd Amendment so controversial? 6. What do the 4, 5, 6 and 8th amendments focus on? 7. Does the government have the right to take your property and if so, from where do they get that right? 8. What is the purpose of the 9th Amendment? 9. Describe what each of the following Amendments do: 13, 14, and 15. 10. With the exception of the 21st Amendment, what type of right was addressed in all Amendments after the 15th (that dealt with…

Words 988 - Pages 4

Habeas Corpus and Civil Liberties Essay

you have been wrongfully accused or convicted you will appreciate its history and debate. Freedom of Speech Our forefathers made it clear that we as a nation are entitled to civil liberties. One of these civil liberties is free speech the first Amendment protects this right to free speech and expression. Although all of our rights have their restrictions the point is we should be grateful to have them. Because many countries are subject to their countries unfair laws and also unfair taxes just…

Words 1633 - Pages 7

Religion In Public Schools: Epperson V. Arkansas

The American Constitution refers to religious freedom as being able to practice the religion of your choice without it being forced upon you. Either individuals chose what religion to practice or they practice no religion at all. There have been controversial impacts when it comes to religious freedom. Implications for federalism related to religious freedom include banning schools from teaching religion and allowing political candidates to make their religion known. Religious freedom also has some…

Words 1668 - Pages 7

5 PAGE AP GOV SANTA MONICA ESSAY

Jose Mendez Anaya P4 February 9, 2015 Criminals or victims? Relevant amendments involved in this case are the first and fourteenth amendment. Section one of the fourteenth amendment contains the due process clause, this clause makes it unlawful for local and state governments to discriminate against people. In this case, the SMMAMC leader, and his seven members, may use this amendment in their appeal. The SMMAMC leader can argue that the police, a form of local government, discriminated against…

Words 1301 - Pages 6

Prayer In Public Schools

Introduction: Prayers in schools are one of the most controversial issues of our generation. The heart of the issue revolves around whether schools should be allowed to mandate prayers? Conservatives argue student led prayers instill morals into students. Liberals on the hand, argue that while prayers are legal by the First Amendment, there should be a balance between church and state. Religion plays a major role in everyday lives and for students, school takes up half of their daily lives. Thus…

Words 1827 - Pages 8

Procedural Vs Substantive Due Process

The difference between procedural and substantive due process refers to the procedures states must follow when it comes to the Due Process clause. Procedural due process is defined as the actions the state or federal government must follow in both civil and criminal cases before denying any person a constitutionally protected right that concerns the person’s life, liberty, or property. It also exists to help ensure procedural justice which is defined as the fairness of the process used when applying…

Words 1019 - Pages 5

Abortion Despute Essay

Abortion Abortion is the termination of a pregnancy after conception. Women can put an end to their pregnancies but it involves killing the undeveloped embryo or fetus. This is a very controversial subject in America and many other countries around the world due to the fact that some believe abortion is murder. Many argue that a fetus is not yet a person but a baby’s heart start beating at 5 weeks into pregnancy. The Abortion despute and what I believe is that the life of any human creature,…

Words 592 - Pages 3

Response To Abortion Law

As we mentioned in the 14th Amendment people should not be derived from decisions related to a person’s body. Despite many women always obstacles when they are trying to get an abortion. Supreme Court decisions allows women to have an abortion before the third trimester, however, some local governments have put restraints and regulations that make it difficult, sometimes impossible to have an abortion. As we learned in class there are two types of due process. The first is procedural process, the…

Words 1516 - Pages 7