Of mice and men is great book and people want to get rid of it, but not everyone can just decide which books stay and which go. Most logically the students and teachers should decide and maybe even the parents. Not just anyone in the town or city should decide which books stay and go. Especially if parents and teachers have better sense in which books students will like.
The first issue about having the community choose books is that the community does not know the students as well as their own parents. Therefor making it harder to know which books students will like. Also they shouldn't choose because they may have not liked the book back in their day, but maybe now the students will like it. It should be