The Police Misconduct Case

Words: 890
Pages: 4
Open Document
Police Misconduct
The amount of shoddy investigation practices in this case is unbelievable. For one thing, Kyle Gibbs, a police officer in Ada, at first sent Sergeant Phillips to the wrong McAnally's. It took twice the time for Phillips to get the scene because Gibbs did not use his common sense to find out where the reported crime took place. In the same night, the police did not bother, nor think to collect forensic evidence of the scene. The store manager threw out the open beer can on the counter and "emptied the ashtray with a single cigarette butt in it" Mayer, 1987, p. 8). The two pieces of evidence that could have definitively solved the crime were tossed away like garbage.
When the police publicized the composite sketches of the men …show more content…
Although Bill Peterson does reiterate his evidence, his evidence is lacking in strength. Calling his evidence circumstantial is a courtesy. Aside from the confession tapes, Bill Peterson just had a bunch of puzzle pieces which he cut up to fit his picture of the crime. He appeals to the emotions of the jury, asking them, "Was it a dream to Denice…or a living nightmare?" Mayer, 1987, p. 395). He is also begging the question, by assuming that he has already proven Denice was murdered. Peterson also makes an ad hominem argument, by downplaying Richard Kerner's skill as an investigator and mocks him, calling him "Dick Tracy in disguise" Mayer, 1987, p. 395). Chris Ross does the same about Janette Roberts' pictures of Tommy, exclaiming, "her credibility stinks!" Mayer, 1987, p. 398). Ross' theory that Odell is actually Tommy is an unsupported blind statement. Mayer points out that Odell appears in both Fontenot and Tommy's tapes, which would not make sense if he was an incarnation of Tommy. Also, Tommy and Odell were in the store together, which does not fit with Ross' theory. As with the police, the prosecution molded the suspects to their evidence, instead of using the evidence to prove the suspects committed the …show more content…
The prosecution did not prove corpus delicti. Not once did the prosecution prove that Tommy and Fontenot were at McAnally's. The closest they got was establishing that Tommy may have been at J.P.'s down the road from McAnally's. The only time Fontenot was implicated in the crime was through Tommy's confession. The prosecution did not prove either confession to be true, and that would have been impossible seeing that they were elicited through police malpractice. The witnesses against Tommy and Fontenot were either unreliable, erroneous or unrelated to the case. The prosecution did not prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that Tommy Ward and Karl Fontenot committed any crime, let alone rape and
Show More

Related Documents: The Police Misconduct Case

Police Misconduct Cases

In order to understand the extent to which misconduct occurs, one must examine the various police misconduct cases. However, creditable data is difficult to obtain due to the bias that is present in internal investigations. Internal investigations are often skewed in favor of police officers. Officers often work under an unwritten code known as “Blue Wall of Silence” (Nolan, 2009). The blue wall of silence suggests that law enforcement has a tendency to withhold the truth in order to cover up wrong…

Words 151 - Pages 1

Police Misconduct Case Study

Police Misconduct is a hot button topic in the zeitgeist today; personal feelings on the topic seem to have little bearing on policy changes and prosecution of Police Officers charged with abusing their position. The following questions need to be raised: How many civil and human rights society is willing to give up to remain safe? Do authoritative positions corrupt otherwise good people, or do authoritative positions attract bad people? If laws governing police misconduct get stricter, will it…

Words 1624 - Pages 7

Police Misconduct Research

Governmental Misconduct Many factors influence governmental misconduct. The factors of governmental misconduct are forcing false confessions, lying or giving the jurors false information, not handing evidence over to prosecutors, and bribing people to secure faulty evidence and informants (Covey, 2013). In addition, prosecutors force defense witnesses not to take the stand, allowing unreliable witnesses to testify, intentionally destroying evidence, and depending on forensic experts that are not…

Words 639 - Pages 3

Police misconduct essay

105 Police Misconduct What is police misconduct? It can be defined as any action performed by a law enforcement officer that is unethical by established employment guidelines, unconstitutional, or a crime with in itself. When people hear the term “police misconduct” they automatically think of a police officer using unnecessary force against a civilian. While that is a form of police misconduct it is not only form. Throughout this paper I will bring light to the many types of police misconduct…

Words 1027 - Pages 5

Why Do Body Cameras Catch Police Misconduct?

Have you ever thought about police wearing body cameras? Body cameras can be very useful and reliable for police officers and citizens. Ways body cameras can help by catching misconduct and ensuring safety. Police officers can partake in misconduct. Ensuring safety is very important for both police officers and citizens. To sum it up, police officers should wear body cameras. Body cameras can catch police misconduct. First, fewer officers partake in misconduct when they wear body cameras, for example”…

Words 555 - Pages 3

Prosecutorial Misconduct Essay

Prosecutorial Misconduct Prosecutorial Misconduct is an issue in the United States Justice System and there are ways to stop this misconduct from happening. Prosecutor misconduct is conduct which violates court rules or ethical standards of law practice (US Legal, Inc.). It is an attempt to persuade the jury to wrongly convict a defendant or to impose a harsher than appropriate punishment. "According to the Center for Prosecutor Integrity, multiple studies over the past 50 years show that courts…

Words 633 - Pages 3

Police Misconduct Research Paper

Jeremy Garcia Ms. Berry CE 2010 25 October 2016 Police Misconduct in The United States On March 3rd, 1991, Rodney King sped down a highway with police in hot pursuit. Eventually, Los Angeles police caught up with King and fired two tasers into his back, after he was decided to be resisting arrest. When that didn’t stop King from struggling, several LAPD officers ruthlessly beat him with batons. The scene was recorded by a bystander, and what the tape included proceeded to shock the world. After…

Words 2480 - Pages 10

Exclusionary Rule Impact

kind of illegal searches or police misconduct. The exclusionary rule is something that prohibits anyone using most or almost all evidence in any case that was gathered and obtained to not be able to be used in a court of law because it is ruled to be in violation of the Fourth Amendment. The primary purpose of this rule is to deter any kind of police misconduct of any kind from violating individuals rights like any unreasonable searches or seizures and…

Words 893 - Pages 4

Body Cameras Research Paper

provide reliable documentation to support the nature of events that happen between officers and citizens (Chapman 2). Evidence can not be made up. Evidence will be recorded as proof to make things more reliable. Improving accountability, lowering police misconduct, and recording evidence is what body cameras can do if officers wear them. Body cameras can help enhance officers' liability. This helps with proving whether an officer is right or…

Words 970 - Pages 4

Cja214 Week 4 Essay

Police Conduct CJA/214 February 14, 2013 Police Conduct Police officers commit murder. They are accountable for their actions of abuse of police discretion. When looking at the corruption, misconduct, and brutality within the police force, there appears to be no firm statistics to show how rampant the problem is. Areas of the judicial system…

Words 1465 - Pages 6