Sigmund Freud And C. S. Lewis

Submitted By Heather1420
Words: 1326
Pages: 6
Open Document
The question of whether God exists or not is a very important one. Two of the most influential people of the 20th century questioned it, one until his death. These people were Sigmund Freud and C.S. Lewis. They separated people into two categories: those who believe in the supernatural and those who do not believe. Why such a distinction? Why were these two men so intrigued with the existence of God? Perchance they spent so much time arguing their own positions on God because they realized that the existence of a supernatural higher power would indeed have an immense impact on their lives and on the world around them. Sigmund Freud was raised in the Jewish tradition but with much influence from Catholicism. This odd combination of religious rituals and tradition may help to explain his doubt towards God and why he spent nearly his whole life arguing against the existence of a supernatural higher power. Freud theorized that one’s view of God comes from the view you have of your own earthly father. When a man comes of age and is thrust into the harsh world, he desires nothing less than a refuge. A place of security and protection from the unyielding downpour of the world. Being an adult, he can no longer look to his parents for this protection but he wants someone to do this for him. Freud theorized that the man’s need to overcome his helplessness leads him to the idea of a supernatural higher power, which he then calls God. God acts as an idealized father figure for humans, providing an enemy to the harsh world and an ally in life’s troubles. God provides not only protection from nature in the world, but also from evil in the world. Needing an incentive for the suffering around him and a guide for how he should live, the man turns to God for direction. He mistakes the historical moral development of society for rules given and enforced by God. The internalized teachings of his parents and the morals accepted by his culture now become the commands of God. Some of the commandments enforce boundaries on man’s instinct, but they also provide security. Lewis was an atheist like Freud until he became convinced of the truth of God and Christianity. Many of his arguments directly answer the arguments of Freud. Lewis asserts that we do wish for a God that can fulfill our needs and provide moral order, but we wish for these things simply because we were created to desire them. Lewis, an atheist until the age of 31, was never completely happy or content until he embraced the idea of God. He describes his unhappiness as resulting from “an unsatisfied desire which is itself more desirable than any other satisfaction”. Lewis called this desire “Joy” and he found its fulfillment only when he surrendered to the idea of God. He argued that the innate longing one feels is a desire for a relationship with their Creator, and the desire itself suggests the existence of God. Sigmund Freud believed that this desire can be satisfied in other things but Lewis disagreed. Only in a relationship with God can humans find true and lasting contentment. Lewis would argue with these men that time and time again humans turn unsatisfied from earthly pleasures to look beyond themselves for something that might fill the void they feel. Lewis also teaches that humans are born with an instinctual set of rules that govern their actions. He uses this innate moral conscience as more evidence for the existence of a Creator God. He proclaims that if there were a higher power that gave life to humans, then that power would have left some influence on our behavior in order to sway us to act in a certain way. This moral law that the Creator has put in our minds is a sign of Gods existence. It is right that we do commonly learn the moral law from our parents or from the society around us, but that does not mean that society is the creator of that law. Both Sigmund Freud and C.S. Lewis offer compelling arguments for and against the existence of God. Armand Nicholi
Show More

Related Documents: Sigmund Freud And C. S. Lewis

Question Of God

Question of God Part I: In modern day America, I believe that people question the thought of God because there is little proof in his existence. In an effort to support my beliefs I will draw from the practices of Plato, who was a student of Socrates in ancient Greece. Considered one of the great ancient Greek thinkers, Plato spent most of his life developing his Theory of Ideas, which was a significant part of his philosophical beliefs. While Plato is thought to have expressed many of Socrates…

Words 1231 - Pages 5

Questions On Obedience To God

Chapter 1 Questions 1. Where do you think you will be and what do you think you will be doing in the year 2020? In the year 2020, I will be 28 or 29 years old. There is so much that I hope to have done and hope to have become. I hope that by that time I am married, that God has brought the man that is best for me, who, with him, I am able to live and serve God better than I would if I were alone. I would also hope to have children. That God would have equipped me to be best mother. To be in…

Words 551 - Pages 3

Essay on Resume: Existence and God

Does God Exist? An ongoing question that will never have a certain answer is whether god exits? When you think about this question, a lot of other questions come out of this one question. Questions like “What is God?” “Where is God?” and how is God doing all of this?” All of these questions pop up in our heads for nothing because these questions will never be answered if you really think God exists. There are questions in life that you want an answer for in order to lead to happiness or a meaningful…

Words 606 - Pages 3

Essay on Islamic Worldview Critical Thinking

I. Islamic Worldview a. The Question of Origin – Similarly to Genesis of the Bible, the Quran offers verses describing creation. “Surely, your Lord is Allah who created the heavens and the earth…" (Yunus 10:3) The Quran also tells us that Allah is the creator of all, including man. There are very few differences between the Islamic and Christian views of Creation, as both views accept that everything was created by the Lord. b. The Question of Identity – “The Islamic Identity is taken to mean the…

Words 922 - Pages 4

Euthyphro Dilemma Research Paper

discusses this, known as the Euthyphro Dilemma. Attributing to one side of the argument, I believe that God loves holiness or morality because it is holy. In other words, I think morality comes from outside of God, and he commands actions because they are moral. My basis for this argument is that I believe God is subject to a higher law and he creates order out of chaos; this in turn would show that God follows preexisting laws that could have characteristics of morality. The Euthyphro Dilemma dialogue…

Words 1094 - Pages 5

Review Of Michael Shermer's Argument Of God, The Divine

God, the divine being that can do no wrong many people think if we listen to god we will have a great life, but the argument of god being real or not is not a simple matter, but I ask all of you to think about this very question. Where is your evidence of god being real, and why the argument of without god there no moral or if God is real why would this earth be so uneven from others being more rich to some being more poor, so why would you worship someone that pick favorites or someone that encourage…

Words 1158 - Pages 5

Biblical Worldview Research Paper

answers to fundamental questions about existence, humanity, purpose, morality, and destiny, rooted in its understanding of God's revelation through Scripture. Regarding the Question of Origin, the Bible teaches that God is the Creator of the universe and all that is in it. Genesis 1:1 states, "In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth." Humanity, according to the biblical narrative, is not a product of random chance or natural processes, but is deliberately crafted by God. Genesis 1:27 declares…

Words 539 - Pages 3

Essay on God's Role in Aldous Huxley's Brave New World

there is no need for God and religion. God is simply a response to human suffering, and since there is no suffering in the novel, not even in death, God ceases to be useful. Modern society reflects a trend somewhat similar; as science has progressed and suffering and inconveniences have decreased, people have strayed from religion, preferring modern pleasantries over God. Indeed, there are many people today who would argue that, as the amount of suffering in life decreases, God becomes less and less…

Words 929 - Pages 4

How Does Elie Wiesel Use Faith In Night

character, questions his faith and God throughout the traumatic events of the Holocaust. His views of God and his faith drastically change from the beginning of the novel to the end of the novel. He struggles to keep his faith in God, and this struggle reflects why the memoir is titled “Night.” Eliezer, at the beginning of the novel, is very religious; he has a thirst for religious knowledge. Moshe the Beadle acts as his tutor in the endeavor. He has complete and absolute faith in God. When he is…

Words 511 - Pages 3

Innocence In Bless Me Ultima

events, is forced to question all of the morals and beliefs he has been taught and by doing so, he’s also forced to lose his innocence. Early on in the book, Tony learns to deal with death. The first time Tony bears witness to a death was with Lupito. Lupito was a normal man but the war had made him sick. He was delusional enough to mistakenly shoot the sheriff, he thought the sheriff was a japanese soldier, and refuse to stop firing, causing his death. Tony was full of questions after seeing Lupito…

Words 973 - Pages 4