A Brief Note On The Right Perspective

Submitted By qerik
Words: 736
Pages: 3
Open Document
The Right Perspective
We are told, and we all believe, that there are some things we ought to do and others that we ought not. Ethics is an examination of these ought’s or norms of behavior. Lets interpret the following scenario and its dilemma. Your best friend confides you a document with an almost finished project that could cure cancer. Your wife, who ironically works in the same field as your best friend, encounters this document. A discussion is brought upon you with your wife to go behind your friends back and get as much information necessary to finalize this paper. In your hands is the decision to betray your friend, give the documents to your wife and fasten the cure for cancer, as it would save thousands of life’s or to honor your friend request and maintain all of your friends hard work safe. While interpreting this dilemma, it can be approached from both the Consequentialist and Non-Consequentialist perspective. A consequentialist perspective states that whether something is right or wrong only depends on the consequences of the deed, whereas, a non-consequentialist perspective believes that right or wrong truly depends on the intention of the action. I will be comparing what perspective is correct and my position related to the dilemma.
John Stuart Mill an English philosopher believed in utilitarianism, this meaning that a decision should be made whether something is right or wrong depending if the decision would make everyone happy and relieve suffering. This is what we call a Consequentialist perspective. Mill, situated in this scenario, would decide that giving the paper to your wife would be the outer good for everyone. Due to the fact that keeping the paper will only bring happiness to your friend instead of accelerating the cure for cancer and bring happiness to the entire world. Mill would say that this decision would promote the survival of our specie, as cancer is a globally known illness that takes thousands of lives every year.
Immanuel Kant a German philosopher believed that a decision should be made depending on judging the rightness or wrongness of an action based on properties intrinsic to action, not its consequences. This is what we call a Non-Consequentialist perspective, a perspective that will judge a decision by its ethic intention. Kant, situated in this scenario, would decide that keeping the document and keeping the work of his friend secured would be the right decision. Due to the fact that lying and betraying his friend by any means is wrong. A lie no matter what is a lie, it affects a person in different ways and in this scenario it will affect his friends relationship and work.
Even though John Stuart Mills and Emmanuel Kant are both concerned with the moral qualities of action and choices, they differ in different ways. Kant’s
Show More

Related Documents: A Brief Note On The Right Perspective

Michigan's Right To Work Law And A Perspective From Management And Labor

Michigan’s Right-To-Work Law and a Perspective from Management and Labor February 21, 2013 Michigan’s Right-To-Work Law and a Perspective from Management and Labor Organized labor in Michigan took a devastating blow in December of 2012, with Republican lawmakers rushing a bill through the Senate and House that would have the state join the ranks of those considered to be “right-to-work” states. Those who are unfamiliar with unions and the “right to work” laws being passed in states across…

Words 2349 - Pages 10

Ethical Perspective Essay

Ethical Perspective The ethical perspective of an individual has a profound affect on how he lives his life. Ethical perspective can be that of character, obligation, results, or equity; or C.O.R.E.. An individual may fall into one of these perspectives or may be blended between two or more. An individual’s ethical perspective can be reflected in the culture of their organization and determines how they handle ethical situations on a daily basis. My personal ethical perspective is substantially…

Words 2237 - Pages 9

Essay about Ethics and Professional Life

the difference between right and wrong. According to Velasquez, Andre, Shanks, and Meyer, of Santa Clara University, (2008), "Ethics refers to well based standards of right and wrong that prescribe what humans ought to do, usually in terms of rights, obligations, benefits to society, fairness, or specific virtues." I am going to examine and discuss both personal and professional ethics, while explaining the importance of understanding one’s own personal ethical perspective. Personal ethics are based…

Words 783 - Pages 4

Langston Hughes And Rose's Perspective On Democracy By Reginald Rose

writing strategies about their perspective on democracy however they both talk about their different opinions on democracy For instance Hughes wanted it to be equal for him and rose wanted everyone to have equal rights. Rose’s perspective on democracy is that democracy isn't being taken seriously. He uses his drama to show this when some people serve on jury want to finish the case so that they can get back to their regular lives. Reginald Rose talks about his perspective on democracy using drama and…

Words 242 - Pages 1

Sociology Assingment on Religion Essay

means to them personally, causing this to be an extremely interesting topic of discussion. Because of so many different religious beliefs in our diverse culture we will analyze several different perspectives of religion along with why or why not it is appropriate for the workplace. The Religious rights in the workplace state “The term "religion" includes all aspects of religious observance and practice, as well as belief, unless an employer demonstrates that he is unable to reasonably accommodate…

Words 960 - Pages 4

Evidence Based Practice Model

case the ID individual, while following all ethical principles and critical thinking. There are three different perspectives to apply with this method, which are “A Client’s Right to Self-Determination, Strengths and the Holistic Perspective, Eclectic or Integrative Perspective.” The first perspective, “A Client’s Right to Self-Determination,” means that the client has the right to determine what is best for themselves within reason. For the…

Words 575 - Pages 3

Democracy In 12 Angry Men

Throughout the years, many people have had numerous perspectives on democracy. A few individuals may feel it is reasonable and fair, while others feel it isn’t equivalent and unfair. In “12 Angry Men” by Reginald Rose, “Democracy” by Langston Hughes, and “Telling Americans To Vote, Or Else” by William Galston, all authors convey their perspective on democracy. Although these authors perspectives on democracy contrast from one another. They all similarly recognize that there are flaws within a democratic…

Words 1240 - Pages 5

The Feminist Activism

Each chapter examines a current feminist perspective and highlights the main feminist critiques of the perspective. The text starts by introducing us to Feminist activism and explaining how it is often divided into two periods; the late nineteenth century (first wave) and the 1960s and 1970s (the second wave). Both periods were very important parts of the feminist movement and have helped bring out changes to our society in how woman are viewed, their rights, and how gender issues are understood. The…

Words 811 - Pages 4

Ad Paper Comm2600

exists towards women (UN Women, 2013). What is the point of these ads? They use different levels of perspective, the transmissional perspective and ritual perspective, to affect how an audience thinks or feels (Baran, 2009). The UN Women Campaign advertisement brings shocking information into the open. Women gained the right to vote through the 19th amendment and through that gained equal rights or that is what we all assumed. All of the searches posted on the campaign advertisements are real and…

Words 688 - Pages 3

Essay on julius caesar

“Examining the idea that “sometimes what is right to one person is wrong to another”, and this can generate diverse insights” People have different thoughts of what “good” music is but does that mean one person I right and the other is wrong? Conflicting perspectives generate diverse insights into what we personally believe in while changing the way we perceive and think of certain situations, events and insights. It is through the funerary speeches of Marcus Brutus and Mark Antony that we are…

Words 550 - Pages 3