Torts: Tort and Easy Legal Cases Essay

Submitted By AramGlasband
Words: 747
Pages: 3
Open Document
In this action plaintiff Paul is suing the defendant ConsumerPro for defamation. To prevail on this action Paul has to prove 1. Defendant made a defamatory statement about him, and 2. Published this statement to a third party who understood the statement to be defamatory against Paul; which 3. Resulted in damage to his reputation, and 4. Damages.
Defendant has moved the court to dismiss plaintiff’s complaint. A motion to dismiss is granted where plaintiff fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. If the defect is curable by amendment courts will grant relief to amend. I. Is Defendant’s statement a non-actionable opinion?
A non-actionable opinion is a statement which cannot be proved false.
Here, ConsumerPro made the statement that Paul is “reputed” to be an ambulance chaser and takes only easy legal cases. First, since ConsumerPro reputes that Paul is this things it will argue that this statement was its’ opinion and not a declaration of fact. This argument will likely prevail because whether or not Paul is an ambulance chaser in either sense of the word cannot be proven false. It is merely an opinion.
Second, the term “ambulance chaser” has both a colloquial and literal definitions. However both definitions imply that Paul is a sub-par attorney which is something that cannot be proven false it is merely an opinion. Additionally the statement that Paul only takes, “the easy cases” is vague and unclear, weighing on the side of an opinion, because the determination of what an easy legal case is subjective and cannot be proven false.
Therefore, the court should grant ConsumerPro’s motion to dismiss because its statements against Paul were opinions and cannot be proven false. II. Must Paul allege malice or negligence in his defamation action against ConsumerPro?
A non-public person does not have to allege malice or negligence in defamation action, only that he suffered damages. A non-public person is a person who does not project themselves into the spotlight.
In this case, Paul is an attorney who litigates automobile accident cases. Based on these facts he does not participate in any offices or events where he thrusts himself into the spotlight. Therefore he would be considered a non-public figure and not have to allege malice or negligence only damages.
Therefore the court should deny ConsumerPro’s motion to dismiss for Paul’s failure to allege malice or negligence because he is not a public figure. III. Must Paul allege special damages in his action against ConsumerPro?
Defamation can be either libel or slander per. In a libel case the plaintiff does not have to allege special damages. In a slander case the plaintiff must prove special damages. In a slander per se case the plaintiff does not have to prove special damages where the defamatory statement is about and or affects his business reputation.
Here since ConsumerPro wrote its comments
Show More

Related Documents: Torts: Tort and Easy Legal Cases Essay

Intruder's Actions

intentionally broke into Sharon’s private property without consent. Furthermore, the intruder is likely to face the civil court for intentional tort against Sharon and Daryl. In precision, the torts that did arise from the incident includes battery with intent to cause assault and harm if either the individuals saw the battery thereto before it happened. Explain your legal duties and responsibilities to Sharon and Daryl As indicated in special relationship, as the owner of Springfield…

Words 1064 - Pages 5

Torts Outline Essay

I. INTRODUCTION TO TORT LIABILITY—WHAT IS TORT LAW UP TO? 1. Tort, definition -- French and Latin, definition points to wrong-doing and twistedness. A civil wrong, other than breach of contract. For an act to be a tort, there must be: a legal duty owed by one person to another, a breach (breaking) of that duty, and harm done as a result of that action. Examples of torts are negligence, battery, and libel. 2. Classifications for locating torts in body of law Private Law v. Public Law. Public…

Words 6877 - Pages 28

Pearson and Mcdonal Lawsuit Analysis Essay

defined as frivolous. One of those cases is the McDonald’s split coffee case. This is the case where the plaintiff spilled her coffee and was rumored to sue McDonald’s for 2.7 million dollars and win. The other’s case is the Pearson dry cleaning case where a man sued Chung Dry Cleaner’s 54 million dollars for losing his pants. The plaintiff won in the McDonald’s Case and the Plaintiff lost in the Dry clearance’s case. In this paper we are going to dissect each case by the facts, the law, the issues…

Words 3462 - Pages 14

Malpractice Research Paper

Professional Malpractice When a person becomes ill, they go to a doctor. Someone seeking legal advice goes to a lawyer. A person in search of an architect, engineer, accountant or member of the clergy looks for a professional in that specific field, to help them solve their situation. It is important to trust these professionals since we typically need them at a vulnerable time in our life. Unfortunately, there may come a time in this relationship when the professional becomes negligent…

Words 1365 - Pages 6

Negligence Notes Essay

MELBOURNE TRADING ACADEMY Legal Issues for Accountants Notes 1: Negligence Chloe Wu 2015/5/21 FXPLUS MELBOURNE _ Chloe Wu The law of torts aims to restore the injured person to the position he or she was in before the tort was committed. A person can only sue in tort if he or she can prove the infringement of a right that has historically been protected by the law of tors or can persuade a court to adapt an existing legal principle to create a new legal right. A tort action is commenced by one…

Words 3391 - Pages 14

Business Regs and Essential Risks Essay

is, why the ERM is becoming more important, how relative people know ERM is alive and well. Meanwhile, internal audit should link between ERM and internal audit (Harb, para.2008). Potential Tort Violations In the business regulation simulation, there were several noticeable tort risks caused by Alumina, Inc. There are numerous regulatory risks that that can assumingly be caused by the company. They are environmental negligence such as water pollution, toxic substances, and hazardous…

Words 2015 - Pages 9

determination of employment Essay

taxes, whether a dismissal is reasonably handled and if the contractual rights are properly applied. According the “master’s tort theory”, the acts of employees are the acts of the employer in law as what the employees do is considered under the authority of the employer. So the employer is totally responsible for whatever his employees do. Another theory named “servant’s tort theory” also indicates that the employer should be liable for the acts of his employees since the employer is the superior…

Words 822 - Pages 4

Online Dating Violence Against Women

Although no amount of legal updating is going to solve the problem of gender-based harassment online, when stalkers, harassers or online bullies can safely engage in online activity, under the assumption that they’ll never be caught, it might be time to revisit all of our laws, policies and practices that should protect women as virtual reality becomes our actual reality. U.S. Department of Justice statistics suggest that 850,00 American adults, who are mostly women, are targets of cyber-stalking…

Words 1299 - Pages 6

Issues related to free Internet download in China Essay

Tomato Garden free of charge. In addition, PC games are relatively easy to pirate and download for free; So many teenagers would do this rather than buy a game. The Chinese users can almost get everything from the Internet, including the best-selling novel, latest movie, music or software by totally free. It sounds that this “free Internet environment” provides Chinese users with “great convenient”, but it’s not. Network tort already became increasingly pressing issue in China since this illegal…

Words 1811 - Pages 8

Criminal Law

Pilgrim films. In this case Montz presented a concept to NBC universal for a reality TV show. The show followed paranormal investigators around in haunted places. Over a number of meetings Montz had with NBC Universal he presented scripts and videos about his idea. After the…

Words 3797 - Pages 16