Torture term paper

Submitted By Madelein_n
Words: 1779
Pages: 8
Open Document
Navarro 1

Is Torture Ever Justified?

Madelein Navarro

Philosophy
Mr. Atwell
January 15, 2014

Navarro 2

Is torture in any form ever justified to gain information for a specific cause? Even if that cause is for good or for bad intentions? Many would state that torture is justified as a last resort or others deem it as inhumane. Torture means any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining from him or a third person information or a confession.1 Torture has the negative effect of dehumanizing a civilization individual but on the other hand torture can be useful in getting information out of hostage taking criminals.
Beatings and physical violence, blinding with light, bone breaking, branding, castration, glasgow smile, and chinese water torture are just the few ways that someone can be tortured.
Guantanamo Bay detention camp is an example in which torture was used ranging from sexual assault/humiliation, sleep deprivation, sensory deprivation, solitary confinement/isolation, forced medication, temperature extremes, watching others being tortured and psychological techniques.
Many of the interrogators were trained by Survival Evasion Resistance Escape (SERE) or had experience in the Joint Personnel Recovery Agency (JPRA). SERE was a program to train military personnel who have been caught as prisoners of war to withstand torture during interrogation. Military personnel went through programs of beatings, starvation, stress positions, and so. The SERE program was established after years of experimentation by the CIA and the other four branches of the U.S. military. It was founded during the Cold War when 36 US air men gave false confessions during the Korean War.2 President Obama on his second day signed an executive order to close Guantanamo. He also signed an executive order outlawing aggressive interrogation techniques. So as a country we will no longer perform torture to
"Defining torture." What is torture? ­. http://www.irct.org/what­is­torture/defining­torture.aspx
"Torture Techniques Used in Guantanamo." The Justice Campaign Supporting Human Rights
Transparency and Fairness for David Hicks..http://thejusticeca mpaign.org/?page_id=273.
1
2

Navarro 3

prisoners but still continue to do so as a last resort. An example of the usage of last resort was the waterboarding ( waterboarding induces panic and suffering by forcing a person to inhale water into the sinuses, pharynx, larynx, and trachea3) that we used in the bin Laden case. It began with Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, who broke under the pressure of harsh interrogation techniques that included waterboarding. He gave information including name of a trusted courier of bin Laden.
As Obama stated that they would no longer continue to use torture, unfortunately in
August 2014 the C.I.A was using wrongful interrogation forms for terrorism suspects after 9/11.
The C.I.A also mislead the Bush administration officials and Congress about the extent and nature of the torture, and that torture was ineffective for intelligence gathering. The President allowed the use of torture for the C.I.A and is allowing people such as, George Tenet the
Director of Central Intelligence (DCI) for the United States Central Intelligence Agency, to go ahead and protest what he signed to be prohibited. As this report became worldwide issue from multiple countries gave their opinions on the situation that the US has applied to torture. One of the countries that replied were China: Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Hong Lei told reporters Wednesday: "China consistently opposes torture. We believe that the U.S. side should reflect upon and rectify its relevant behavior, earnestly obey and implement the provisions of international conventions. In a
commentary
Show More

Related Documents: Torture term paper

Argumentative Essay On Torture

ON TORTURE This paper will systematically investigate different positions taken on the moral permissibility of torture, to reveal that torture is not to be accepted or justified under any circumstance. In order to effectively address the matter, we ought to come to definitional terms with “torture”, despite the lack of unanimity and the spread of contextual usage of the term. For the scope of this paper, the term “torture” will be adopted to refer to any act by which mental or physical pain…

Words 1031 - Pages 5

Censorship in 1984 by George Orwell Essay

almost all claims made by the Party in this novel, the truth is left ambiguous and the reader is not told whether the documents are truly destroyed. For example, a picture which Winston throws into one early in the novel is produced later during his torture session, if only to be thrown back in an instant later. Nineteen Eighty-Four (sometimes written 1984) is a 1949 dystopian novel by George Orwell about an oligarchical, collectivist society. Life in the Oceania province of Airstrip One is a world of…

Words 1329 - Pages 6

Essay on Nine Lives 2 Faces

He has 730,000 followers on twitter, and 2.1 million followers on Instagram. According to google the term Alex From Target was googled more than Justin Bieber in a few weeks after he became famous. Others have tried to gain popularity off of Alex’s fame. Alex has gained so much fame that his life has been threatened, and his family’s personal information was leaked onto the internet. Is Torture Ever Justified? Gul Rahman was a prisoner in 2002 at a secret American detention site in Afghanistan…

Words 759 - Pages 4

Southern Slavery Analysis

Slavery in the south has two main interpretations, the economic interpretation and the paternalistic interpretation. While both were rooted in the concept of keeping slaves for economic gain, there were differences in the ways the slaves were treated and viewed. But the economic interpretation is far more likely considering, the african american slaves that were geological transferred for possible profits into the booming cotton empire and that were put in conditions that were completely subjective…

Words 1389 - Pages 6

Lindsay TravisManagement 382Shell Argument PaperShell Should

Lindsay Travis Management 382 Shell Argument Paper Shell should follow the same standards in Nigeria that it follows in the US, England and the Netherlands. 1. Principle of Fairness/Distributive Justice – Never take any action that harms the least among us; the poor, the uneducated, the unemployed. Shell makes billions of dollars from the oil drilled in Nigeria, but very little of that is received by the Nigerian people. The village surrounding Shell doesn’t have any running water, and barely…

Words 313 - Pages 2

Darkness: V for Vendetta and Social Construct Essay

Darnkess isn’t what you think it is Darkness is defined by who is in power, not by what is actually dark. Darkness over time, both in literature and in society, has always taken on a negative connotation. It is often viewed in conjunction with terms such as evil and bad, when in actuality this idea of darkness stems from societies constant fear on the unknown. Darkness as an evil force is a social construct established by a moral code and due to the differences in moral codes throughout society…

Words 1658 - Pages 7

Guantanamo Bay Research Paper

public bus, to return to Germany when the police stopped the bus he was in. He was the only non-Pakistani on the bus and with his bright red hair, it was very obvious he was out of place. The police asked him to step off the bus to look through his papers as well as ask some questions. Murat had been told by Journalist that this same things had happened to them, so he explained to the police he was not a journalist, but a tourist. At this point the police detained Murat but promised him they would…

Words 4698 - Pages 19

Un Peace Keepers Research Paper

Nations after the tragedy, however had little power, failing to stop Germany from invading Poland in 1939. The UN was officially formed in 1945 when the charter of the United Nations was drafted at the San Fransisco conference in California, where the term ‘United Nations’ was first coined by Franklin D. Roosevelt and Winston Churchill. The conference was attended to by 50 nations and several non-government organisation (NGO). This officially stated the unity of Great Britain, the United States and…

Words 598 - Pages 3

No Exit Comparitive Paper

Xxxxx xxxxxx xxxx xxxxxxx xxx xx xx xxxxxxx xxxx No Exit Comparative Paper In the play, “No Exit” by Jean-Paul Sartre there are vast types of themes in relation with existentialism. In the play it proves to be that the indefinite truth of the innate need to gain recognition and reinforcement exist in many areas such as it is+ incorporated in the play. When dealing with the situation it can undoubtedly lead to the destruction of not only relationships amongst others but also the ultimate destruction…

Words 727 - Pages 3

Carmen Garcia Documentary Essay

they follow labor right lawyers Daniel Kovalik, Terry Collingsworth and activist Ray Rogers as they take action against Coca-Cola’s violation of human rights against the labour union. This documentary shows Coca-Cola’s involvement in the kidnapping, torture and murder of union leaders…

Words 1102 - Pages 5