ultimate essay

Submitted By cole-nicosia
Words: 1597
Pages: 7
Open Document
Cole Nicosia
There is currently an intense and on going debate between what Americans should do with immigrants and other sub cultures. Multiculturalists believe that immigrants can have two identities and do not have to call themselves Americans and live only within American culture. Assimilationists believe that all immigrant cultures need to come together to form one nation’s culture in which you only participate. Two Yale students, Trevor Wagner and Laura Marcus, participated in this on going debate each explaining why they are right. Trevor Wagner addresses the pro side of the debate and Laura Marcus addresses the con. Trevor Wagner believes that America is changing because of immigrants not appreciating and understanding American values and claims that immigrants need to be assimilated for America to be its best. In contrast, Laura Marcus believes that a little assimilation is good but claims that you can have two identities and still be American and practice your other culture. After analyzing the students’ facts, support, and tone, it becomes clear that Trevor Wagner’s speech was more superior.

Support is essential in a persuasive argument. Depending on how you support yourself in your argument will greatly impact the audiences’ point of view in what you are saying. In the pro argument, Wagner does this with precision. In the argument, he supports his claims with great detail, and also provides possible scenarios of consequences if we don’t take his side. On the other hand, Marcus supports her claims using manly her opinions and self-experiences creating a weaker argument. Wagner indicated that immigrants need to adapt to American public mores and stated, “If we do not force immigrants to accept the superiority of our public mores, then we weaken them by allowing the rise of a large class of voters who have values that directly contradict those of the American republic.” This provides good support for his position because he’s saying something that can definitely happen. When people become uneducated of their government, they will be taken advantage of, thus weakening our nation and repeating other instances where this happened in history. On the other hand, Marcus’ argument supports her claim that immigrants want to have more than one identity by stating ,” They come with the baggage of their home country and often want to cling to them … But most times they are happy to adopt an American identity alongside it.” She is supporting her claim these immigrants want to cling to their home country but are happy to get another identity. Further, that all Immigrants feel the same way. When her audience hears this oversimplification of how these immigrants feel, they believe that she is not only giving poor support, but she creates an oversimplification of the way immigrants feel when coming to America and uses no true evidence to back it up. We know she feels like this because she speaks of what immigrants do as if they all do the same thing, when in reality they don’t. Some immigrants could have had it rough in their home countries and are looking forward to adopting American customs. This weakens her argument because she is not giving in depth support in what she is saying. So basically, she is speaking her opinions of what immigrants do and states all immigrants want this or that, when in reality all immigrants may not want the same things she does. She attempts to create support of her claim after using things of what she been through with her life and her opinion on what other immigrants believed. The pro argument presented not only goes into depth, but he doesn’t include only his opinions and untruthful support to back him up. He creates this possible and convincing scenario that; if we don’t assimilate the nation can become weak. In contrast, the con side is just simply trying to win over people opinions by only using her opinion, and doesn’t include anything else to make her argument side actually
Show More

Related Documents: ultimate essay

The Ultimate Taboo Essay

The Ultimate Taboo: ‘Survival Cannibalism’ Reflective Assignment—Grade 12 Law Course Cannibalism is often regarded as one of the most deeply repugnant acts to be committed in a civilized society--one that is fraught with obsessive fears and fascination. However in such extreme circumstances as that of R v. Dudley and Stephens (1884), State v. Holmes (1841), or the case of the Donner Party (1846-47); these extremist of situations had about them a kind of normality found only in our innate human…

Words 694 - Pages 3

Essay on Perception and Ultimate Truth

is even possible it follows that God exists. The final argument which I will continue discussing in depth is the action of personal experience for the containment of ultimate truths. One must be open to belief based on insufficient evidence and spiritual perception. In doing so, you attain the possibility to discover of ultimate truth and enlightenment. In “The Ethics of belief”, William Kingdon Clifford defends the rigid principle that we are always obliged to have sufficient evidence for every…

Words 1381 - Pages 6

Ultimate Frisbee Argumentative Essay

Ultimate Frisbee is a sport played by 14 players, 7 on each team wherein the goal is to pass the white disc up the field until it is caught in the end zone. Originally created by high school students in New Jersey, the sport combines aspects of populars sports creating a fast paced strategy filled game. It has grown and spread to nearly 80 countries. Whether Ultimate Frisbee should be an Olympic sport is an ongoing argument that is debated between Ultimate lovers and haters. Some question its legitimacy…

Words 443 - Pages 2

Waiting for the Ultimate Storm Essay

Waiting for the Ultimate Storm The year was 1992, and Hurricane Andrew gave us the most haunting visit South Florida had seen in over thirty years. The voice in the radio came booming through, like a wrecking ball in full swing. Stores were running out of supplies faster than the stock boys could bring them out from storage. Bottled water, canned goods, batteries, and candles were more precious than the brightest of diamonds imaginable. I gathered as much as I could get my hands on, and rushed…

Words 667 - Pages 3

Essay about Hinduism and Ultimate Goal

Dharma- Hindu belief, a person’s religious and moral duties Moksha-Hindu belief, ultimate goal or existence- union with Brahman 7) he Vedas tells us about Aryan society. It is a collection of hymns, chants, ritual instructions and other religious teachings. 8) In Hinduism, a person’s ultimate goal is to reach moksha, the union with Brahman. They have to free themselves from selfish behavior. In Buddhism, the ultimate goal is nirvana, union with the universe and it releases them from the cycle of…

Words 791 - Pages 4

Deformation: Ultimate Tensile Strength Essay

appropriate. a. Pascal b. offset yield strength c. ultimate tensile strength d. plastic strain e. hardness 2. Given specific dimensions and load-elongation data from a metal tensile test, calculate stresses and strains, plot an appropriate stress-strain curve, and determine the yield strength (by the 0.2% offset method when appropriate or by the sudden change in slope of the stress-strain curve when appropriate), the elastic modulus, and the ultimate tensile strength. 3. Given the dimensions of…

Words 2808 - Pages 12

Utilitarianism and Ultimate Moral Principle Essay

Chapter 7 1. Bentham believed in one ultimate moral principle, namely, the Principle of Utility. This principle requires us, in all circumstances, to produce the most happiness that we can. 2. To understand why the Principle of Utility was so radical, we have to appreciate what it leaves out of morality: Gone are all references to God or to abstract moral rules “written in the heavens “. Morally is no longer conceived ha faithfulness to some divinely given code or some set of inflexible…

Words 351 - Pages 2

The Final Response of the Ultimate Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy Essay

Sophia Marraccini Mr. Ceruzzi ­ Final Reading Response of The Ultimate Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy Since the first book in the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy was only 200 pages, I decided to read the first two books instead, so this second reader response is on the second book. The second book itself is called “The Restaurant at the End of the Universe.” In it, it continues the basic plot of the story, where the Earth is destroyed it to make a hyperspace bypass and Arthur Dent, one of the last survivors of the Earth…

Words 583 - Pages 3

Breaking Through the Boundaries: the Ultimate Love Story Essay

Breaking Through the Barriers: The Ultimate Love Story By: Yanelly Torres Dr. Laura Meyer Art History 131 February 28, 2013 Throughout art history there have been many artists who refer back to mythological figures and tales as artistic inspiration. Mythological stories, as well as the ideas of classic history, became increasingly reverted back to with the start of Neoclassicism. Rationality and tradition were rediscovered and implemented into artwork more frequently in the mid-eighteenth…

Words 1308 - Pages 6

Psycho: Cary Grant and Ultimate Hitchcock Masterpiece Essay

other. “North by Northwest”, “Notorious”, “Vertigo”, “Rear Window”, “The Birds”, “Shadow of a Doubt”, “Strangers on a Train”, “Rebecca”, “Suspicion”, “The 39 Steps” and “Psycho” are among his most loved. The truth is there is no such thing as one ultimate Hitchcock masterpiece, there are only favorites. Every month or so, I tend to invite a close group of film professors, directors, editors, writers, and critics to my living room. We watch some of the greatest films together. The screenings always…

Words 344 - Pages 2