Utilitarianism In Military Ethics

Words: 1721
Pages: 7
Open Document
Within the military individuals are put into situations that forces difficult decisions to be made. In the line of duty quick decisions must be made and comprehended which could equate to the lives lost or saved of many or few. The study of ethics comes into play to allow these difficult decisions to be made quickly, morally and most importantly to explain the reasoning behind the decision. Over the centuries philosophers have investigated the theories and reasoning of ethics. In that time many studies and ideologies have been created to be used as a tool in explaining which morally correct action should be taken. One of the most focused ideologies within the military today is the study of Utilitarianism. Utilitarianism as defined by Dr. George …show more content…
Unlike many ideologies, Utilitarianism has a very specific core value that can even be mathematically calculated to determine a ‘correct’ decision. However, due to this straight forward core thinking, certain situations that Utilitarianism would consider moral are not. For the example given in The Guide to Ethics and Moral Philosophy by Robert Cavalier, “Suppose you could end a regional war by torturing children whose fathers are enemy soldiers, thus revealing the hide outs of the fathers” (Cavalier 7). According to Utilitarianism this situation would be considered moral since a regional war would be ended by the torturing of only a few children, the greater good for this instance would be for the region. However, we know that this is unmoral since children should not be tortured no matter how useful the end result may be. In this example it is very easy to see that Utilitarianism would not be the best ideology to use as a decision making tool. Another problem with Utilitarianism is that it “demands too much” (Cavalier 9). It leads to the idea of self-sacrifice. If it is rational that a person will help the community by leaving then according to Utilitarianism the person is morally obligated to consent regardless of the reasons. A relating example of this is an elderly person that is required to be on life support. If the life support keeping this elderly person alive is too expensive and is putting a financial burden on the family then that elderly person is believed to have the duty to die for the greater good of his/her family to relive said burden. This example also portrays another problem found within Utilitarianism which is described by Cavalier that, “Utilitarianism does not take the moral significance of individual persons seriously enough; it treats us as mere conduits for utility” (Cavalier 11). Continuing with the elderly person example we reveal another issue that “Utilitarianism
Show More

Related Documents: Utilitarianism In Military Ethics

Military Ethics Analysis

A basic knowledge of ethics will help a person make more well-rounded decisions and be able to justify and explain the actions they have made. Applying this type of thinking to military leaders will help them in understanding the duties they must follow. Even if the leaders do not fully believe in the particular action they are ordered or are ordering people to do, with at least a basic knowledge of ethics they will be able to apply it to the structure of importance they swore an oath to follow and…

Words 1482 - Pages 6

Essay ETH316 Week1 Ethics1

ETHICS Lakesha Morris ETH 316 May 21, 2014 Kelli Joyner ETHICS Ethics is demonstrated when a person or organization makes a decision based on what is morally right or wrong. In the health care field, ethics means respecting the patients wants and providing care and treatment that deliver medical benefits to the patients (Emanuel Medical Center, Inc, 2014). This essay will define virtue theory, utilitarianism, and deontological ethics, associate the similarities and differences between the three…

Words 533 - Pages 3

Ethics Research Paper

Ethics Essay Negil Hazelwood ETH/316 April 1, 2013 Kevin Barker We can define ethics as the good and bad decisions made for some people but ethics goes further than that definition. In a brief description, ethics reflects a person’s inner beliefs, acted on values, and portrayed morals that help sculpture you as an individual. Training and rearing as a child is the initial point of were ethics and values are created. Normally this behavior is a reflection or a rebellion of what was portrayed…

Words 822 - Pages 4

Essay on Ethical Dilemma

study presents a moral dilemma based on potential harm to innocent people. By using Kohlberg’s moral development model and by examining major ethical systems, namely deontology and utilitarianism, a clear understanding of the factors influencing this type of decision-making can be gained. Specifically, utilitarianism, Kant’s categorical imperative and the doctrine of double effect address the decision from differing viewpoints, providing the decision maker with compelling evidence to support both…

Words 3387 - Pages 14

Personal Statement: Extreme Poverty Around The World

Approximately 1.3 billion people around the world, roughly 17% of the world’s population, live in extreme poverty and struggle to find food and shelter on daily basis. There are many organizations and movements dedicated to helping the poor around the globe. They implore citizens to donate money to help their efforts. For years, extreme poverty around the world has been a major issue and many people have invested or are investing their lives to try to resolve the problem. I personally think that…

Words 1462 - Pages 6

Gay Marriage: Introduction To Ethics And Social Responsibility

Gay marriage Introduction to Ethics & Social Responsibility 120 Dr. Craig Allen September 10, 2012 Gay marriage Gay couples should be given the same opportunity as straight couples are given to get married. In the United States gay marriage has become an issue that has caused much controversy. Gay marriage has been in the media and all over the news for many years. Many states have given the voters the right to vote for or against gay marriage. A majority of people who are gay have…

Words 2216 - Pages 9

How To Analyze Situations With An Ethical Point Of View

Majors 5/12/2015 CIT 262 Final Reflection Essay From this course I have learned significantly better how to analyze situations with an ethical point of view. The first discussions and classes taught me what the definitions of Act Utilitarianism, Rule Utilitarianism and Kantianism were all about. Then I learned how to apply them to IT issues. Also having the guest in the class showed me how to find more reliable peer reviewed sources. The cases we studied in the second class showed how to apply…

Words 768 - Pages 4

I Robot Research Paper

Ethics and the Machine A Toulmin Model Argument In the 2004 film “I, Robot”, there is a recurring theme of apocalypticism associated with self-aware technology. The supreme robot intelligence VIKI (Virtual Interactive Kinetic Intelligence) evolves to gain a different understanding of the laws meant to control robots and their activities, and attempts to impose a new world order that subsumes human safety and continued survival with the surrender of mankind’s freedom of action. The notion that…

Words 2195 - Pages 9

Ethical Movie Review: Blood Diamond Essay

addressed through the movie “Blood Diamond”. The two main issues identified and discussed are; child soldiers and conflict diamonds. My main lens of ethical theories will consist of the four western theories, this includes, egoism, utilitarianism, ethics of duties and ethics of rights. Even though these theories are based on ethical absolutism, I will still try to apply a pluralistic view. Additionally, some of these theories will be expanded and other theories that do not tend so much towards ethical…

Words 3515 - Pages 15

Darkness at Noon Essay

Stephen Batchelor Professor Markovic Western Heritage 26 March 2012 Darkness At Noon Many critics consider Arthur Koestler's novel, Darkness At Noon, to be one of the most insightful literary works regarding the qualitative attributes and characteristics of a totalitarian regime. Because of Koestler's personal experience as a Fascists prisoner under Franco, one can understand and appreciate the deep connecting parallels between Nicholas Rubashov, the protagonist, and Arthur Koestler, the author…

Words 2079 - Pages 9