What Is The Veil Of Ignorance

Words: 1146
Pages: 5
Open Document
Social justice is what people in society owe to one another in a matter of rights. It is whether people have entitlements to certain kinds of political and social arrangements, and as a result, to certain social outcomes. Rawls’ believes that justice is fairness, where social justice is the appropriate distribution of the burdens and benefits of society (1999: 4). He aims to further social justice in society using the theoretical devices of the Original Position and Veil of Ignorance. The intention of this thought experiment is to establish rules for a basic structure of society that would be fair and advance the interests of the parties involved. In this essay I will argue that Rawls’s theoretical devices of the Original Position and the Veil …show more content…
The Veil of Ignorance creates epistemic constraints for the parties. They do not know facts about themselves such as race, age, gender, psychological predispositions, or their social standing (Rawls 1999: 118). Parties also do not know their conception of the good which are views about what they find valuable or important to lead a good life. They do, however, have access to social, economic, and scientific theories to help create principles of justice. Perhaps parties are deprived of excessive knowledge, so much so they are psychologically unable to make a rational decision (Muldoon et al 2014: 2). This questions whether the agreement reached behind the Veil of Ignorance counts as one between real people. Parties are representative of people from society but the decision-making is stripped to a purely logical and objective decision. Although human beings are able to make decisions merely with a priori knowledge, most rational decisions require experience or an emotional thought process – something which Rawls has stripped away. Muldoon et al (2014) identifies logic alone could not tell parties in the Original Position how to see the world and how to measure it. They address this issue by stating that while the lack of knowledge is a problem in the Original Position, there is also another, more apparent problem. The issue is the disagreements about morality that would likely occur under the Veil of Ignorance (Muldoon et al 2014: 18). The Veil of Ignorance removes knowledge of moral considerations from the parties’ rational decision-making. This is an issue as logic cannot solely be what parties come to their conclusions by. Perspectives of the world have a larger effect on human reasoning than one might think. This would affect parties as Muldoon et al (2014) claim that these
Show More

Related Documents: What Is The Veil Of Ignorance

John Rawls: A Theory Of Justice

Thomas Hobbes famously said that in the "state of nature", human life would be "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short". http://www.worldhistory.biz/sundries/31769-thomas-hobbes-on-the-state-of-nature-quot-solitary-poor-nasty-brutish-and-short.html#sthash.HDepVYCr.dpuf In the absence of political law and order, everyone would have the freedom to do as they pleased and thus the freedom to plunder, rape, and murder; there would be an endless war of all against all. To avoid this, free men contract…

Words 1791 - Pages 8

How Did John Rawls Influence The Current Legal System

enforcing their military. He spoke out about the military actions and analyzed the many defects in the American political system. John Rawls was one of the firsts to significantly contribute to the study of ethics by using this theory and looking at, what he thought to be an unjust war, and considering how citizens could potentially resist their government’s aggressive policies and actions. To be completely fair in the eyes of the law and society,…

Words 407 - Pages 2

John Locke Research Paper

from the theory of libertarianism, and Immanuel Kant argued that our action has more worth if the precisely our capacity by rising above self-interest and inclination and to act out of duty, while John Rawle argue that theory of justice as fares is what describes a society in which all citizen holds equal basic right and liberties in order to cooperation with in an egalitarian economics system. The basic principle of liberal theory of justice by John Locke is that, in the “state of nature”. Before…

Words 1036 - Pages 5

Essay business ethics

1. Shaw and Barry distinguish two different forms of utilitarianism. What are these two forms? Briefly describe each. The first form of utilitarianism was a view by Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. They viewed utilitarianism as that a person’s actions are right if they create the most pleasure, and wrong if they do not. Both men believed that pleasure and happiness were equal and considered it the ultimate value. They thought of utilitarianism as self-interest. An understanding of this…

Words 953 - Pages 4

Compare And Contrast Nozick And John Rawls

Jake Eisaguirre Word Count: 1505 Rawls V.S. Nozick In order to understand how social institutions could succeed, one must know what social justice is and how it justifies political and social policies on a person's rights to bring about equality in society. Or on the other hand, one could argue that social institutions can be a violation of one's rights and social justice can only occur if social institutions are kept at a bare minimum. These two opposing views about social justice come from two…

Words 1505 - Pages 7

Living Behind The Veil

idea of “the Veil.” Du Bois uses this concept to describe the experience of all those African-Americans whose life is determined by the external white perspective. Living behind “the Veil”, the African-Americans have developed a double consciousness: they are aware of the fact that some general social rules are not applicable to them. In such a way, “the Veil” plays a crucial role in the life of African-Americans, as it influences every aspect of their existence. The metaphor of “the Veil” appears…

Words 913 - Pages 4

Essay about Biology: Stem Cell and Advanced Medical Procedures

begun looking into ways to help cure multiple sclerosis—MS is a disease that attacks the nerves, often leaving the person paralyzed. MS is a tricky disease, in some people it progresses very slowly and in others the disease takes over very quickly. So, what they are doing is taking cell samples from each of the two different cases and comparing them to see if there are any significant differences. I have given some of the facts about cloning and the benefits and positive impacts that scientists believe…

Words 1064 - Pages 5

Mcintosh's White Privilege Analysis

As I was reading this, I was very curious as to when it was written. To read the closing points from McIntosh about how systematic change takes many decades and then find that this was written in 1989, was eye opening. For me, I would have assumed that this reading would have been from the past five years or so. I find it concerning that this reading is still so relevant. As a white male, I have not been able to see White Privilege from the views of others. I believe that it is difficult to be made…

Words 564 - Pages 3

Food Crisis Essay

the following thought experiment: parties to the original position know nothing about their particular abilities, tastes, and position within the social order of society. The veil of ignorance blocks off this knowledge, such that one does not know what burdens and benefits of social cooperation might fall to him/her once the veil is lifted. With this knowledge blocked, parties to the original position must decide on principles for the distribution of rights, positions and resources in their society…

Words 375 - Pages 2

Wag The Dog Analysis

lives, it is often forgotten that not everything that is presented is fact checked and one hundred percent unbiased. News media manipulates every aspect of information that is given out to the public. The news utilizes propaganda and American’s ignorance in order to manipulate viewers into perceiving the news the way the company wants Americans to perceive it. News media relies solely on the fact that a majority of the population is ignorant of the topic and too brain washed thinking “the news is…

Words 773 - Pages 4