Who Is Lizzie Borden Guilty

Words: 1210
Pages: 5
Open Document
Many people know the story of Lizzie Borden from the popular nursery rhyme. What most don’t know, however, are the gruesome, malicious details behind the rhyme, and what caused the killer to get away with murder, unscathed. The story of Lizzie Borden, and the murders of her parents brings up many different arguments, and anyone who knows about the murders, knows that there are multiple opinions on what happened that fateful night. Though the background of the Borden family, discovery of the bodies, the trials and life after the murders, many suspicions and much evidence arise that leads most to suspect that Lizzie Borden was guilty of the murders of her own two parents. The victims of the gruesome murder on August 4, 1892, were Andrew and …show more content…
Bowen, making the conclusion that the suffering of the Borden’s was short lived. Shortly after Dr. Bowen indicated this, police arrived on the scene of the crime to keep neighbors at a distance. The medical examiner who was the next to arrive, concluded that the wounds were created by a heavy, sharp object, such as an ax or hatchet, and that the killer had to be a tall, strong person. During the police search of the house, they looked for any traces of the murderer or the weapon, but nothing was discovered that could identify who the murderer was. The only thing found was an outline of a body in the loft of the barn, as if someone had slept there the night before. The main suspect for the murders, immediately, was Lizzie. Suspicion had turned to Lizzie, since no one else was in the house that day, and no signs of an intruder were present. On August 11, 1892, Lizzie Borden was arrested and accused of the murders of her father and stepmother. She was questioned two days earlier, and gave “confused and contradictory answers” according to the police. After she was arrested and taken to jail, she pleaded not guilty. On August 22, lizzie had a preliminary hearing, and at the end, the judge pronounced her “probably guilty” and ordered her to face a grand jury. After her trial in front of the grand jury, she, again, gave confusing and jumbled answers when she was asked questions, and during the maid’s questioning, she sat with her …show more content…
Most of their fathers money was given to Lizzie, and she used some of it to attend arts conventions and associate with the arts. Her sister moved out of their house in 1905, and gave all her money to charity before dying on June 10, 1927, in New Hampshire. Lizzie, however, remained on the property for the rest of her life, being accused of shoplifting in 1907, further tarnishing her reputation. She died of pneumonia in 1927. (Howard) The suspicion that Lizzie Borden was, in fact, the murderer of her parents, was further backed up by Lizzie’s background and evidence that found her guilty. Even though her trial proved her not guilty, many still believe she is the murderer and specific examples and evidence is given to prove that. The fact that she did get away with murder and lived out the rest of her life free of charge makes most people upset, but the guilt she had to live with, knowing she murdered her parents, is almost punishment
Show More

Related Documents: Who Is Lizzie Borden Guilty

Lizzie Borden Research Paper

committed, Lizzie Borden was questioned by the police about the events that took place prior. Lizzie’s responses to the police were deemed to be “inconsistent” and she was “rambling.” Many of her answers were confusing and did not make sense with the crime. At the time that the murders took place, Lizzie had multiple different stories about where she was. She told police she was out in the yard, retrieving fishing gear from the barn, and that she was out picking pears. Police arrested Lizzie for the…

Words 2282 - Pages 10

The Guilt: A Case Of Lizzie Borden

are the real guilty ones. According to the prisoners, a lot of people who are found Innocent are guilty for the crime. Even though Lizzie spent 10 months in Massachusetts prison, she was found innocent. In my opinion, if a girl is being abused she would be mad and lose her mind and kill her parents. Lizzie didn’t have the best relationship with her stepmother and was always cold blooded towards Abby. Lizzie Borden has a lot of evidence against her that she committed this crime. Lizzie killed her…

Words 350 - Pages 2

Lizzie Borden Research Paper

Lizzie Borden was born in Fall River, Massachusetts on July 19, 1860. Her mother died when she was only two years old. Lizzie’s father, Andrew, remarried shortly after to a woman named Abby. Lizzie’s older sister, Emma, was ten years older than her. Emma fulfilled the role as Lizzie’s mother. The family lived in an old home downtown, with no gas lighting, hot water, or even a bathtub. Abby was quiet and often stayed in the home and had friends over. The Borden sisters and the relationship with their…

Words 2075 - Pages 9

Lizzie Borden Theories

Borden murders still stand as an enigma in American crime cases. Arnold R. Brown portrays this event through his book, where he displays his theory on who committed this crime. He automatically believed the conspiracy that Lizzie had killed her dad and stepmom until he began to truly dissect this case. ‘Lizzie Borden: The Legend, the Truth, the Final Chapter’, written by Arnold R. Brown, accomplished the goal of displaying his theory, however, I did not like the way this book was set up with unnecessary…

Words 876 - Pages 4

Lizzie Borden Persuasion

might have had two culprits who had gotten off the hook. Almost the entire world has heard of Lizzie Borden, the girl who brutally murdered her parents with a hatchet, but there could be another suspect. Borden had to have had a helper to complete this crime and it had to have been the servant Bridget Sullivan due to their stories changing, the undisturbed crime scene, and Bridget standing up for Lizzie, though evidence proved guilty. On August 4th, 1892 Andrew and Abby Borden were hacked to pieces in…

Words 805 - Pages 4

Lizzie Borden

Murder is an atrocious part of life. June 5, 1893 in a quiet town there was a brutal of a husband and wife, the main suspect in the case was lizzie Borden, the victim’s very own daughter. It seems obvious that lizzie Borden did it due to the trail, dress , poison , and hatchet. For example when she was in the trail felt calm and looked like she don’t care. If you lost a loved one in your family that was murdered you will be sad. The trail said she was laughing down stairs she could done it because…

Words 558 - Pages 3

Lizzie Borden Essay

Lizzie Borden Lizzie Borden took an axe and gave her mother forty whacks. Once she saw what she had done, she gave her father forty-one. So, goes the old verse that immortalized Lizzie Borden as one of history's most notorious murderers, fair or not. Lizzie was born on July 19, 1860 — the youngest child of Andrew Jackson Borden and Sarah Morse Borden. Lizzie was a young, unmarried woman who lived with her parents in Fall River, Massachusetts. Her mother died when she was two years old…

Words 1082 - Pages 5

Lizzie Borden Case Study

The Lizzie Borden case is extremely intriguing. Andrew and Abby Borden were both found brutally murdered in their home in Fall River, Massachusetts. Lizzie Borden, Andrew and Abby’s daughter, notified the family’s maid of the discovery of Andrew Borden lying dead of the sofa. The authorities were notified and a subsequent search of the house found the body of Abby. According to Barbara Maranzani of History.com, Andrew Borden did not lack in the area of enemies and by all accounts was involved in…

Words 729 - Pages 3

Case Of Lizzie Borden

discuss the untrue and heinous allegations presented against Ms. Lizzie Borden. If you turn to anyone of acquaintance to Ms. Borden, it is apparent that she is an amiable, charitable woman. As reported in the Boston Herald, “They talked of her life, of her inclinations, her interest in church work, her modesty of manner, unswerving sincerity, gentle forbearance and aspirations to be and to do all that is best and right in life. [.] Lizzie Borden's life is full of good works, kindly offices in the church…

Words 692 - Pages 3

Lizzie Borden: The Murder Of Lizzie Borden

Lizzie Borden was born and raised in St. Fall River, Massachusetts 1806. In 1892 at thirty three still living with her step mom and dad . “She murdered” them both with a hatchet her step mom 19 times in the head and and dad 10 times. August 11th , Lizzie was arrested for the murders,although there was no physical evidence linking her to them. There was a person who had said she attempted buying prussic acid, a very poisonous liquid, in the days before the murders. A women named Emma claimed to have…

Words 198 - Pages 1