Why Ability Assessments Don't Cross Cultures Essay

Words: 10048
Pages: 41
Open Document
You Can't Take It With You
Why Ability Assessments Don't Cross Cultures
Patricia M. Greenfield University of California, Los Angeles

A central thesis of this article is that ability tests can be analyzed as items of symbolic culture. This theoretical perspective, based in cultural psychology, provides psychological researchers and clinicians with the tools to detect, correct, and avoid the cross-cultural misunderstandings that undermine the validity of ability tests applied outside their culture of origin. When testers use tests developed in their own culture to test members of a different culture, testees often do not share the presuppositions about values, knowledge, and communication implicitly assumed by the test. These …show more content…
Knowing. For a test to travel freely, (a) the universal unit of knowing must be the individual, and (b) (although not for all ability tests) there must be a universal distinction between the process of knowing and the object of knowledge. Communication. For a test to travel freely, (a) the function of questions must be universal, (b) the definition of relevant information must be universally the same, (c) decontextualized communication (communicating about something that is irrelevant to the immediate situation) must be universally familiar, and (d) communicating with strangers in an impersonal manner must be universally acceptable. Evidence against the universality of each of these conventions is presented in turn. The problems caused by cultural variability in these conventions are analyzed and solutions proposed. For each convention, I discuss how it can be used to detect cross-cultural misunderstanding about the requirements of an ability test and what can be done to correct or prevent this kind of misunderstanding. The ultimate goal is to specify culturally sensitive strategies for the appropriate assessment of abilities in a wide range of cultural contexts.

Values and Meaning
Is There Always Agreement on the Value of a Given Resin_rise?An Example From Cognitive Testing in Liberia
Cole, Gay, Glick, and Sharp (1971) took an object-sorting task to Liberia, where they presented it to their Kpelle
Show More

Related Documents: Why Ability Assessments Don't Cross Cultures Essay

Studying in Uk Essay

challenges/ policies………………………………………………..5 3.3 Method of assessment as it defer…………………………………………6 3.4 Ability to meet up cost by working part-time……………………………..6 3.5 Ability to imbibe time management policy………………………………..6 3.6 The Culture shock phenomenon…………………………………………..7 3.7 Different strategies of persuasion as it differs in the UK……………….7 4.0…

Words 3671 - Pages 15

The Benefits Of Diversity Training

need to understand diversity issues and their impact on products, services and staffing. This diversity-training course discusses the business benefits of diversity in the workplace with guidelines on interacting with different personalities and cultures, and teaches employees to approach diverse people with inclusion and respect. Diversity training became increasingly popular starting in the 1980s. It began as a response to the increasingly diverse workforce that followed the women rights and civil…

Words 1332 - Pages 6

Disproportionate Representation

A Guide to Creating More Equitable Learning Environment,” it described a couple of important issues that were about disproportionate representation. One issue was explained as the success rate of that group. Basically meaning they would base the ability of the students off certain statistics and just put them in special education. Another one was the overrepresentation of certain ethnic groups in special education just because of certain statistics like where they were from. Areas mostly rural and…

Words 1667 - Pages 7

Cultural Literacy: What Every American Need To Know

some of the conceptual ideas surrounding the construct. It presents new core elements of cultural literacy relevant to the 2020s. A critical assessment of…

Words 4389 - Pages 18

Essay on UNIT 50 Sharon Carter Copy

different learners from many different backgrounds, abilities and needs. My role is to be a positive role model to my learners and to effectively promote Equality and Diversity incorporating it within my teaching. Encouraging my learners to engage and interact with one another without any form of prejudice and use of stereotyping taking place. Promote Equality Value Diversity Achieve learning 1. Understand the key features of a culture which promotes equality and diversity. 1.1-…

Words 5582 - Pages 23

An Introduction to Intercultural Communication Essay

An Introduction to Intercultural Communication Intercultural communication is of importance to international businesses as it examines how people from different cultures, beliefs and religions come together to work and communicate with each other. Demands for intercultural communication skills are increasing as more and more businesses go global or international. They realize that there are barriers and limitations when entering a foreign territory. Without the help of intercultural communication…

Words 29173 - Pages 117

Get Synergized Essay

helping organizations (leaders and teams) increase the engagement integrity and alignment that make their work bigger than a game. Our services help you strengthen your ability to stay true to yourself and be a positive force in organizational life - however you define those. The result is better execution and innovation, and the ability to generate extraordinary value for yourself, your organization and the larger world. What services do we provide? ¬ - How can we help! • Team Alignment A team…

Words 4178 - Pages 17

Communication as a Cross-Cultural Challenge for International Management Essay

COMMUNICATION AS A CROSS-­‐CULTURAL CHALLENGE FOR INTERNATIONAL MANAGEMENT A CASE STUDY OF GINA TRICOT Paper within: Bachelor Thesis in Business Administration Authors: Tutor: Frida Mordenfeld Sandra Johansson Pamela Hinojosa Giron Zehra Sayed 881201-­‐5520…

Words 18350 - Pages 74

Assig 3 Essay example

hazards in the work setting or in off site visits………………………………………………………………………………11 Task 3.7: Undertake a health and safety risk assessment in own work setting or service illustrating how its implementation will reduce risk…………………12 Task 3.8:Explain how health and safety risk assessments are monitored and reviewed…………………………………………………………………………………...12 Task 3.9: Explain why it is important to take a balanced approach to risk management………………………………………………………………………………12 Task 3.10: Explain the dilemma…

Words 6296 - Pages 26

Psychology 112 Notes Complete Essay

INTELLIGENCE – the ability to profit from experience, acquire knowledge, think abstractly, and act purposefully, problem solve and adapt to changes in their environment. Origins of intelligence: Genes-nature Environment-nurture Implications of above: EUGENICS – selective breeding, Galton – sensory, perceptual, motor processes, Binet – memory, imagery, comprehension, judgement – Education (intelligence testing) One single Intelligence: G FACTOR – a general intellectual ability assumed to underlie…

Words 4494 - Pages 18