Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior Essay

Words: 1186
Pages: 5
Open Document
Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior
-------------------------------------------------
Amy Chua
“Hey fatty – lose some weight.” Do you think this sound like a mother who is superior? According to the Western idea of what good parenting includes this would be intolerable, but if you consider this from an Eastern point of view this wouldn’t be wrong or abnormal. In additional it seems that Chinese parents can get away with things that Western parents can’t which alludes to talk about two different child-rearing methods which only has one thing in common – they do what they think is best for the child. Amy Chua is an ardent supporter of the eastern way of bringing up children and exposes some of her parenthood experiences in her article “Why …show more content…
Besides logos Amy Chua also uses pathos to appeal to her receivers, but it is essential to recognize that she’s not doing this on purpose. The reason why phatos is represented is this case is caused by the virtuous indignation people get when they read about her manner of upbringing her own children. The major part of Western people feel insulted or else offended and even provoked and hassled because of her statements. With that Amy Chua is able to led the receivers go through an entire chain of emotions and that is caused by pathos. Her way of engage the reader is therefore very cogent because she has her argumentation under control which means that her statements are substantiated. After all is it though difficult to regard her argumentation as reasoned based on her subjective line of approach. But still her rhetorical means has a beneficial effect.
The message is clear – Chinese mothers are superior according to Amy Chua and her opinion is as plain as a pikestaff. Her argumentation will perhaps seems persuasive but it’s important not to disregard the consequences of adopting Amy Chua’s values and methods of upbringing. First of all there is a main difference between the Eastern way of bringing up children which is much more directed by requirements than it is in the Western world where the bringing up is directed by permissions. It’s problematic that Amy Chua refers to the Western parents
Show More

Related Documents: Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior Essay

why chinese mothers are superior Essay

Jacob Weatherly Instructor Shannon Takeuchi Eng. 100 11 October 2014 “Why Chinese Mothers are Superior” Reading Response Amy Chua is a mother of two children who describes herself as the “typical Chinese mother”. She begins her article by letting the audience know the rules of a typical Chinese mother. She says that her kids were never allowed to attend a sleepover, have a playdate, be in a school play, watch TV or play computer games, choose their own extracurricular activities, get any grade…

Words 425 - Pages 2

Amy Chua's Essay 'Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior'

Writer, Amy Chua in her essay "Why Chinese Mothers are Superior", acknowledges the reasons why Chinese mothers are superior in their use of discipline. Chua's purpose is to describe what Chinese mothers do on a daily basis in order for their kids to succeed. She adopts a optimistic tone in order to express her feelings in her informative essay. Chua achieves her purpose through the use of explosive diction. Amy Chua begins with words that are flamboyant to the intended audience. In the first…

Words 283 - Pages 2

Chinese Parenting In William Zinsser's College Pressures

pressures college students face daily. As for Amy Chau’s Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior, which was published in the Wall Street Journal, this article discusses the different parenting styles of Chinese and Western parents. While both articles are similar in many ways, there are many differences amongst them as well. For starters, College Pressures and Why Chinese Mothers…

Words 985 - Pages 4

Happyness or success MLA Essay

Marshal Ma Professor Currey ENG 1A April 1st, 2014 Happiness or Success? Chinese Mothers Choose the Latter Amy Chua, known as “the Tiger Mother”, shocked the world with her book “Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother”, which records how Chua raises her children in a stereotypically successful way. In her book, Chua mentions that her two daughters, Sophia and Lulu, have a list of things that they are never allowed to do including attending a sleepover, having a play date…

Words 1702 - Pages 7

Essay on Chinese Mom superior Mom

Response to Amy Chua’s “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior”. “You are so smart; you can achieve anything you want.” This was a common mantra in my house… at least when it came to me. It seems that I had set the bar for myself pretty high, walking at nine months and reading by the age of five. My brother, on the other hand was precocious in a different way, testing the limits of his physical body instead of stretching his mental muscles. The expectations for each of us were completely different. Thinking…

Words 1110 - Pages 5

Essay on Immigration Success

The Chinese Success Why are Asian children the smartest in school? It is because of their mothers. The stereotypical Asian mother wants the best for her children. She wants them to have the best grades and to be the best in everything. Well, that is not a stereotypic. This is true. In Amy Chua’s article “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior,” she describes what she does to make sure that her children keep on top and be the best at everything they do. Many people believe that her parenting method…

Words 877 - Pages 4

Cultural Universals Between United States and China Essay examples

has its specific culture and there are some obvious cultural universals between China and America. One example of such cultural universal is the directness of American versus the humbleness of the Chinese people. Another example would be the self independence of the young Americans versus the young Chinese who tend to depend on their parents. What I would like to cover are the holidays observed by United States and China, roles played in the family by husband and wife, parenting styles and conflict…

Words 1076 - Pages 5

Parenting: Parent and International Module Parenting Essay

kid. Well that’s what we think is normal. With “Chinese” parents there is a mindset of the parent that there kid is going to succeed in everything he/she does, and if not they have failed in raising their children like they should. If you have been raised by “Western” parents most of us find that we tag the parenting strategies of “Chinese” parents as mean or taboo. Vice versa, “Chinese” parents believe that their parenting strategies are superior, and that any other way of parenting is obsolete…

Words 397 - Pages 2

The Battle Hymn of Tiger Mother Essay

The Battle Hymn of Tiger Mother Is this a story of how Chinese parents are better at raising kids than Western ones? Is this a story of how a mother is humbled by a thirteen-year-old? But instead, it’s about a bitter clash of cultures and a fleeting taste of glory. This is a warm story about a mother, two daughter, and two dogs. Why was the book named as The Battle Hymn of Tiger Mother? Instead of describing the cruelty or some other bad personalities, The Tiger is the symbol of strength and power…

Words 956 - Pages 4

Hanna Rosin's 'Battle Hymn Of The Tiger Mother'

Several parents believe that their parenting style is superior to others. Amy Chua is an excellent example of a superior parenting style. Chua believes that Chinese parenting is the best compared to alternative styles (219-22). Hanna Rosin’s parenting style contradicts Chua’s style. Rosin believes in a laid back parenting style, and give utmost freedom to her children (222-25). There are several aspects of Chua’s parenting style that many do not agree with. Similarly, there are aspects of Rosin’s…

Words 1289 - Pages 6