Essay on Writing Under Stalin

Submitted By Studyhelp02
Words: 1737
Pages: 7
Open Document
The Comedy of a Non-Comedic Regime

Humor plays an interesting role in The Children of the Revolution by Peter Duncan, as it provides laugh out loud scenes in the context of a terrorizing ruler, while also utilizing comedy to code the underlying idea of Stalin’s horrible authoritarian reign. The uniqueness of this film is the depth of analysis that accompanies the comedy, while sharing many themes with the actual Stalinist era. The film almost forces the viewer to periodically click pause in order to understand the laughter on every level. It is important to note that this movie was released well after the Stalinist regime in 1996, so although the director was in no danger of response from Stalin and or Russia, he accurately portrays the necessary coding and civil life of the period it is set in. This essay will look into the two ways that humor is utilized within the film, from a simple chuckle for the viewer, to an underlying strike against the Stalinist ideals; clearly showing the anti-authoritarian nature of the movie. Initially, the humor in The Children of the Revolution comes as comedic relief for the viewer, but also symbolizes a significant survival skill under the Stalinist regime. During a parent teacher conference, Joan is made aware of a speech that Joe gave in class where he speaks about Stalin in an admiring light. When the teacher implies to Joan that someone may be giving Joe communist ideas, Joan responds, “Ideas? Oh God no…” (Duncan min37) as if she hopes this is not the case. This humor engages the viewer in what is to come, as it symbolizes the whispers of the citizens under Stalin in an amusing way. Even though Joan lives in Australia and there is no reason to hide her beliefs, Duncan chooses to have Joan keep her communism a secret from Joe’s teacher, making Joan represent the citizen who must whisper, while the teacher represents a citizen that would report Joan to the authorities. This brings up a major daily role of the citizens under Stalin, while keeping the topic humorous by making the communist have to hide her beliefs. This skill of not speaking about what you believe in helped many during the Stalinist era, as people who were suspected to be against Stalinist ideas could be arrested or killed. This comedic style within the theme of whispering shows up later in the film as well, when Joe is arrested every single time he spray paints communist comments on a building. Even though Joe wants to be arrested, the theme is still present as it shows that there was little to no forgiveness for being open in ones anti-authoritarian views. Furthermore, comedic relief is utilized once again to address the themes of deception and homo sovieticus among the Russian citizens. When Joan first meets Stalin in Moscow, Stalin prepares for her visit in two main ways. First, he spends ample amounts of time cleaning himself up to look presentable and professional for Joan, and second, Stalin has three of his men act as puppets to convince Joan that Stalin is funny, caring, and a great man. This acting by the three men is a clear example of the deception that took place in Stalinist Russia, as the Stalinist regime promoted and promised that the new government was a great improvement and was the best situation for the people. With Joan representing the Soviet citizens, Stalin tricks her into believing that he is someone he is not, and this only makes Joan love him and his ideas even more. The fact that the three men did exactly as Stalin asked on command, strongly suggests that these men were examples of homo sovieticus, the new soviet people. These men are portrayed as mindless drones with no individuality, performing only what is told of them and enjoying the tasks. This humor comes with an underlying attack at Stalin as well, for the men who represent homo sovieticus are embarrassing, useless, and dumb characters. Moreover, the film employs countless comedic examples of underlying attacks against Stalin
Show More

Related Documents: Essay on Writing Under Stalin

Stalin's Persecution Of Trotsky, Mcneil And Service

beliefs. He writes of Stalin the traitor, an enemy to the noble ideas that prevailed in Russia under the leadership of Vladimir Lenin. It is clear throughout this reading, even with no prior knowledge of Trotsky, that he was a strong supporter of the communism as it stood under Lenin. The narrative of betrayal has personal touches. Stalin’s persecution of all opposition to Stalinism, Trotskyists included, had a significant negative impacted on Trotsky. This is evident in his writing. He paints a picture…

Words 471 - Pages 2

Essay on animal farm

Orwell’s goals in writing Animal Farm was to portray the Russian Revolution of 1917 as one that resulted in a government more oppressive, totalitarian, and unequal than the one it overthrew. Mr. Jones is based on Tsar Nicholas II, who was the last Russian emperor. During his rule, the Russian people experienced terrible poverty and uproar, marked by the Bloody Sunday massacre in 1905 when unarmed protesters demanding social reforms were shot down by Nicholas' army. As the animals under Mr. Jones lead…

Words 791 - Pages 4

Essay Macbeth: Soviet Union and Macbeth

have been found between historical figures and fictional characters. The character “Macbeth” created by William Shakespeare for the play “Macbeth. One of the most easily explainable examples of this would be with previous soviet ruler, Joseph Stalin. Stalin got to power by creating a platform of trust while being the General Secretary. He was extremely close to Lenin and his supporters. As Macbeth was to King Duncan, loyalty and trust to the previous head of power, he eliminated the threats to his…

Words 1206 - Pages 5

Animal Farm and the Russian Revolution - Essay

George Orwell's novel Animal Farm is a great example of allegory and political satire. The novel was written to criticize totalitarian regimes and particularly Stalin's corrupt rule in Russia. In the first chapter Orwell gives his reasons for writing the story and what he hopes it will accomplish. It also gives reference to the farm and how it relates to the conflicts of the Russian revolution. The characters, settings, and the plot were written to describe the social upheaval during that period…

Words 892 - Pages 4

Joseph Stalin Dbq

During the 1930s Stalin gained power over the USSR. In his beginning time as a leader, he ruled with two other people. They each had a particular role in the government. Vladimir Lenin was the overall leader where Trotsky ran the military as a General. As for Stalin, he was lower on the power scale and he was in charge of the job system. When he gained power, he tried to revolutionize the Soviet Union. Stalin’s totalitarian rule changed the agriculture, industries, and culture in the Soviet Union…

Words 1611 - Pages 7

Why Is Leon Trotsky The True Revolutionary

Revolutionary for Russia! Trotsky organized the October Revolution and became leader of it. He was leader of the red guards. He organized and implemented many acts of the revolution. Lenin used Trotsky as an organizer. As organizer he united the group under one cause and with a leadership of one goal- revolution! He was the one who ran the Red Army. That is one reason he is a True Revolutionary. Trotsky was a westerner in ideals which was an ideal of the revolution. He dressed the part of the revolutionary…

Words 504 - Pages 3

MODERN HISTORY SYLLABUS FOR REVISION PURPOSES Essays

text and are on MyOLMC for the Cold War. Have a look at Past HSC Questions for the various units on MyOLMC or go to the Board of Studies Website to investigate past papers. Get a feel for what the questions look like. Have a go at planning and/or writing some examples. Get your friends to Peer Mark. World War 1 In investigating for the source-based study, students shall develop knowledge and skills to respond to different types of sources and relevant historiographical issues related to World War…

Words 995 - Pages 4

Animal Farm Analysis Essay

experiences with Stalinism and totalitarianism during the Spanish Civil War. Orwell successfully portrayed his views of totalitarianism throughout the novel, which depicted major events that took place in the Soviet Union during the Stalin Era. Norman Pereira, writer of “Stalin and the Communist Party in the 1920s,” offers insight and a re-evaluation of the road to totalitarianism and Stalin’s role in the Russian Revolution, which provides a solid background for the historical context laid out in Animal…

Words 2305 - Pages 10

Rhetorical Devices In Animal Farm

A rhetorical device is a technique used in writing that helps the author persuade the reader toward the topic the author is writing about. Rhetorical devices are also used to help the reader identify the argument that the author has and what stance he or she has on it. The novel Animal Farm by George Orwell is a fictional story of a farm that has been taken over by animals and is now run in the form of a dictatorship with total equality for all members. This may seem like a simple story but it has…

Words 844 - Pages 4

Animal Farm Literary Analysis

wanted to free themselves from the humans whom they were slaves to, but once they were free and new leaders were chosen, greed, power, and corruption soon spread throughout the new farm. The animals couldn’t think for themselves. They were trapped under the power of corrupt leaders. The theme that is conveyed through the use of literary elements is that large masses of people will be blind to the cruel and selfish acts of their beloved dictator. An allegory is a symbolic fictional narrative that conveys…

Words 1143 - Pages 5