Why should Atticus not defend someone who is guiltless? Atticus took the case and defended Tom even though he knew that his chances of winning remained slim. However, he showed significant evidence to prove Tom innocent. He drew from the mouth of the father that the girl’s left eye was blackened and then continued by having the father sign his name revealing that he utilized his left hand. In addition to this, Atticus showed how Tom’s left hand was crippled. He ultimately concluded that the guilty party was not Tom, but the father. Tom was in a position where a girl was being abused by her father. One day when the father was away, the girl asked Tom to come inside and help her. Her heart was not loved; her mind was not loved; her desire to be loved drove her to kiss Tom. As the father came, Tom saw him and knowing that being near her would end badly for him, he ran. The father entered and beat up his own daughter. In order to hide it, he accuses Tom of raping