Birthright Citizenship

Words: 689
Pages: 3
Open Document
Many countries like Argentina, Mexico, Canada, and Pakistan practice Jus Soli, which means that is a right to give the citizenship or nationality of the country and state to those new born. But, the dysfunction of the current US Immigration System has resulted millions of illegal or unauthorized immigrants in the country. Many people suggested to solve the problem of illegal immigration by reinterpreting or changing the fourteenth amendment to the US constitution to eliminate birthright citizenship. However, those who suggest such change encourage those illegal immigrants to remain in the US. Not only, but for this reason the United States Fourteenth Amendment does not have to be changed because it could dramatically affect the country. Since …show more content…
Immigrants has been always a concern to the US because Americans think immigrants are dangerous, rapists, drug dealers, violent, etc., and the most common reason for a lot of immigrants to come to the US is either to work or give birth and that will not decrease the number of illegal aliens; unlike the problem will keep growing. Conversely, Linda Chavez express on page 594, paragraph 3 “Repealing birthright citizenship is a terrible idea. It will unquestionably jeopardize the electoral future of the GOP by alienating Hispanics—the largest minority and fastest-growing segment of the U.S. population.” Since Hispanics is the largest group of people in the US, it will highly impact the electoral future. Ending birthright citizenship will affect more to the US than to …show more content…
The Fourteenth Amendment provides: “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.” Which applies to a person who was entirely native to the United States, not the citizen or subject of any foreign government. However, Linda Chavez mention in page 595, paragraph 7 the following: “"The amendment, in clear words and in manifest intent, includes the children born within the territory of the United States of all other persons, of whatever race or color, domiciled within the United States," wrote Justice Horace Gray for the majority.” Meaning that it does not matter where your parents come from, if you born within the US you have the American citizenship. Lastly, the 14th Amendment extremely expanded the protection of civil rights to all Americans and is cited in more litigation than any other
Show More

Related Documents: Birthright Citizenship

Birthright Citizenship In America

Lately, there has been many changes due to our new president, Donald Trump. One of the main changes is about birthright citizenship. So many life’s have already been changing because of him recently; for building the wall on the Mexican American border. Many people fear that he will be targeting how he will handle the immigration and change what it means to be an American. Even though we have our fourteen amendment which is, anyone that’s born in the United States and subject to jurisdiction are…

Words 973 - Pages 4

Essay On Birthright Citizenship

Birthright Citizenship By taking away birth right citizenship there would have to be several reforms on the laws and a repeal of the whole 14th amendment and that’s the least of the problems. If birthright citizenship would be abolished then it would also put a burden on all U.S. citizens. This is because they would no longer be able to prove their citizenship easily and inexpensively. The bigger problems are that immigrants actually help the economy more than hurt it and this would just make it…

Words 556 - Pages 3

Birthright Citizenship Debate

The birthright citizenship is a controversial topic that has caused a debate between the people who are in favor of it and those who do not. According to the author Linda Chavez in her essay called “The Case for Birthright Citizenship,” if birthright citizenship ends, it would change what it means to be an American. Likewise, the author and professor of law Ediberto Roman, in his article “The Proposal to Eliminate Birthright Citizenship Is Long on Attacks, Short on Legality,” says that legally eliminating…

Words 662 - Pages 3

Birthright Citizenship Definition

Birthright Citizenship is a common practice in the U.S. that allows children who were born on the territory of the United States automatically become citizens, regardless of their parents’ legal status at the time. In 1868 the Fourteenth Amendment that states “All person born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside” made the birthright citizenship a part of the Constitution. This practice…

Words 1058 - Pages 5

Birthright Citizenship Research Paper

During his presidential campaign, President Donald J. Trump has called for a reform in birthright citizenship, one that excludes children of illegal immigrants. US birthright citizenship, granted in the 14th Amendment, guaranteed that any child born on American soil is automatically, regardless of his or her parentage, a US citizen. Congress initially passed the amendment after the Civil War in 1868 to ensure children of African American slaves were US citizens. However, as more women flock to the…

Words 722 - Pages 3

Birthright Citizenship Pros And Cons

It means that nowhere in the 14th amendment it states that children of illegal immigrants will become citizens and are going to be given the equal rights as “normal” citizens even though the amendment talks about birthright citizenship just not specifically about birthright citizenships to children of illegal immigrants. It is not fair for those who came to the U.S. the proper way, who did not break the law or…

Words 568 - Pages 3

Revealing Birthright Citizenship Rhetorical Analysis

pg. 596, line 3 - “Repealing birthright citizenship is a terrible idea. It will unquestionably jeopardize the electoral future of the gop by alienating Hispanics-the largest minority and fastest-growing segment of the U.S Population. More importantly, ending birthright citizenship would fundamentally change what it means to be an American.” I think Chavez knows that her audience is white businessmen, who already dislike immigrants, plus she already stated people dislike immigrants. Politicians use…

Words 513 - Pages 3

Birthright Citizenship Should Be Abolished Essay

process far more difficult. Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump has recently proposed an immigration plan where anyone in the United States will not automatically become a U.S. citizen at birth. So now the question arises, should birthright citizenship become abolished to secure the actual interest of “real” Americans, or should we open our doors to even more diversity and peoples from around the world to continue to grow as a nation? This recent proposal from Donald Trump has divided the…

Words 700 - Pages 3

Ending Birthright Citizenship Case Study

Ending birthright citizenship in the United States could increase the number of marginalized, powerless people because it would mean that children born to undocumented immigrants would not automatically become citizens. This could create a population of people who lack legal status and rights, making them more vulnerable to exploitation and discrimination. The consequences of the increase could include; limited access to education and healthcare because without citizenship people may struggle to…

Words 173 - Pages 1

13th Amendment Pros And Cons

damaging. Eliminating birthright citizenship will increase the undocumented population instead of decreasing, which is what Republicans want. Along with this, it is unwise to remove it because the economy will suffer greatly. Not only will it take a 5.7% plunge downhill, but it will also take a great amount of money and time to remove all illegal immigrants and birthright citizenship. In addition, causing complications by having to establish a new system to prove citizenship because birth certificates…

Words 163 - Pages 1