Constitutional Policing

Submitted By Aprilhope
Words: 1361
Pages: 6
Open Document
Constitutional Policing Our text states “The criminal justice system is bound by laws that criminal justice actors must follow. This body of law is known as procedural law. If criminal justice actors violate procedural laws, criminal cases can be "tossed out," and if the violation is serious enough, the criminal justice professional can be held legally responsible.” (Wright, 2012). However, there are many cases that have been in court and many arguments have been fought considering if the law was followed legally and correctly. We have laws that all justice systems must follow to guarantee the safety and rights of all citizens are being followed and not infringed upon in any way.
Our text conveys these guidelines and it is stated that “The Constitution of the United States which was adopted in 1787, is the supreme law of the United States. The Constitution lays out the structure and framework of the government, its powers, and the rights of citizens. No U.S. law is higher than constitutional law. The Bill of Rights conveys the first 10 amendments of the U.S.Constitution” (Wright, 2012). The amendment that we will be investigating will be one of the most important in any justice system which is The Fourth Amendment to the Constitution. This amendment reads: The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable search and seizures, shall not be violate, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things seized. (Wright, 2012).
The case of Weeks v. United States is in regards to the violation of the Fourth Amendment. Weeks was arrested at his place of employment and even though he was not home law enforcement unlawfully entered his home and seized documents which they wanted to use against him in the court of law. The case covers these acts because a warrant was not issued to enter is home or retrieve any documents in regards to the charges he was being arrested on at this point of time. After careful examination of this case this amendment was violated due to unlawful search and seizure by law enforcement. Personal property was taken from the plaintiffs’ home without a warrant and these items were being used against him in the court of law. The court went through several other court cases that had similar issues to determine if a violation had occurred to the plaintiffs’ rights of unlawful search and seizure without a warrant. Upon the findings and dedication of the system that the rights of the people shall not be infringed and upon the courts findings they ruled in the plaintiffs’ favor. His rights had been violated and that the findings and the indictments needed to be reversed using the laws as the foundation of any or new prosecution proceedings could be filed in this case. (Weeks v. United States, 1911).
The case of Silverthorne Lumber Company, Inc. ET AL v. United States is also about the acts of a violation of The Constitutions Fourth Amendment. The facts of law enforcement going to this company and did an illegal search and recovery of documents of the company evading taxes without a search warrant was a violation of the fourth amendment. Court rulings led to the return of the original documents but copies made were not which in fact is illegal as well. However, subpoenas where produced for the company to reproduce these documents and were denied by the company due to they believed their rights had been infringed upon in the previous acts. The courts already had the copies, so in my opinion why were they needed again? Although, these documents could not be produced as evidence due to the illegal prior acts the fact of denial of the company refusing to produce the documents again is what was in question. The fact that this was a corporation and not a sole person the rights of the fourth amendment still apply to all regardless of the title of the
Show More

Related Documents: Constitutional Policing

Gun control in the US Essay

Gun Control in the United States Background In 2010, there are 270 million privately owned guns, which is approximately 27 times the number of Canada’s (James et al). This is because the Second Amendment to the United States’ Constitution states that the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed (“United State Constitution”). However, because firearms can be seen as both self-defense tools and harmful weapons, there are many controversies about the politics of gun control…

Words 565 - Pages 3

Function Of Law

principles that are formed to suite the needs of those deciding its purpose. The role of law for business and society is to provide set rules and procedures that fall within general functions which reflect the position of the people. In various types of governments the law is adjusted to suite the needs of the dictator, its citizens or its elected body as seen fit. In a republic, such as the United States of America, the laws are formed by elected leaders to suite the needs and concerns of the citizens (Republic…

Words 971 - Pages 4

California Crisis Analysis

I believe that the United States political system being in crisis applies to politics in California as well, but with some differences. The major critic of California’s political system is that it is too dependent on “voter-approved rules a regulations” (Anagnoson et al. 8). California may be a republican government—where officials are elected to make decisions for their constituents—but it is also clearly majoritarian as noted by the massive amount of laws and regulations in existence due to Californians…

Words 1485 - Pages 6

History: African American and Booker T. Washington Essay

Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. DuBois were both crusaders of better living standards of the black people in United States. Each of them had different social beliefs which determined their advocacy of the civil rights of Black Americans. Booker T. Washington who was an author acted as a leader and educator of the black American society. On the other hand, W.W.B. DuBois was a civil rights activist, a historian, educator, sociologist, writer, scholar and a leader of the black Americans, and this makes…

Words 666 - Pages 3

Dred Scott Court Case Summary

declared that Scott was still a slave and African American were not to be considered a national citizen of the United States. It had also ruled the Missouri compromise as unconstitutional, which would support the south in its expansion of slavery. “The Dred Scott decision infuriated Republicans by rendering their goal—to prevent slavery’s spread into the territories—unconstitutional” (Corbett et al., 2014). Ultimately, the Dred Scott decision took away from previous provisions that had been made to settle…

Words 1595 - Pages 7

First Amendment Rights Essay example

Schroerlucke 1 Laura Schroerlucke E. Fowler Honors Sophomore English February 24th, 2013 Hate Groups in the United States and First Amendment Rights The First Amendment of the United States Constitution was written to protect the right of freedom of religion and freedom of expression from government interference. Freedom of expression consists of the freedom of speech, press and assembly, the right to petition the government for a redress of grievances, and the implied rights of association and belief ( …

Words 810 - Pages 4

gun control Essay

Summary: Gun-Control Thompson, Price, Mrdjoenovich and Khubchandani on their study called “Reducing Firearm-Related Violence on College Campuses-Police Chiefs’ Perceptions and Practices” show how are guns used on college campuses on the United States. They state that since the attacks of September 11th 2001, this has been a concern for many people because these places are “soft vulnerable targets of terror” and right now there is no information of how these events begin or how are the guns and the…

Words 608 - Pages 3

Marriage Equality Research Paper

Marriage Equality The United States has been a country for over 230 years. In that time, the laws of the nation have been evolving to meet their original intent of equality. Slavery, abolished. Women, granted suffrage. Segregation by race, color, and creed, deemed unacceptable. However, the American people have another hurdle to clear before they can claim to be members of a just society. Voters in multiple states have seen fit to restrict the ability of same-sex couples to seek equal rights…

Words 1055 - Pages 5

When And Why Prohibition Was Passed Essay

A. When and why Prohibition was passed ? The ratification of the Eighteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution which banned the production, transportation, and sale of alcoholic beverages introduced the country into the historical period known as Prohibition. The law was seen to be a cure for the perceived problems in society. Since the colonial period, consumption of alcohol had been so disputatious that whether or not it should be religiously considered as a sin. By the turn of the…

Words 601 - Pages 3

An Analysis Of The State Of Arizona

Cesar Avila Ms. Christine Walsh English 109H 3 December 2012 Editorial, ACLU.org As the “melting pot” of the world, the rich and unique culture of the United States can be attributed to the fusion of traditions and values brought by the waves of immigrants who sought to attain the American dream. President John F. Kennedy once remarked in his book A Nation of Immigrants that “every ethnic minority, in seeking its own freedom, helped strengthen the fabric of liberty in American life...We see…

Words 2348 - Pages 10