Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients Essay

Submitted By chelz144
Words: 1116
Pages: 5
Open Document
Drug testing for welfare recipients
The state of Florida recently headed up a movement that was widespread among the United States highlighting a popular issue, drug testing welfare applicants. Florida proposed that the recipients pay for a drug test to continue to receive benefits and if found positive for drug use the recipient will become ineligible for a year. This movement has been a very politically controversial topic but yet is a hot topic in taxpayer’s minds. Some argue that it is not right to force someone to a drug test or to pay for one when those having to do so are simply asking for public assistance in times of need. Some have even argued it is unconstitutional. However, drug testing recipients would eliminate the people legitimately in need from the people simply using the system to support their bad habits and encourage more people to become productive contributors to society. Two of the government assistance programs that have been repeatedly abused are TANF and MEDICAID.
Temporary Assistance for Needy Families [TANF] gives a like cash amount of money to single parent families and/or unemployed two parent families. The program was originally called Assistance for Dependent Children and was designed to make it easier for women to be stay at home parents. The average recipient of the Temporary Assistance for Needy Family’s program in Florida receives $253 a month for up to five months. With the new law being in place these applicants are now being required to cover the cost of a drug test upon approval of the application. If the drug test comes back positive the applicant is disqualified from receiving the cash benefit for up to one year pending seeking out drug rehabilitation. If the drug test comes back negative the cost of the test is reimbursed and the assistance is provided. According to the state of Florida’s TANF applicants drug test results, from July 2011 to October 2011, 7,030 applicants passed, 32 applicants failed and 1,597 applicants did not provide results” (Sulzberger, par 22). 18 percent of the applicants either didn’t get drug tested or failed, so that’s $412,137 of government money saved a month. That’s a large sum of money to be saved in a four month time span, imagine the amount of money that could be saved a year.
Another government assistance program known as Medicaid has been linked to several drug dealing operations. A dealer illegally distributes illegal drugs for profit, so the income received from doing so isn’t reported and therefore shows them at the zero to low income level. “In 2014, individuals under age 65 (including parents and adults without dependent children) with incomes below 133% of the Federal Poverty Level ($14,500 for an individual in 2011) will become eligible for Medicaid in every state” (“Non-Disabled Adults”). Currently this only applies to adults with dependent children, adults with disabilities and adults aged 65 or older. Medicaid essentially provides cost free medical and cost free prescriptions. Anyone familiar with the drug trade knows that narcotics (prescription drugs) are a huge part of that market. It will be easy for a drug dealer to get their hands on narcotics with Medicaid and ultimately cost free as long as they can act in pain and pull it off in the eyes of a doctor. Once prescribed medications by a doctor its simple and thanks to Medicaid cost free. Drug testing these individuals would eliminate the criminally driven people from using the system to continue in their illegal activities and sales
Arthenia Joyner, a democratic leader in the Florida state senate stated that, ''There are millions of people seeking aid from the state for the first time because they have lost their jobs and they still have children to feed and bills to pay, these people now are having to suffer the indignity of having to undergo a drug test.” This may be true that these “people seeking aid” are coming for the first time to get help but a drug test for
Show More

Related Documents: Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients Essay

Drug Testing Welfare Recipients Rhetorical Analysis

for “Drug Testing Welfare Recipients” In Aljohara Albadi’s essay, she supports drug testing welfare recipients. She offers her thesis - because the welfare programs will not fade for a time, all welfare recipients should get drug testing in order to be qualified for the check. She uses her modest tone to persuade the hostile that welfare recipients should be drug tested. Her starting point is good that if welfare recipients need to pass the drug test for the check, there will be fewer drug users…

Words 699 - Pages 3

Argumentative Essay On Welfare Drug Testing

Welfare recipients losing their benefits over drugs. In 2012 more than one-fifth of the U.S. population, or 52.2 million people, received some kind of means-tested public assistance every month. How many of those recipients do you think are using the assistance for illegal substances? Seven states- Utah, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Missouri, Arkansas, Tennessee, and Mississippi- already initiated the act of drug testing recipients of welfare benefits. This insures they are not under the influence while…

Words 798 - Pages 4

Essay On Welfare Drug Testing

Kimberly Yee, an essayist for the USA Today expressed in her article that “No drug test, no welfare.” Tax dollars are perpetually utilized on welfare and even drug addicts. Therefore, when applying for welfare drug test should be a necessity for state assistance. This project is to avail families who are in need and not to fortify the ones who have addictions. It is a need to change the welfare system. By doing this, it would avail society rely upon their self and not the administration. States…

Words 1376 - Pages 6

Arguments Against Welfare Drug Testing

The first welfare program was started during the Great Depression, to help relieve the suffering people, as a part of Franklin Roosevelt’s “New Deal” (Issues & Controversies). Welfare is government assistance provided to people that need help affording to live. Food stamps, healthcare, and unemployment benefits are only a few forms of welfare. Taxes get taken out of working American’s paychecks to provide these benefits to the poor. In Issues & Controversies article “Welfare Drug Testing: Should the…

Words 572 - Pages 3

Essay On Welfare Drug Testing

Drug testing on Welfare recipients has been a controversial issue in the U.S., both federally and state wide. Recently, two states have mandated the use of suspicion-less drug testing which has been disputed constitutionally. Nonetheless, other forms of drug testing have been allowed to flourish, with the decision being made and guided by the lower courts. (Carpenter, 2015) In order to gain an understanding of the psychology of how drug testing affects the lives of individuals, we must first understand…

Words 1598 - Pages 7

The hazards of drug testing on welfare Essay

2013 The Hazards of Drug Testing for Welfare The establishment of welfare has proven to make a positive influence on thousands of Americans’ lives. The argument that is now surfacing is whether drug testing should or should not be required for welfare recipients. There is cause for pause because both sides to this argument have good view points. Today, each state is given a check by the federal government and is then in charge of distributing the money to each welfare recipient. This is why each…

Words 736 - Pages 3

Essay On Welfare Drug Testing

Welfare Recipients should be required to random drug screenings. Many citizen question where there U.S tax money is going, unfortunately not many know. There's been an ongoing debate on whether welfare recipients should be drug tested. The issue has been brought up time and time again. The main topic of tax money is the use of assistance money and are the recipients using them for the right reasons? The solution to knowing if the assistance money is being used correctly is drug testing the recipients…

Words 556 - Pages 3

Drug Testing Research Paper

Final Research Paper Should Drug Testing Be Required to Receive Welfare Adam Saville ITT Technical Institute November 6, 2015 Research Methods Dr. Thorman Should Drug Testing Be Required to Receive Welfare Introduction At least thirteen states have passed legislation regarding drug testing or screening for public assistance applicants or recipients (Alabama, Arkansas, Arizona, Florida, Georgia, Kansas, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Tennessee and Utah.) Some apply…

Words 1005 - Pages 5

Arguments Against Drug Testing

Florida paid out $118,140 to drug test welfare recipients. That resulted in paying out $45,780 more in tax payer dollars than they would have paid to provide benefits to the 2.6% of beneficiaries that failed the drug test. America has been debating drug testing welfare recipients for years now, some Americans think that screening out drug users will save tax dollars in the long run, while others believe it will only be detrimental in a variety of ways. Drug testing our welfare beneficiaries is unconstitutional…

Words 903 - Pages 4

The Pros And Cons Of Welfare

million people in the United States are on some type of welfare. Welfare is financial support given to those people in need around the country. Research showed the good and bad parts of the welfare system. The welfare system in the United States is continuing to grow over the years. The government should legally be able to mandate drug testing to welfare recipients. To get on welfare you have to meet the basic qualifications required. The recipient must be 18 years old, you must be a citizen of the United…

Words 2036 - Pages 9