In the short story Ichabod attempts to use his …show more content…
Ichabod’s over-imagination not only leads to his gullibility and credulity, but also to his downfall. After the party, Bones presumably follows Ichabod on horseback, acting as the headless horseman. When he encounters Ichabod he throws a pumpkin at him. The rest is a mystery for the reader to presume, as we are only told that Ichabod was spotted years later working as a judge. Brom Bones was able to use Ichabod’s grand imagination against him, ultimately driving him out of the village, and securing Katrina Van Tessel for himself. Milne claims, “Because he [Ichabod] does not understand that the story of the headless horseman is just a story, he is easy prey for Brom” (145). Similarly, Theodore concurs with Milne suggesting, “Ichabod is also a very gullible individual who believes in the supernatural, thus providing his opponent with the weapon that will destroy him” (Theodore 1210). Both writes agree that Ichabod’s over-imagination leads to his