From Security to Sovereignty Essay

Submitted By Gazelle1
Words: 1167
Pages: 5
Open Document
From Security to Sovereignty: The Canadian Arctic, from Strategic to Economic Interests

Introduction

This short essay will focus, analyze and provide concrete examples of the mutations of the reasons behind Canada’s motivations to gain sovereignty over the Arctic from 1945 until today. I will attempt to highlight the similarities and/or differences in Canada’s needs and /or interests in protecting the Arctic. I will hopefully reflect some of the key evolutions to the Canadian Military, which were directly link to the Arctic sovereignty. I will describe the two periods, followed by an individual analysis or comparison and end with a conclusion. All will be supported by the appropriate footnotes and bibliographies references as required.

First Description: The Cold War

The “Cold War”[i] was the continuing state of conflict, tension, and competition that existed after World War II. The Cold War began in the mid-1940s and lasted into the early 1990s. When made clear that the Arctic would be of strategic importance to both Superpowers. Especially, after the testing of Nuclear weapons by the Soviet, it was evident that Western security was at risk. Therefore National security demanded action. Canada lacking the resources to do so on its own was essentially forced to join “NORAD”[ii]. Canada’s need and interests dictated an Arctic patrol program was required. With its neighbor and solid ally, they establish 3 radar networks including the “DEW”[iii] line. At sea, the Navy generally decreased as the Cold War progressed, no ice breaker until 1954 and reduced to sporadic warship patrol into the Arctic during the summer. The idea of acquiring nuclear submarines surfaced a few times but usually dissipated quickly. The role of Canadian submarine in those waters during that period was nearly nonexistent.

Second Description: After the Cold War

The period following the Cold War is often referred to un-imaginatively as the “Post cold War”.[iv] Since the late 90’s the role of Canadian Submarine in the Arctic waters patrol has changed. With the aging fleet of Oberon class submarine, the Canadian Government and the Royal Canadian Navy had to make tough decisions and choices. This culminated in 1998 with “Lease/buy” arrangement of 4 United Kingdom “Upholder/Victoria Class”[v] diesel-electric submarines. This Strategic weapon was crucial for Canada’s ability and aspiration to eventually cut its ties to its giant neighbor to the south on its Arctic Defense Policy. Moreover, this provided Canada with a capable offensive power capability in terms of its effect on other countries behavior when dealing with our sovereignty. As displayed in the 1995 Spain fisheries confrontation. This acquisition brought Canada into a select group of countries possessing this asset also allowing us more say as well demonstrated by the development of the Water space Management Agreement. This instant and others help assure Canada’s sovereignty and control over its policy in the Arctic in the process.

Analysis

The major differences between the Cold War and the Post Cold War period when it comes to Canada’s needs and/or Interests in protecting the Arctic were substantial. During the Cold War era, other than the occasional foot or air patrol, not much resource was ever dispensed by the Canadian Government. On the other hand during the Post Cold War, Canada realized the importance of the Arctic to his sovereignty and international status as a player. The role played by the Canadian submarines in the Arctic waters patrol is one of irony is that the one ocean to which it has the greatest difficulty sailing is the Arctic Ocean. While it can deploy and maintain almost all its ships off the coast of any country for extended periods of time, it has almost no ability to maintain a presence in Canada’s third ocean. Throughout most of the Cold War, Canada left the protection of the Arctic Ocean to its allies. During the
Show More

Related Documents: From Security to Sovereignty Essay

AOS 2 CHINA REVISION Essay

military power: troop deployments, militarisation, strategic placement of armaments KEY TERMS Sovereignty – Legitimate or widely recognised ability to exercise effective control of a territory within recognised borders. Primary organising principle of global politics, which provides states with the authority to represent their territorial entity within the international community. State sovereignty can be challenged internally (for example, secessionist groups) or externally (for example, one state…

Words 449 - Pages 2

A Discussion Upon the Vying Perceived Importance of Soverign Rights Versus Human Rights Essay

Sovereign Rights. Where in the past Sovereign Nations have enjoyed complete discretion over their actions towards their own citizens and inhabitants, the adherence to ratified Human Rights has challenged the primacy of the State in matters of National Security and self-determination. Matters concerning the State such as counter-terrorism and the treatment of citizens now must be handled with deference to established human rights, an issue of controversy causing the global community to debate the question:…

Words 2704 - Pages 11

Comparing The Film 'Security, Liberty, And The Myth Of Balance'

In “Security, Liberty and the Myth of Balance: Towards a Critique of Security Politics” by Mark Neocleus page 134, under “Security, Sovereignty Prerogative” the quote I believe summarized the whole argument of the idea of a balance between security and liberty is “The search for security is thus the driving force behind the creation of absolute sovereignty, derived in turn from the supposed absolute liberty of the individual in the state of nature.” If you don’t put any restriction in liberty, how…

Words 475 - Pages 2

Essay On Sovereignty In Singapore

internally and externally. Singapore is no different. From 1965 up to now, Singapore has grown to be a stable nation state. Internally, the challenges could be famine, riots and a coup. Externally it could be terrorism and war. All these could lead to undermine the sovereignty of nation-states. Firstly, what is sovereignty? What makes a country sovereign? The most basic concept of identifying sovereignty would be borders, population, legitimacy and security. Having borders around a country would let other…

Words 1005 - Pages 5

Outline: International Relations and Sovereignty Positive- Capabilities Essay examples

are more effective when they operate from an organization base- states, international organizations, or nongovernmental Organizations 2. Define sovereignty and list the four criteria that define a state. Sovereignty- the quality of having supreme, independent authority over a geographic area Territory Population Government control of territory and populations Legitimacy 3. Explain the evolution of the international world system, from the Treaty of Westphalia to present-day…

Words 847 - Pages 4

Is Intervention Ever Justified?

and liberty, while keeping cooperative security. Cooperative security has four points’ transnationalism, integration, collective action, and democratic peace theory. In other words cooperative security is trying to seek greater relations among states, while intertwining other states economies and working together for a greater benefit than one state would receive by acting alone. From a liberalist point of view intervention is needed if cooperative security cannot be maintained, as well as for individual…

Words 1327 - Pages 6

Pros And Cons Of Preemptive Intervention

state’s territorial integrity and political sovereignty, it must act right away or it will have no chance to act later” (Nye 212). Legitimate preemptive intervention as described by Nye should only be used if the threat to one’s state’s sovereignty is imminent. As long as the threat is imminent preemptive intervention is legitimate, but if the threat is not imminent and preemptive intervention is used then the intervention is a violation to a state’s sovereignty because there is no immediate need for…

Words 1602 - Pages 7

Geography: United Nations and Sacred Space Essay examples

of collective responsibility to pursue peace and security still makes equal sense for the strong and the weak countries of the world. I believe it does. The weak want to know that if they're threatened by another country the international community will not be indifferent. The powerful know that even if they had the resources to wage war successfully against any potential aggressor state, it would be better to spare those resources if their security and national interest could be indubitably protected…

Words 1055 - Pages 5

Hobbes: Political Philosophy and Sovereign Essay

What does absolute sovereignty mean for Hobbes and why does he think it necessary? Thomas Hobbes, an English philosopher, felt that society naturally resembles a State of Nature, and that this State of Nature is a State of War. A State of Nature is “the condition where we are forced into contact with each other in the absence of a superior authority”. In order to avoid living in a State of Nature, and therefore avoiding a State of War, a sovereign had to be erected; the sovereign would be given…

Words 1609 - Pages 7

Essay on State Is Losing Its Sovereignty

possibly be. The state has been defined in many ways: one where it is described as an ancient political community that uses security as an economic exchange in order to gain revenue. The state has also been described as the government and even a protection racket. A state is entirely made up of the society, government as well as the people residing in that area. Sovereignty can simply be defined as power or authority. It is the ability of a state to act independently in a geographic area. The principle…

Words 1503 - Pages 7